site-wide search

SomaliNet Forums: Archives

This section is online for reference only. No new content will be added. no deletion either...

Go to Current Forums ...with millions of posts

PUNTLAND AND SOMALIA

SomaliNet Forum (Archive): RA'YIGA DADWEYNAHA - Your Opinion: Somalia: Archive (Before October 29, 2000): PUNTLAND AND SOMALIA
Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Cabdirisaaq Maxamed

Saturday, October 14, 2000 - 08:39 pm
Brothers and sister of the Somali nation i greet you in peace.And i pray Allah that he bring us back to our sense.So that we sit back and refect and construct our future in an intellegent way.i have being reading what some of you posted.And it seems that most of you are driven by stessful emotion and the blind suport for your clans.Even raakiya Oomar could not stay away from clan based talks.I can say few positive things about R.Oomar.She is beautiful and the first time i saw her in the televition i admired her.Here is a young Somili girl working as an international newscaster,though what she was saying was against the my interest and the interest of my clan.To me the word Somali meant everything.And was and still is larger than life.But the more time passby the more i drift away from that notion.What does Somali or Somalia mean to me today as a young majerteenian man.And what security do i have in the Makeshift Made-in-arta government.And what hope does it give me or the future of myself,my clan and my future children.As a magerteen,i know that iam under threat and every Somali clan whats wants to see the end of Majerteen frankly speaking.But we somalis we dont like to talk like this and we dont like to openly talk about how we love our clans and dislike those who dont belong to us.So my brothers and sisters lets tell each other the thruth .because hiden feelings cause an imaginable hate and explosive behaviour.and we all know the out come of that behaviour.We all know what happened in Somalia.So now out of frustration we are trying honestly or otherwise to find a quick-fix solution.Some of us like the solution more than others ,be it personal or clan based.But the fact is If Somaliland succeed to break away from the rest of Somali,there would be no Somalia.And the quetion is who would follow.Puntland would be next for sure.Followed by many tinny beak away somili this or that.And what do we achieve.bassically nothing.we will be the nothing.the biggest loosers on the face of the earth.And we will be victim every one and every nation.We will be used and abused in every way immaginable.So how do we save our self from this looming catastrophy.No much options i guese.We love our clans more than we love our beautiful land.We would rather narrow mindedly and selfishly support and defend any make shift government as long as ther is a personal gain for for us and clan,and risk loosing somalia for good.the alternative way to go if we are wise and is to come of the self endused coma,open our mind and think in a broader picture of the Somali nation.And brothers and sisters let us build a just society where the interest of every individual and every clan is met.And let us lay down the foundtion where the strong pillars of the our Laws and rules stand one.Rules that no one could break,swist or turn.Laws that would save guard the weak among us and the srong equally.Laws that would ensure the existance of the Somali nation for a millenium to come in peace and prosperity.If we dont do that let us all prepare for the inevitable doom looming over our heads.May Allah lead us unto the right path,the path of those whom he had favoured,not the pathe of those who aern his anger nor of those who went astry.Amin.Wassalam Aleikum.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Garxajis

Saturday, October 14, 2000 - 11:47 pm
The best somalian presentation i have ever seen
it brought into tears as somaliland man we are
somaliland's. walaalo to be honest with u we
killed by daarood people like Aadan gabyow,
Morgan and Gani. Personality I have nothing
against Particularly against majerten.
Majerten have fought agants siad bares regime.
Majerten are everybodys favourite but the people
who don't like u are the hawiyes.As H/yonis man
and muse care and my best being majerten, cumar
maxamud i think true somalian clan and respected
by most of the somalian tribes. The reason e
everybody talks majerten is because they r well
known very historic and proud nation. All these
garacyaal are jeoulassy of u r success and they
want to sound like they hate majerten but inside
they wish they were born from them.

God almighty bring the nation together.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Kumade

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 01:53 am
IIdoor waa kuu nacasnimo inaad Darood kala
xigsataa waa kuwii karbaashka kula dhacay
Ha ilaawin Morgan waa MJ Gani waa MR Gabyow
waa reer Kuumade.
Majeerteen haduu wanaag leeyahayna waa Darood
Hawiye hadaay nacaana qof ibna aadan oo jecel
his MR majiro marka xaqbaay uleeyihiin in aay
nacaan waa kuwii karbaashi jirey sida Dabacayuun
uu u karbaashi jirey Siyadka.
Mj Darodka manecbo lakiin hal mid baaysan jecleen
Daroodka waa qof is amaano waa ri isnuugtey Daroodka waxaay aminsanyihiin in uu san qofka
Darood uu san u baahneen is amaan sawabtoo ah
taariqda ayaa amaaneyso Soomlina waay la socotaa

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Cawil Bander Qaasim

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 04:50 am
Cabdirisaaq
horta waxaa ay samaysay raaqiya Oomaar ma ogi,mise waxaad u jeeddaa raage Oomaar.
Cammii waa runtaa anigu marar badan baan yaabaa waxa dadka Majeerteen ku diray,oo loo necebyahay
xitaa hartigaa la sheegayaa haddaad la sheekaysatid way caayi Majeerteen.
waxaanse runtii ogaaday in ay yihiin dad dadka ka horreyn jirey haatanse la soo gaadhey.

Inba keenadiid wuxuu yidhi Beri aad u horreyeey

Gob ninkii ahaan jirey iyo midkaa haatan garb taagan
Gedda kaasi yahay yuu kan kale gaar isleeyahay
labadaa garbood oo sinsiman yow(yaa u) ganiqidoona

Markii cammii ha welwelin hana murugoon wallaahi hadalada aad qortay murugo ayey igu abuureen,shucuurtaydana way kiciyeen..
walao aanan majeerteen ahayn hase yeshee wixii soo gaadhaa anna isegi maayaan,ninka iyga necebna i jeclaan maayo....
Cawil Salah(from Bander qasim)

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Sahal

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 10:45 am
Garxajis & Cawil i appretiate your nice comments. Cawil Even though you didn't mention your tribe i'm sure they're nice ppl and i have alot of respect for them because of what u said. Garxajis brother, to me personally i have alot respect for your tribe (Isaq) and i many friends who are Issaq's. Waa dad nafta kuu hurin loona huri karo. Aad baan uga xumahay meesha ay Soomaali maanta kala taal. Thank You.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

baran

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 01:58 pm
sahal magaca noo dhaaf qaldaan yohow majeeten ma tihid

kumade thanks bro sifaacan baa u hadshay nimankaan qaldaaminta naf taa hayso waa dhiman rabaan waxay maqleen cabdulahi yusuf aa dawlada diiday ma oga miyaa in majeeten nimankii ugu oday sanaa ay xamar joogan sida xasn abshir maxamed abshir kuwo kale.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Ali

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 02:57 pm
Cabdirisaaq ,garxajis and awil are true Somalis.Thank you bros.Boran and sahal displayed weakeness and insecurity.Iam Majerteen too and i dont believe that the few old loosers who went to join Mogadishu represent the view of all Majerteen.You can keep them in Mogadishu cos we dont want the back.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

HABARTA

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 04:52 pm
TO: CABDIRISAQ AND GARXAJIS

I am a Habargidir and the only
Majerten subclan that I have admired
and respected is Issa Mohamud (Ciise
Maxamuud)
Walahi, they have won much respect
and dignity among other clans, coz,
I guesse they are peac-lovers, and
always try love to solve everything
in peace
I wonder how Mj would look like
without Issa Mohamud?.
MJ stands for the evil. and evils
should be stopped.
Habarta

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

JOOGAX

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 05:20 pm
I don't think that you guys talking about the reality of the said clan. But let me tell you one thing.The Worst clan of Somalia is the above said Clan.
Ar soo Barya!!!!!!

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Xuudhi

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 05:25 pm
Sahal we don't want yr garbage in Mogadishu, keep them beside A/llahi Yusuf(The Old dictatur)..

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

EEGA

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 05:29 pm
Walaalayaa,maana laga tegin weli fikradii majeerteen een ahayd" Inta madax madow & majeerteen....". Isla weynida iyo wax aadan ahayen iska yeelida, duudsiga soo laguma barto Majeerteen....!!!!!

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Cawil Banderqasim

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 06:45 pm
Dear sahal

as per my name Awil BANDERQASIM, I thought i have cleared Who the heck I'm, if that is not enought,just for get it ,you never know it...
I was just showing my sympathy to MJ Brother.(waxaan hubaa in uu i qiyaasayo ciddaan ahay)

Banderqasimi

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

yusuf

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 08:45 pm
SOOMAALI WAXAY DAD UGU NECEBTAHAY ISAAK IYO
MAJEERTEEN COZ THEY R CIVILIZED PPL THEY build
their area while others are figthing omong themselves and reach any agreement,thats why those
ppl hate majeerteen and isaaak.
but hey who cares let them stay behind and talk
about us while we r building our countries
S/LAND and PUNTLAND.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Sahal

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 10:27 pm
Cawil Sxb Bander qaasim waa lawada dagaaye so it isnot clear yet. You could be if i'mnot mistaken dashiishle.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

ISTAR

Sunday, October 15, 2000 - 10:48 pm
tu eega walaal runtii soomali oodhan majecla majeerteen sababtoo ah waadadka soomaaliya dhisay
intamadaxmadow iyo majeerteen maansha alaah majeerteen ilaah ayaa badiyay!!!!! dadkuna waxay yihiin uma ogola.majeerteen hanoolaado.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

JEYTE

Wednesday, October 18, 2000 - 02:57 am
MEEDJEERTEEN BARBAARTA ABGAAL AA XAMAR KU SUGEE

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Dr. Omar

Wednesday, October 18, 2000 - 03:26 am
MAJEERTEEN WAA QABIIL QABAA'ISHA SOOMAALIYEED KAMID AH, MAGARANAYO WAXA DADKU GAAR UGU FAQUUQAYAAN!, HADII QOF KAMID AHI XUMAAN GALAYNA(shaqsi ama caam) WAAKU KELIGIIS EE REER LAGUMA EEDI KARO, MARKA AYNU KADEGNO REER WAX KASHEEGII OO AAN UGUDUBNO MAWAADIIC KALE OO NIQAASH IYO XIISO LEH.

( THIS SEEMS TO BE SINCELESS)

Dr. Omar

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

ALIF

Wednesday, October 18, 2000 - 04:20 am
TO: ALL MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS OF MAJEERTEEN
FROM: AWDAL LIBERATION FRONT-"ALiF"

RE: PRESECUTION OF THE MAJEERTEEN

DEAR ALL,

We are all aware of what happened from April 1978 (a coup d'etat) to June 1979. Afer the coup had failed Siyad Barre sent his Red Barrets(duub cas)against the Majeerteen in Mudug Region. The Red Barrets systematically smashed the small reservoirs in the area around Galcaio so as to deny water to the umar Mahamoud Majeerteen sublineages and their herds. In may and June 1979, more than 2000 umar Mahamoud, the Majeerteen sublineage of Colonel Abdillahi yusuf AHMED,died of thirst in the waterless area northeast of Galcaio, Garoowe, and jerribaan.
In Galcaio, members of the the Victory pioneers, the urban militia notorious for harassing civilians, raped large members of Majeerteen Women. In addition, the clan lost an estimated 50,000 camels, 10,000 cattle, and 100,000 sheep and goats.

Sadly that is the tragic History we all know; now lets ask ourselves these questions

1. Who was against the Majeerteen Clan, was it
(a) The Somali people in general or
(b) The Somali Government.

2. Who were the Red Barrets
(a) Non-majeerteen Somalis
(b) All Somalis including majeerteen(like-
Morgan)

3. What did the Majeerteen wanted, was it
(a) Better Somali Government and the
leadership? or
(b) the so colled PUNTLAND


4. Now, who is refusing the Majeerteen to
lead he country?

I will comeback to conclude this subject later on, when the questions raised here are all answered by you.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Reer muuse cade

Wednesday, October 18, 2000 - 04:25 am
Habarta.

I agree with you not only because I'm Ciise Mahmoud,but we love Somali unity. Thanks bro you
first Habargidir say that.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

cali daaq cumar

Wednesday, October 25, 2000 - 04:12 pm
subxanalah,
ladies and gentelamn, brothers and sisters, somali people;

i can not as a young somali man, descripe my utter amusement, disspointment and disgused on how all of you participants in this debate as a SOMALI people, would rather prefare to influence a young brother who grew up in the west and never witnessed any of the abvoe mentioned atrusaties of the past and who would rather see a strong somali nation (not on clan based idiology) but as national based infistructure.

since all you 'intellectuals' are so sadly opsessed with this negative tribal based idiology, i would like to clearfiy that i'm (darood, warsangly) so therefore i have nothing against majeerteen or for that matter any other somali tribe whether its other daroods , isaaq's, hawiya's and any other somali tribe or clan.

the reason being I DO NOT BELIEVE IN INTRIBELISIM,_______ p e r i o d_________AND THEERFORE WOULD NEVER EVER JUDGE THE PAST OR THE PRESENT ACCORDING TO IT...NO MATTER HOW BAD..

its been proven extemly practiclly nribelism not to have any meaningfull and lasting benefials to NO body.

i strongly strees that i do NOT know anything about the above so detailedly descriped history, and i much rather not know any more about it...

Why i hear you wonder? because i believe that its much more sensible and moral, to forgive what happend in the past and to try and forget it (if possible) for the sake of our future generations......if Blacks are prepared to live with the Whits in America and in South Africa togheter in piece in harmony ( after the long destingusihed history that we all know of), than why isn't on earth, that we as somali nation with shared religion, language, culture, national complextion and racial background could quite possible live toghter in piece and harmoy and for a common purpose and interest, which is a strong united fedral nation with strong economy, good health services, good education systems, higher life standards, strong stablishment of low and order, real protected soverenthgy and RESPECTFUL NATIONAL PRIDE,

i bag you all please to be honest with your selfs and admit that these are what you really want for your selfs and for your childeren.

i live in england and i have seen how a real nation is and how real democratic government governs.... i always feel low and jelous because i wish somalia was like this.... i have a dream that 1 day i'll see our beutiful motherland SOMALIA becoming as developed, as piecefull and as strong as ENGLAND.. i firmly believe that we could become like them and even better because we have ISLAM on our side.

i'll LIKE to ask you all as the somali muslim people 1 question that always bothers me; dont you wanna go to heaven?

if your answer (which i'm sure it's yes) is yes than allah may have his mercy on us and our fathers, because if we continue the way we are 2 day, than i dont think we'll be going towards heaven, BECUASE WE BELIEVE IN TRIBELISM AND TREAT EACH OTHER ACCORDING TO IT, ..... AND TRIBELISM IN ISLAM IS XARAM ..REMEBER THAT.
<<<<<QABYALATU WAA XARAN MAQDAC AH ISLAMKA>>>>>

that is all i wanted to say, thank you and ilahay hayno naxristu inshalah.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

cumar

Wednesday, October 25, 2000 - 07:59 pm
yo kid your not majerten so who the hell are you anyway and incase that iam wrong and that you,re majerten what is this sad story all about I am majerten and i don,t see your point

we have beautiful country soroundedby our
brothers and sisters with allahs blessings

we have peace loving elders and intellectuals to lead us the wright bath so what's there to worry man, as a young majerten living in London I learn one thing whatever people say about who you,re don't let it get to you bro at the end of the day its all-talk nobody in this world can do nothing to us because we are proud of what we are

and our goal is to stay that way

so trust me nigger and be proud

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Keyse

Thursday, October 26, 2000 - 01:48 am
To: Bandarqaasim
gabaygu waa kaa liicay ee waa sidan
Laandheere gob ahaanjiroo gocoshadu hayso(sidayda)
Iyo kii ka gaabnaan jiroo haatan garabtaagan
Geda kaayuhuu kan kale gaar isleeyahaye
labadaa garaad oo gudboon yow garnaqi doona

thanx

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

samiira

Thursday, October 26, 2000 - 12:46 pm
Habarta c/maxamedc/c/maxamud/c/maxamud waawalaalo markaaad ciisimaxamud iyoanaga ha iskukaaya dirin. Waxaadubaahan tahay in aadheshid dadkutaageersan ooah ciisemaxamud.sitaas aad uheshidna ciisemaxamuud amaan aadan uhayn oo been ah baad bilowday.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Sahal

Friday, October 27, 2000 - 10:41 am
Samiira just chill sis!!!

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

isxaq

Friday, October 27, 2000 - 10:57 am
annigoo ah isaq,majeertween laba qof ayaan ka jeclahay ee ha lay doondoono.
nin dhintay,iyo mid ma dhalays ah..
soo barya.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

Kacaan-diid

Friday, October 27, 2000 - 12:34 pm
ALIF,

Thanks for the sympathy. Sincere or insincere, you shed some light on a sad part of our somali history. For the youngesters, who were too young to remember, and for those who need more info on this, please visit Amnesty International's page. You will also find out more about the massacres of our brothers in the North.

Now to get back to your questions, I don't know how any answers given to U will assist you reach a reasonable conclusion. Nevertheless, I will try to answer them accordingly.

1)Of course the dictatorship regime, not the general public.

However, for too long the Somali public were fed into a too much propaganda, and lies against the Majeerteens. The lies and propaganda wars has taken their toll, and as a result so many of our somali brothers and sisters became brain washed. They believed what they were told against the Majertens, and since then, they had a negative image about us. Quite frankly, you sound one of those brain washed victims.

2)The Red Barrets, were special military police force intended to guard the former dictator. They were somalis from all clans, but mainly from his own sub clan, since loyalty and trust were important factors of becoming one of them.

3) None of the above.

This is where I sensed of your sickness. They want justice, they want peace and most of all they want what most somalis want-SOMALI UNITY.

4)Again wrong question to ask. No clan can refuse or give us leadership, nor are we asking for it. Refer to answer 3) .


Although you did not state clearly, between the lines you implied the Majeerteens or Puntland state, is against Somali Unity, for not supporting the outcome of the failed Arta Peace Process. I would lie to you if I said, We support the so-called government of Somalia, because we don't, But, this does not mean we are anti Somali unity. The Somali Unity we want is an inclusive one. Every Somali with a sane head sees the Arta outcome is nothing, but a total incarnation of the dictatorship era. Its led and dominated by none other than the top officials of the tyrannical regime. Still worse, these individual who led the Somalis the doom they are in, are not remorseful, and never spoke out against the brutal crimes you listed in your article. They and whoever supports them should realize that
they are part of the dark history of Somalia, and they will remain so as long as history is recorded. As for the people of Puntland, They will join their somali brothers when the time comes, and they want nothing but a peaceful coexistance from all somalis.

Wish U Luck.

Long Live Puntland, & Long live Somalia.

Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of pageLink to this message  

OUTKUZT

Saturday, October 28, 2000 - 12:55 pm
TO: ALL OF YOU

I hereby declare that am one of the minorities in somalia a.k.a MIDGO (yaxar)(as known as OUTCAST).

after reading so many debates and some disgusting, un-intelligent comments I tried to stay away to post some of the comments that I wanted to make.

the reason I am writing this today is to ask those Majeerteen fellow (to whom we shared their land and peacefuly co-existed centuries and centuries). To take stand for their kingdom because without majeerteen in somalia there is no peace or prosperity that will prevail.

CONFESSION:

I confess that in my childhood years I hated Majeerteen in the depth of my soul as I was growing up, I always wanted them dead. all of them. I use to day-dream the day I take the matter in my very own hand and take revenge for the all the misery and humiliation that my people suffered in somali history, shortly after those barberian alien invaded our Land and distroyed our little peaceful kingdom. distroyed our civilized world and then subjected our best and brightest genius among us to serve their technical needs ( since they had no knowledge whatsoever about craft,smith,etc).

After all, they make ridiculous whatever we use to take a pride off, such as new ennovation, techno- wise, it term of iron-smithery and know-how for our survival needs.
Also,
I hated their hypocrisy when it comes Inter-marriage. they always use to take advantage on us, for example: we had the best and most beautiful women in the area, then one of them come without any regards go and marry her, and automatically she is of of them ( majeerteen) and her children are majeerteen considerable higher grade than us. the very same child that our daughter give birth from the same midgan womb.
What was more ridiculous than that is when one of our man fall in love with their woman, they make sure that it never took place, either that man has to be killed by her brothers or exiled from his family. if their woman fall in love with one of us and they can not help,than they will go to the extreme to perform hysterectom on her (to remove the womp)so that she will never bear a midgan child.
Such a drama was too much for my little brain back in the days, up untill recently when the things fall apart in somalia and worst nighmare came in reality when a most Ignorant and sub-human of all mother nature (HabarDigir)get a weapon in their hands and wipe-out my entire race on the face of earth.

Things could have been a lot better and much more smoother if majeerteen had taken charge of habrdigir and keep them in check as they always did in somali history, after all I have no enemity toward any somalis let it be hypocrite majeerteen or sub-human habardigir ( I don`t have a word to discribe their disgusting inhumane).

I think I should rest my case here and see what some of you write in return.

Feel like posting? Pleaase click here for the list of current forums.