FarIyoAlif wrote:X.Playa wrote:Your so called people have no authors , these are clan probagandist who recorded Daarood fairy tales , thats not history. History needs citations and references and your clannnist Idaajaa and Aw Jaamac have non of that. so they all quoted these guys above and they intentionaly misquoted them or selectivly quoted them .
so x.playa your whole argument is based on what the british wrote nothing else, you are saying the Darawiish were like the modern day al shabaab (bear in mind that you are not even muslim and you said insult the prophet pbuh publicly), you spew your clannist filth against the Daarood day in day out, you exclude daarood authors completely from your evidence and you only acknowledge the stuff that was written by the cadow gaal that unlawfully occupied your homeland for more than century but ofcourse you don't see it that way you see the Daarood as your enemy and the white man as your brother. teeda kale what i don't understand is that you are telling us the Daraawiish were mainly made up of Isaaq, yet the Isaaq territories at that time were occupied by none other than the same enemy the Isaaq (darawiish) were fighting against

it doesn't add up. Everyone knows that the Harti or the Ogadeen were not all supporters of the Darawiish movement but they did make up the majority and I'm not denying the fact that there were some Isaaq Darawiish. Until you tell the truth about the Darawiish this thread will not prove anything and all your posts will be taken as a pinch of salt.
There is nothing new in Idaajaa , Aw Jaamac , or Abdi Sheekh`s book divine Madness. They are just a regurgitations of what has been written and recorded by the Italians and British, the only difference is the Daarood injected many fictious personas into that record , like Ismaaciil Mire , while downplayed many great non-Daarood dervish.
I have not claimed any where that the Dervish were Isaaq , what i argued was the top leaders from 1899-1904 were mostly H.J , H.Y and most of the top Daarood dervish were Ogadeen Bà-Geri and Cali Geri. The foot soldiers of the Dervish were made of all somali tribes, take for example the first battle March 1900 at Jigjiga. Your clannist Idaajaa and Aw Jaamac claimed they were mostly Ogaadeen, but the British, French, and Italians during those early years stated the war in jigjiga was fought by:
1- Ogadeen
2- Sheekhaal
3- Gedabursi
4- Oromo.
you see the difference, your Daarood always cleansed non-Daarood from history. and make no mistake am not pro-dervish in any shape or form , am of the healthy opinion that their destruction and extermination was a good thing.