Will Somalis move away from Qabyaalad?

[PrinceDaadi]

Qabiil has nothing good to offer and is the mother of qabyaalad and all other problem.

All over the world people come together and do things as community that share interest not because they r grouped under useless qabiil name.

Actually there is no single country which has got qabiil structure that has made any meaningful development.

[TheCadaanGuy]

Well, last time qabyaalad nearly disappeared was around "Somalia's golden age" just before Barre went crazy.

If betting was halal, I'd bet my $1 that it will slowly disappear as Somalia becomes peaceful because that time, there will be no real need to rely on clan for protection and a sense of belonging to.

[PrinceDaadi]

TCG: as people income improve their qabyaalad decreases so if we want to reduce qabyaalad then we have to improve people's income.

[TheLoFather]

If Qabyaaladnimo is motivated by the love of one's own qabiil and not by the hatred towards another qabiil, it can be very positive and a force for good for all concerned.

[PrinceDaadi]

If Qabyaaladnimo is motivated by the love of one's own qabiil and not by the hatred towards another qabiil, it can be very positive and a force for good for all concerned.

I don't see how qabiil got any positive and how you can love your qabiil with hating its imaginary enemies.

[HorseedS]

Qabiil has nothing good to offer and is the mother of qabyaalad and all other problem.

Listen dude qabiil can be a blessing at times. Qabiil brings people together not for bad reasons but for good reasons. When someone is sick or they're in a bad financial situations the qabiil steps in to lend them a hand. If I get into a car accident today god forbid, first people to come to my aid will be my qabiil not some strangers I've never heard of before. Give credit where it's due ninyahow qabiil has a lot of benefits if it's used the right way.

[GAMES]

Technically, if you were to get into a car accident, the first people that would come to your aid would be EMS or other first responders....which are of course strangers.

[theyuusuf143]

If Qabyaaladnimo is motivated by the love of one's own qabiil and not by the hatred towards another qabiil, it can be very positive and a force for good for all concerned.

exactly. simply qabiil is like nation, and qabyaalad is like nationalism. if nationalism is good qabyaalad is better. Both can be used positively or negatively. for example Hitler was a nationalist he motivated his people to Subdue other Europeans. In contrast angela Merkel is nationalist as well but she is just doing the opposite of what hitler did to other Europeans. same like that each Somali qabiil can use positive or negative qabyalad. if my qabiil elites encourage me to contribute our habarjeclo qabiil development its positive qabyalad. if they encourage me to shoot dhuloos on sight its negative qabyaalad. la jiifiyaana banaan la joojiyaana banaan kkk.

[PrinceDaadi]

Horseed: actually when I have issue some of the people I call besides family r friends whom we don't share qabiil and I was doing that since 2003.

I understand adinka qabiilka diin idiin yahay but for us we encourage individualism and we identify our self as Somali period.

[HorseedS]

Horseed: actually when I have issue some of the people I call besides family r friends whom we don't share qabiil and I was doing that since 2003.

I understand adinka qabiilka diin idiin yahay but for us we encourage individualism and we identify our self as Somali period.

"Qabiil ba diin idin ah" So you're just going to come up with some bullshit yah? Nin weyn baad tahay wax kasta oo afkaaga ku soo dhaca lama soo qoro ninyahow. I'm around a lot of people who aren't my qabiil but you don't see me bragging about it. At the end of the day qabiil has it's benefits whether you like it or not.

[Itrah]

I'm talking about those under the age of 30. Many of us view tribalism as nothing more than as a technique to be used in Fadhikudir debates. Nevertheless, I believe Somalis of my generation will gradually move away from this destructive practice. Qabiil will only be used for identity. What do you guys think?

^^ It will never go away, even Gulf Arabs who are rich as fuck still stick to using their clan system.
No amount of modernization will get rid of it.

[LiquidHYDROGEN]

Gulf arabs aren't a modern society, they are simply rich peasants. True change comes from cultural evolution, not petrodollars.

[Idman702]

Qabiil brought me closer to most of my cousins and relatives who I never thought existed. Qabiil can have positive effects.


Now there's a certain member in this thread asking qabiil to be demolished when he's the biggest qabiliste on this forum. Just because he's "quiet" people think he's a good person with a good heart when he is indeed the most evil member on this website.

The quietest snake has the deadliest venom.


**sips her cappuccino**

[Idman702]

Horseed: actually when I have issue some of the people I call besides family r friends whom we don't share qabiil and I was doing that since 2003.

I understand adinka qabiilka diin idiin yahay but for us we encourage individualism and we identify our self as Somali period.

"Qabiil ba diin idin ah" So you're just going to come up with some bullshit yah? Nin weyn baad tahay wax kasta oo afkaaga ku soo dhaca lama soo qoro ninyahow. I'm around a lot of people who aren't my qabiil but you don't see me bragging about it. At the end of the day qabiil has it's benefits whether you like it or not.

Yo I just wrote about him. He's the biggest qabiliste on this forum. I am aware of what he spews behind closed doors. And you can see at times he will show his true side and hides away for weeks.

[TheCadaanGuy]

TCG: as people income improve their qabyaalad decreases so if we want to reduce qabyaalad then we have to improve people's income.

Probably but I don't think money is main thing. It can be as simple as keeping Somalis busy and happy. Why the need to declare war when you're happy with your life? Some will do but majority won't. Those who do, will get arrested by an army or police.

After a while, Somalis will start to care less about their tribal identity just like back then because they don't have a need for them any more.