SomaliNet Forums

smooth wrote:

incognito1 wrote:Great job by the people of puntland, we are in the year 2016 and as a people we deny to be led by clan mentality.
.

What do you propose? district based sadbursi even more clanish crap we actually had a civil war over? the same system Puntland couldn't even implement in their own 1 tribe enclave? great logic sxb

There is no new proposal, were saying let's implement what we all agreed upon in 2012. 2016 elections will not be based on 4.5 everyone signed it backtracking is not allowed in this game.

That proposal was a 1 man 1 vote that was signed, which can't be implemented due to al-shabab that's financed by dhiigshiil and Somaliland, you would have been a minority in that system anyway, hence why the IC already signed 4.5, show me were the agreement says "district based" which is what faroole really wants, also explain to me why you failed to implement that in 18 years? you have no leg to stand on, either legally or morally.

smooth wrote:That proposal was a 1 man 1 vote that was signed, which can't be implemented due to al-shabab that's financed by dhiigshiil and Somaliland, you would have been a minority in that system anyway, hence why the IC already signed 4.5, show me were the agreement says "district based" which is what faroole really wants, also explain to me why you failed to implement that in 18 years?

Stop acting stupid, it clearly stated 4.5 will not be used 1 man 1 vote or other alternatives.
I don't got time to dig up documents for you go Google it.

Inti qabil qabil laysu haystay ba meesha lagu dhamaday , sida qolo waliba qoloda kale ugu xumaynayso waxas oo dhana waxa samaynaya dad xukunka isku adkaynaya , aan runta isku sheegno xasan awalba laluush bu meesha ku yimi , hadana lacag tii ka badan bu haysta oo waxu raba waxa asaga dantiisu ku jirto uun inu sameeyo , wa nin qalafsan oo macnaha dimuqradiyada iyo wadani nimada aan aaminsanayn , anigu ma kala jeclo belayadi wadankan ka talinaysa , mar haduu yahay maamul cadalad ku dhisan oo joojisa silica iyo rafadka umada , bahidoodana wax ka qabata wadanka gees ka gees ,umadana midaysa oo ilalisa sharafta iyo karamada dalka , having said that hasan must go we need fresh face and new ideas , there should not be second term this is not dhaxaltooyo.

smooth wrote:

incognito1 wrote:Great job by the people of puntland, we are in the year 2016 and as a people we deny to be led by clan mentality.
.

What do you propose? district based sadbursi even more clanish crap we actually had a civil war over? the same system Puntland couldn't even implement in their own 1 tribe enclave? great logic sxb

I propose we follow the constitution!!!!!

http://www.somalinet.com/forums/viewtop ... 7#p4634297

knet wrote:

smooth wrote:That proposal was a 1 man 1 vote that was signed, which can't be implemented due to al-shabab that's financed by dhiigshiil and Somaliland, you would have been a minority in that system anyway, hence why the IC already signed 4.5, show me were the agreement says "district based" which is what faroole really wants, also explain to me why you failed to implement that in 18 years?

Stop acting stupid, it clearly stated 4.5 will not be used 1 man 1 vote or other alternatives.
I don't got time to dig up documents for you go Google it.

No need to google I just posted a thread with the signed document.

http://www.somalinet.com/forums/viewtop ... 7#p4634297

edited

incognito1, well done.

These cats are so well known for their back-tracking the agreement was written in crystal clear language.

ii. The 4.5 formula shall never become the basis for power sharing in any future political dispensation after the above mentioned term concludes.

iii. The New Federal Constitution shall not include any provisions using the 4.5 formula and shall not be amended to abrogate this stipulation in any manner.

iv. The New federal parliament that comes into being in June 2012 shall not amend or enact any law or implement any policy that takes into account or attempts to reinstate the 4.5 power sharing formula.

v. After the first term, the parliament will be elected through universal polling of one person one vote.

vi. In case the prevailing situation does not allow for universal polling, the parliament will be selected on the basis of constituencies.

Signatories:
President of the Transitional Federal Government: Sheikh Sharif Shekh Ahmed.
Speaker of the Transitional Federal parliament: Sharif Hassan Sheikh Aden.
Prime Minister of Transitional Federal Government: Dr. Abdiweli Mohamed Ali
Puntland President: Dr. Abdirahman Sheikh Mohamed Mohamud
President of Galmudug: Mohamed Ahmed Aalim
Ahlu-Sunna Wal Jamaaca Representative: Sheikh Mohamed Mohamud Yusuf
Deputy Special Representative, Secretary General of the UN for Somalia: Christian Manahl

Source:
The Binding Document, even the UN signed it.
http://unpos.unmissions.org/LinkClick.a ... uage=en-US

smooth wrote:edited

Smooth i respect facts and it's what I brought you, so there goes your 4,5 argument!!!!

If all you have left are insults,remember that says more about you then it does about me.

I am not an emotional man I am rational one, so if you wish to defeat me in the future. Instead of using insults like a child, destroy me with facts, for that's the only language I understand.

They can shove it, thier damn 4.5 bullshit.

The embarrassment continues.

Somalis, once universally feared and known as fearsome warriors, now domesticated and neutered like animals by international community.

I don't even know any of other countries who are in the same situation.

incognito1 wrote:

smooth wrote:edited

Smooth i respect facts and it's what I brought you, so there goes your 4,5 argument!!!!

TheCadaanGuy wrote:The embarrassment continues. .

smooth wrote:edited

Can someone explain why 4.5 is bad for Daroods, and why district based is good for them. And what would be the difference. Arent districts, more or less, separated by clan.

And what is Puntland's election proccess.

BenevolentGaraad wrote:
Can someone explain why 4.5 is bad for Daroods, and why district based is good for them. And what would be the difference. Arent districts, more or less, separated by clan.

And what is Puntland's election proccess.

4,5 vs district = population vs districts.

In theory Daroods occupy more districs then Hawiye, but Hawiye has a bigger a population,and neither wants the other to gain a political monopoly, either through 4,5 or districs elections Hence the deadlock.

But here is the problem, 4,5 is illegal according to the Somali constitution.

the 4,5 election system ended with the transitional government, now that we are a federal government, we abide by the federal constitution.

when Hassan Sheikh Mohamud was elected back in 2012,
his government was given 4 years to build institutions, and prepare the country for 1 man one vote election system.

Instead he used the 4 years fighting jubbaland, fighting his prime minsters, looting aid money and state property, and last but not least propping up friendly states with the loot money.


And now with the help of his damuljadiid monkeys
Cabdikarim Guleed
Sheik sakiin
he wants to sobatoge the the federal constitution of Somalia.

So in conclusion you could say people are in reality devide between two groups:

The pro constitution - constituencies= districts
The anti constitution- 4,5= illegal

So this is not about Hawiye vs darood but damuljadiid vs the rest.

I can't speak on puntland, someone else has to answer that question for you.