     JAMA | Unrecorded Date
CAN ANYONE TELL ME WHY WE PRAY TARAWEEH JAMAA WHILE OUR PROPHET MUHAMMAD (saw) DID NOT DO SO? WHERE DID WE GET THAT AUTHORITY? IS NOT AGAINST THE TEACHINGS OF ISLAM NOT FOLLOW THE PROPHET AND FOLLOW SAY UMAR(AS)?
THE PROPHET NEVER USED MICROPHONE IN THE MASJID TO CALL THE PRAYERS OR TO MAKE THE QUDBA NOR DID HE USE CARPETS ON THE FLOOR OF THE MASJID TO PERFORM THE PRAYER.
IS IT XARAAM TO PRAY JAMA'A IN NIGHT SUNNA PRAYERS IN THE HOLY MONTH OF RAMADAN? NO IT IS NOT----JUST AS IT IS NOT HARAAM TO PERFORM PRAYERS IN THE MASJID WHILE THERE IS A CARPET ON THE FLOOR WHEN MAKING SUJUUD.
TRAWIIX PRAYERS ARE SUNNA---YOU CAN DO IT IF YOU WANT AT HOME WITH YOUR FAMILY----AT THE MASJID WITH OTHER BROTHERS AND SISTERS IN ISLAM---OR YOU DO NOT HAVE TO PERFORM IT ALL TOGETHER IF YOU DO NOT WANT TO---IT IS NOT HARAAM TO DO IT IN ANYWAY YOU WANT--WITH JAMA'A OR ALONE---OR NOT DO IT AT ALL. :-) |
| allaale | Unrecorded Date
TARAAWIIXDU waa suno wuuna tukaday nabigu s.c.w gurugiisa waxaa kulatakaday rag saxaabo ah.
tan masjiddkana waxaa sameeyay cumar binu khadaab r.c cumarna wa khulafaa'u rashidiin nabigu wuxuu yri s.c.w calaykum bisunatii wsunatul khulafaa'u raashidiin al mahdiyiin.raaca wadadayda iyo wadada khalafadayda hanuunsan. |
| bacaac | Unrecorded Date
what is this all about????????
are you defending or going against???????? |
| Walaalkiin | Unrecorded Date
Nabad iyo Naxariis Ilaahay Korkiina Ha Ahaato
Munaafaq Ilaahay iyo Rasuulkiisa Ka Furtay sow ma tihid oo marba magac la bixi. Soo Adigii ma aha walaalahu ku kashifeen ma tihid markii aad Jamac la baxday oo aad mooday in uu kuu dhaamo ama aad ku gaban kartid Ahmad.
Maxaad ka sheegi Taraawiix waxaadba ka goosatay Ilaahay oo aad isku dayday in aad bedesho Hadalkiisa. Miyaadan maqal Ilaahay oo Leh:
"Laa Mubadila Li Kalimaati Allahi Walan Tajida Min Duunihi Multaxadan" Maxaanse uga daalay saa Ilaahay Baaba Xiray Laabtaada oo waxaad tahay MUNAAFAQE.
Ilaahayow Isagoo Kale Naga Kori.
Ilaahayow Noo Naxariiso |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
Walaalkiin, you are mistaking. Jama is not Ahmed. Ahmed Munaafaq waa yahay. Jamacna ma ka soo horjeedo Sunada. Marlabaad aqri waxa aan qorey kor. Waxaan difaacaayaa in Taraawiixda ay suna tahay oo lagu tukan karo Jamaaca anigoo u jawaabaayo kii su'aasha soo jeediyey ama furey halkaan. Aniga ma aha ninka furey halkaan, walaalkiin. |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
bacaac, i didn't start this forums. |
| Dulli_diid | Unrecorded Date
Jaamacoow, ha maleynin dadka inay maskaxda la'yihiin. Walaalkey ayaa runta sheegay waxaad taahy Ahmedkii la garanaayay ee waxba ha is qarin. Qaabka aad luuqada ingriiska ugu hadleysid ayaaba laga garanayaa except u used all caps this time. Mana ila aha qof Muslim ah oo dhahaya Cumar miyaa la raacaa mise nabiga inuu aduunyada jiro ee doqonimada kala tag. Su'aasha jawaab umaba baahna maxaa yeelay adiga ayaaba cadeeyay oo Cumar inuu bilaabay sunadaas meeshaas ayey ka cadahay. Is waydii naftaada imisa suno ayaa laga dhaqmaa oo waagii nabiga aanan jirin? Yaa baneeyaay? Ogoow inay irida wali furantahay cidii wanaag Islaamka u haysa. Nabiga s.c.w wuxuu yiri "MAN SANNA SUNATAN XASANTAN FALHU AJRUHAA WAJRU MAN CAMILA BIHAA" |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
I don't care you think I'm someone else or not. :-)
Once again, I didn't start this topic and i did not say "Cumar miyaa la raacaa mise nabiga"
STUPID IS WHAT STUPID DOES-------> "doqonimada kala tag". :-) |
| Bille Samatar | Unrecorded Date
Dear Jama thanks for responding to my question.Carpets and microphones have no rules but taraweeh has regulations which have to be followed and the instructions of the prophet (saw) was that it should be prayed at home and not jammaa.That is why Abubakar(as) never prayed it jamaah.If you have facts to dispute what i have said then forward them please but not the cheap ones like comparing religious regulations with microphones and carpets. Your brother in Islam. |
| Bashir Abdi. | Unrecorded Date
Dullidiid.
Jama is not AHMED. I argued him before for being AHMED and he said he is not. Simple as that. |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
Bille, the point you missed is that trawiix is a sunnah, not a farad.
Is it xaraam to do the trawiix at anywhere else? What about if trawiix is not prayed at all, does that mean one committed a sin?
You said trawiix has regulations which have to be followed and the instructions of the prophet (saw) was that it should be prayed at home, but do you have facts to back up this law-----that no one can pray trawiix at the masjid with other brothers and sisters.
I think you need to bring forth evidence; otherwise, you are just making up things.
Facts to dispute is this: The prophet never said in anywhere that trawiix should be prayed ONLY at home.
There is no evidence in any xadiis that says the prophet said you should NOT perform the trawiix prayers at masjids with jamaaca.
If the prophet said such things, UMAR would not have done it at the masjid with jamaaca.
Therefore, it is not xaraam to do it in Masjids with jamaaca, at home, at offices with jamaca--two, three, four or twenty brothers and sisters.
What Mr. Bill should keep in mind is that in Islam, whatever is not forbidden by Allah or by the prophet is not xaraam.
There is such thing called FARAD and SUNNA and OTHERS which are not xaraam or xalaal.
The prophet never prayed in an airplane, does that mean if one should perform his or her prayers in an airplane, the prayers are not counted? |
| Bille Samatar | Unrecorded Date
Dear brother Jama to follow what the Prophet(SAW) did is Sunna and rewarding.Please can you answer my question why diD Abubakar(as) not pray taraweeh jamaah? The answer to this question is the key to what iam talking about.My intention is not to create confusion but to gain knowledge.To follow what the Prophet did is what makes a good muslim and not our own inventions. To pray in an aeroplane the Prophet did not pray in an aeroplane because aeroplane were not there,but taraweeh was there and the PROPHET(saw) prayed it alone and so did Abubakar(as).So instead of coming with cheap comparisons please bring some facts to support your case.Inventions are not permitted in our religion.IN SAYING THAT PLEASE GIVE ME EVIDENCE TO CONVINCE ME OTHERWISE. |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
"Please can you answer my question why diD Abubakar(as) not pray taraweeh jamaah? The answer to this question is the key to what iam talking about."
I think I answered the question.
Let me make your confusion very clear for you:
Say, if Abubakar(RA) did not pray traawix in jamaaca and Umar did it in jamaaca and I do not even do it at all, did I commit sin?
What I'm saying is that, if Umar didn't SAY that Abubakar was wrong to have not done the traawiix in jamaaca, then Umar knew himself that he didn't do anything wrong by doing traawiix in jamaaca.
Both Umar and Abubaker and even the Prophet did not say if YOU do not do the traawiix ALONE, you commited sin.! They didn't even say if you do not do the trawiix at all, you committed SIN.
If YOU are saying that Umar committed BIDCA--INNOVATION, you are saying Umar LEAD himself and other Muslims in HELL, for every BIDCA is DALAALA and every DALAALA can lead to HELL FIRE.
So, Bille, do you know that Umar was in the company of the CASHARA MUBASHIRIIN.
Get this, Bill, Umar did NOT do "INNOVATION"--(BIDCA)
I asked YOU BILLE to bring an evidence in xadiis where the prophet said YOU CAN'T PREY TRAAWIIX IN JAMAACA.
However, BILLE, YOU FAILED to produce ANY EVIDENCE-----So, like I said, you are making up things and creating confusion in your mind. |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
"To pray in an aeroplane the Prophet did not pray in an aeroplane because aeroplane were not there"
Even if airplanes were existed during the prophet's time and the prophet did his prayers in airplanes, BUT I do not my prayer in airplanes, for whatever reasons, and instead I do my prayers in submarine under water, I did not commit SIN.! |
| Bille Samatar | Unrecorded Date
Dear Jama because of the unsatisfactory answers which you gave me and the techiques of avoiding the real question i have decided to do my own research regarding this topic.May Allah show me the real truth.AMIIN |
| JAMA | Unrecorded Date
Yes, my dear Bille. I understand that you are not satisfied.
I told you that UMAR DID NOT DO BIDCA.
What I told you confused you. You made up lies about UMAR. You said Umar made a BIDCA.
If you had EVIDENCE to back up your LIES about UMAR MAKING BIDCA, you would have presented when asked about it.
So, go ahead and do your "own research regarding this topic"----but know though that---you will NEVER find any where in the xadiis where UMAR MADE BIDCA. |
| muslim sister | Unrecorded Date
Salaamku alaykum
to Jama
wallaal waxaan ku gu waaninayaa Illaahay cabsidiisa iyo inaad is ka illaaliso waxyaabaha aad ku had laysid, maanta adduun ayaad joogtaa laakiin bari aaqiro waxaad aduunka kutiri waalagula xisaabtamayaa. diintana baro waayo jahli qatar ayuu ku galinayaa |
