Suaal: Mowliid & Christmas

[Yoousef]

I am a sunni muslim. I don't go into schools and different sects as I believe you shouldn't try to differentiate between muslims.

But I have never heard of stong sunni muslim celebrating Prothet Muhammad(PBUH) Birthday

[Shirib]

You are a narrow minded guy no matter how hard I try to convince you'll always defend the wahabi point of view so lets leave it at that.

Leave him. May Allah guide him towards love for prophet Muhammad pbuh.

Well if the love for rasulluallah is defined by celebrating his birth then congratulations you love him not only more than I but even the saxaaba

[Shirib]

You know what all jokes aside this argument seems very simple.

Did the prophet (saw) celebrate his birthday when he was alive?

No he simply fasted

I fail to see how they can put off Christmas as a pagan tradition but in the same tongue accept Mowliid

[Shirib]

Shrib what did your dugsi teacher say in terms of celebrating
your own Birthday /... I mean .. how can they allow Prophet Mohammed SAW ..
birthday to be celebrated surely they can't go against others celebrating their own birthday

I don't recall but probably not.

[Executive]

You are a narrow minded guy no matter how hard I try to convince you'll always defend the wahabi point of view so lets leave it at that.

Leave him. May Allah guide him towards love for prophet Muhammad pbuh.

Well if the love for rasulluallah is defined by celebrating his birth then congratulations you love him not only more than I but even the saxaaba

True, It just amazes me how he thinks he loves the prophet more than the companion and his family. who never celebrated mowlid. Subxanallah

[BlackVelvet]

You know what all jokes aside this argument seems very simple.

Did the prophet (saw) celebrate his birthday when he was alive?

No he simply fasted

I fail to see how they can put off Christmas as a pagan tradition but in the same tongue accept Mowliid

If he did that then the sunnah is to fast surely and not make a song and dance out of it. I don't see how anyone can suggest otherwise.

[Enlightened~Sista]

Shirib xasarad badanidaa...maxaa kaa galay if they celebrate mawlid or not?

[abdalla11]

Shirib xasarad badanidaa...maxaa kaa galay if they celebrate mawlid or not?

adna maxa kaa galay if women want to wear niqaab or not? how many topics did you create about niqaab

[Enlightened~Sista]

Adiga horta yaa kula hadlay

[abdalla11]

This is a forum

[Shirib]

Shirib xasarad badanidaa...maxaa kaa galay if they celebrate mawlid or not?

really is that all u have to contribute?

[abdalla11]

[melo]

The problem with the Mawlid is that it has been made a prescribed Islamic activity by some Muslims. On that night, and only that night, you will see horders of people coming to the Masjid to remember Rasulullah Saws. What about the other days of the year? And how about all the Unislamic things that happen at these mawlid events? You cannot make something that the prophet saws or his Sahabah did not legislate, a prescribed event. It cannot be considered sunnah.

In short, the problem with Mawlid is the way some Sunnis prescribe and fixate around it, as if its part of our religion. It isn't that important. You would be better off playing nawaafil prayer than celebrating mawlid on the 12th of Rabi Awwal. Remember the prophet saws every day, and not only on some auspicious day that might not even be his birth date.

[OliveOil]

So now you are comparing Nabi Muhammed (SCW) to Nabi Ciise?????

[Shift]

That guy is the somali version of tupac