Proud Muslimah - here's our continued thread

[Steeler [Crawler2]]

"Mad Mac, as mentioned before the duty of previous nations was to preserve their scripture, which was specific only to THEIR nation. The duty of the Muslims is not to preserve their scripture, since Allah has vowed to do that, but instead to spread its message to all people! Allah (SWT) has vowed to preserve the Qur'an because the Qur'an is for all humanity whereas the other scriptures was ONLY for a specific NATION!"

OK again, this makes absolutely no sense. Prior to Mohammed God was a nationlist who provided some nations with Gods laws and left others adrift? But after Mohammed the message becomes internationalist? Come on, that's just ridiculous.

"This has to do with the whole testing thing again Mad Mac as was answered in the other thread! Concerning the pre-ordained part, I have already mentioned about that in SomaliSizz thread! "

You answer it, but your answer is insufficient. Let me explain again. You can't say this is a test, while at the same time the test results are pre-ordained and the test is rigged. God knows the outcome, has created the beings the way they are, and created the "test conditions". In short, he controls the ENTIRE process. Therefore, there is no free will. You can't set the conditions and the results, and then say it's free will. Those things are not compatiable. If this is a test, then we can not have been created by God and he can not know the outcome - that means we didn't come from God and God does not know the future. If you say we did come from God, and he does know the future, then you CAN'T logically claim this is a test.

Posted: 30 Aug 2005 23:57 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Peace,

Mad Mac, as mentioned before the duty of previous nations was to preserve their scripture, which was specific only to THEIR nation. The duty of the Muslims is not to preserve their scripture, since Allah has vowed to do that, but instead to spread its message to all people! Allah (SWT) has vowed to preserve the Qur'an because the Qur'an is for all humanity whereas the other scriptures was ONLY for a specific NATION!

"If God knew that job was not going to succeed, then why did he give it to people in the first place. If you say, well he gave it to people but they failed so he had to take it, then I ask you - didn't he know that in the first place?"

This has to do with the whole testing thing again Mad Mac as was answered in the other thread! Concerning the pre-ordained part, I have already mentioned about that in SomaliSizz thread!

""Again I am not making myself clear here. 1,500 years ago there were plenty of people on the Earth who didn't get the message. Why? If the message is important, and Gods laws are important, then why give it to some but not all?"

And Again, it's the people DUTY to spread the Message of Allah (SWT)! "

OK, who's duty was it to spread the word of Allah to the Phillipines in the year 500 AD?

[Steeler [Crawler2]]

Proud you still out there?

[Steeler [Crawler2]]

Proud
Were you living in New Orleans or something? Where did you go?