Hawiye V Isaaq

[TAATIKO]

samatar insults south everywhere and she wants stop

[Xildiiid]

He's not Isaaq. He's Dir.

[TAATIKO]

He's not Isaaq. He's Dir.

isn't isaaq dir. and he called south yaq yaqsi another interview he called too garbage

[Xildiiid]

I don't see the connection between the title of this thread and the video.


No, Isaaq are not Dir.

[eliteSomali]

Prof Samatar run buu sheegay. Constitution naafaysan wax laguma dhisi karo. Islantana xanaaq baa ka yara muuqda. She's not impartial whatsoever and she seems to be doesn't give a shit.

[Even123]

Samatar getting karbashed by the lady ,..............walee President Hassan waa rageedi, saying thanks and we shall have a look at it when proposed by the Dir's for PM post, he knows full well that President and PM post is in rotation between Hawiye and Darood.

[TAATIKO]

I don't see the connection between the title of this thread and the video.


No, Isaaq are not Dir.

gadabuursi or dhuloos anyone who preach qadiyada belongs to isaaqland


BS; isaaq isn't dir = is not samaale

[Xildiiid]

What's Isaaqland?

By Samaale I assume you mean Samaale = Somali, am I right?

What's the connection between Samaale (a name) and Somali/So'maal (a profession)?


Even,

The letter was not created by the Dir MP's but by so called "unionists" from Somaliland including Cali Khaliif Galaydh.

[TAATIKO]

I assume you mean Samaale = Somali, am I right?

What's the connection between Samaale (a name) and Somali/So'maal (a profession).

NOTHING Samaale= dir+hawiye
so'maali= Nation

[Xildiiid]

Correct and we're not Samaale but Somali.


What's Isaaqland though?

[TAATIKO]

Isaaq land is geopolitical slogan

According to traditions recorded in Shariif 'Aydaruus Shariif 'Ali's Bughyat al-amaal fii taariikh as-Soomaal (1955), the patriarch Samaale arrived in northern Somalia from Yemen during the 9th century and subsequently founded the eponymous Somali ethnic group.[1]

Most Somalis trace their origins to Samaale:[1]

Dir
Issa in Djibouti, Awdal and Ethiopia
Gadabuursi in Awdal and Ethiopia
Isaaq
Hawiye

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irir_Samaale

[Xildiiid]

So where is Isaaqland located?


Isaaq has no connection to Samaale.

[thegoodshepherd]

Somalia waa dir iyo darood. Isaaq said "we are not darood" somalia said "then you are dir" There isn't a third option

[Xildiiid]

^
Who came up with that nonsense?

Isaaq don't inhabit Somalia so your little anecdote doesn't coincide with reality.

[thegoodshepherd]

^
Who came up with that nonsense?

Isaaq don't inhabit Somalia so your little anecdote doesn't coincide with reality.

lol I was talking about why people in koonfur think isaaq is dir. all non darood tribes claim samaale or saab (raxanweyne) such that if you say you are not darood then you must belong to either samaale or saab. The koonfur people were very confused when isaaq came to mogadishu in 1960 claiming a third lineage. They chose not to believe the newcomers and put them with samaale (dir) because they spoke aaf maxa tiri not maymay. And that mr xildiid is why koonfurians have you as a dir subclan in the 4.5 system. And now you know