Can Somalia resist without AMISOM?

[PureQ]

Lets say if AMISOM leaves completely tomorrow, can Somalia resist or will Al Shabaab steamroll Somalia and why?

[Strategic]

they can resist for a while but
-SNA soilders are not paid well.
-health facility is not available
-no equipment to win a war

but things will change soon.

[Halmogg]

Definitely they will regain lost territories very quickly, they can't even pay 100 bucks a month to the poorly equiped "SNA solidier" who is just a tribal militia while a fufu is earning $$ chilling in the barracks.

[Strategic]

many of the fighting by AMISOM is done by poorly paid SNA and AMISOM Just come for second aid that is a fact.when our corrupt leaders give salary to our Soilders and equip them like any other country then we can say yes,that day will come but it has to wait for now.

[theyuusuf143]

Things will not change any time Soon without changing your self. Wanlaweyn should do this

1. Mogadishu revenues should be used to cover banadir security. With That money you can recruite as much Hawiye Soldiers as you can make it 50 or 100 thousand. Mogadishu revenues should NEVER be used to cover the cost of the villa Somalia and those useless 4.5 representatives in it. Bosaso and kismayo are not contributing the federal treasury why would you contribute.Mogadishu ma Timor xabaal taal baa hadii dadka kaleba aanay ogolaym inay cashuur siiyaan federal ka maxaa diidaya haduu abgaalna wixiisa gaar maamusho.

2. Stop begging foreign troops Every federal member state should have at least 5000 Members in the SNA and each state must pay the Salaries of their Divisions. Don't tell me that hawiye can't pay 20 thousand federal Soldiers. Yes you can do it.
3. All you need is Several hundred Technicals, and good supply of Canbuulo, khat and khamri you can Invade countries let alone karbaashing several Alshabaab teenagers. You don't need any fancy looking dress, modern weapons or any thing else.


That's how we do In Somaliland.

[GIJaamac]

Yes, if SNA soldiers get their monthly salary. Both AMISOM and Al-shabaab are hugely overrated.
Al-shabaab are not liked by the civilians anymore like they were back in 2007-2009 and they don't have enough financial resources nor footsoldiers to capture whole southern Somalia.

[Django]

Since when did Kismaayo or Bosaaso receive taxes from Xamar?

[Kudo]

SNA don't exist so Alshabab would steamroll FG. What people call "SNA" are bunch of criminals trained in xamar trying to take over resources from locals so building a credible SNA is not something that will happen soon. A solution is everyone defends their city&towns. This is where things are headed with training of more local militias.

[theyuusuf143]

Since when did Kismaayo or Bosaaso receive taxes from Xamar?

Unlike kismayo and Bosaso Mogadishu give tax to the federal government. A government consisting all clans including yours. My point is reer banaadir have the rights to not give a penny to the federal government. If I don't pay my 30 something iidoor MPs chilling in xamar, if you don't pay your cagdheer ones. Why those Canbuulo eating donkeys are giving what little they have to that Fat ass prime minister and his Cabinet???

[Django]

Mps are paid by UN not xamar tax.
The taxes in xamar do not pass Villa Somalia.

Secondly what ever is got from Xamar is from IC.The only thing HAG can share with you is bullets.

[mahoka]

Xayawaanka habar jeclo doesn't understand that salaries are paid by international organisation and nothing to do with one region Giving tax.

[AbkoowDhiblaawe]

Yes if there is working instituions, SNA given their salaries and other rights they deserve etc. But it aint gonna happen. Zoomalis depends on IC hooyadod ha wasane. Fock IC and do Iska wax uu qabso.

[theyuusuf143]

Xayawaanka habar jeclo doesn't understand that salaries are paid by international organisation and nothing to do with one region Giving tax.

I am well aware of that. At the other hand I am 100% Sure that all Mogadishu port and airport revenues goes to the Somalia ministry of finance. Local banadir government does not get that much.

[AbkoowDhiblaawe]

Xayawaanka habar jeclo doesn't understand that salaries are paid by international organisation and nothing to do with one region Giving tax.

I am well aware of that. At the other hand I am 100% Sure that all Mogadishu port and airport revenues goes to the Somalia ministry of finance. Local banadir government does not get that much.

It's true unfortunately. The local banaadir admin gets 20%. On the other hand Boosaso and Kismayo dont pay shit to SFG. If there is a non Hawiye president in 2016 i will lobby that Banaadir doesn't pay even one shilling to the new SFG. I have good connections and i'm reer mataan.

[cheifaqilbari]

Mohinka why is being qabalist man ka xisbood tolka HJ or any other Northern reer is the same for us ninyow naga daa dambiga. Allah mayck.