SomaliNet Forums

whoever is slandering the marxuum, i suggest you keep your mouths shut and seek knowledge. sayd qutb (rahimahullah) made errors in his books and this was mainly before he made significant changes in his manhaj. even the ulama who corrected him and pointed out his mistakes never went as far as to call him a deviant and a misguided sufi etc. they would say he was a muffakir (a thinker) but his cilm needed taxqiiq. ibn baaz even requested the egyptian government at the time to let him go by jamal abdinasser refused. also, ibn uthaymeen (ra) said he was a man who wanted change for the ummah and he strived hard for this, even when jamal abdinasser offered him amnesty, qutb was quoted (im paraphrasin) 'the finger that professes tawheed will never bow to the will of oppression'.

furthermore, ibn jibreen (ra) one of the former biggest scholars in saudi called him a shaheed who died for a noble cause. how dare you ridicule this man when you spend your life in macsiyah, this man was fighting police dogs in egyptian prisons.

I don't care for your weird words and weird names. He was racist and that's the end of it.

Tobi wrote:I don't care for your weird words and weird names. He was racist and that's the end of it.

there is something called tawbah he made mistakes and this was when he used to write tafseer based on mental logic, not knowledge. he use to grasp the politics surrounding him and his work was very subjective but like i said, this was before he changed.

even the esteemed malcolm x, didnt he have extreme views against white people? didnt he use to call for a black state and to segregate it from the 'evil and conniving' white population? but of course, this was before he learned the religion properly and saw islam for what its really worth.

[quote="Jaidi"]NoAngst your critiques and analysis lose relevance when you can't even distinguish between what you are criticizing. First you tell us Jihadists support Gaddafi( the opposite) now you tell us Qutb was a Wahhabi. Im not sure if you are trolling.[/quote]

Stop derailing my thread this is not about that effete maggot Gaddafi but about the midget Qutb. Was he or was he not a racist based on the quote I provided above?