Enlightened~Sista

[Executive]

Is it halal to sleep with a girl as long as you have good intentions.

[Shirib]

War gabarta iska dhaaf

[Firefly]

Istaqfurillah. What kind of question is this?

[Haddad]

Istaqfurillah. What kind of question is this?

A valid one. Apparently, it's OK with some Muslims (i.e. moderate, liberal, progressive, etc) to sleep with a girl as long as they have good intentions.

[RebelLion]

And this guy wants an islamic state of somalia....?

[934]

If a piano fall on CY and kill him right on the spot, does that make him a shaahid?

[Padishah]

Enlightend Sista is none of those things. Justify, then, how it is a valid question Haddad.

[Advo]

Valid Question.......seeing how that "free-spirited" girl justifies almost everything Islam forbidz, she will most like answer!

"It's ok, aslong as ur planning to marry her"

[Gatspy]

A valid one. Apparently, it's OK with some Muslims (i.e. moderate, liberal, progressive, etc) to sleep with a girl as long as they have good intentions.

Thats absurd dude, this is sinners trying to justify their sins. lool @ good intentions.

If a piano fall on CY and kill him right on the spot, does that make him a shaahid?

Thats a tick question. There r no pianos in Somalia.

[Firefly]

Istaqfurillah. What kind of question is this?

A valid one. Apparently, it's OK with some Muslims (i.e. moderate, liberal, progressive, etc) to sleep with a girl as long as they have good intentions.

Has Enlightened~Sista said this? Do you have any proof for your claim?

[Haddad]

Has Enlightened~Sista said this? Do you have any proof for your claim?

This is about the validity of the question, not what Enlightened~Sista said or might have said.

[Shirib]

Waryaada stop picking on Enlightened Sista

[934]

Playing word games.

[Advo]

Waryaada stop picking on Enlightened Sista

Well if she kept her deviant thoughts on Islamic Manners to herself, no one would pick on her.

[Firefly]

Has Enlightened~Sista said this? Do you have any proof for your claim?

This is about the validity of the question, not what Enlightened~Sista said or might have said.

This is not a valid question by a long mile, how can you even suggest that a Muslim would approve zina? You're claiming that she would somehow endorse this viewpoint, so the onus is on you to provide proof that she even suggested or hinted at something like that.