SomaliNet Forums

AGENT447 wrote:_

jalaaludin5 wrote:So where did the story of 'Habar magaadle in the jihad' came from?


If we weren't in it, it didn't happen nor was it jihad. lol
-
-
-

samaalenoble wrote:For clarity's sake:

1. Habr Magaadle are mentioned separately from Habr Maqdi in one translation.

2. a Qaf can be a 'g' in some Arabic dialects/regions and it is common but a missing "lam" can't be excused.

3. Makadoor translates to - Makka/door - "He who chose Mecca". It can be argued that this clan were the first Somalis/HOAs to become Muslim. They were already fighting Habeshas well before the Adal wars.

5. As of now, evidence still points mostly to Ahmed Gurey being a Samaroon/Makadoor/Mahad Case/Abrayn even without this annotation.

6. The Kacaan bs has long been throughly debunked.

7. It can be argued that it was a set of political wars/conquests not religious wars.

AGENT447 wrote:

samaalenoble wrote:For clarity's sake:

1. Habr Magaadle are mentioned separately from Habr Maqdi in one translation.

2. a Qaf can be a 'g' in some Arabic dialects/regions and it is common but a missing "lam" can't be excused.

3. Makadoor translates to - Makka/door - "He who chose Mecca". It can be argued that this clan were the first Somalis/HOAs to become Muslim. They were already fighting Habeshas well before the Adal wars.

5. As of now, evidence still points mostly to Ahmed Gurey being a Samaroon/Makadoor/Mahad Case/Abrayn even without this annotation.

6. The Kacaan bs has long been throughly debunked.

7. It can be argued that it was a set of political wars/conquests not religious wars.

I am learning brilliant summation

AGENT447 wrote:

jalaaludin5 wrote:So where did the story of 'Habar magaadle in the jihad' came from?


If we weren't in it, it didn't happen nor was it jihad. lol
-
-
-

Shalad baratee waala shubi jiray lol. You guys got your Mujahidnimo stripes and credentials on fellow skinies but we earned ours sided boqol oo sano ka hor and guess on who dee, unlike u anaku xabashida jihaadkooda ayaan kusoo shaac baxnay

RoobleAlWaliid wrote:Thank you Agent, definitely worth reading

The last piece to the puzzle.


Pay attention to Husain Musa Bin 'Abd Allah Makida, a stripe below the k meaning a strong K.

He is of the tribe of Ahmed Girri. So he is of the Habar Maqdi(as written in the book), but a Makida alone has been written now.

This time a K has been added instead of a Q , strengthening the claim to Makadur.

This time even a i has been added to the word which nullifies the other claims to it and strengthens the Makidoor/Makidor/Makadur claim. You can't say Magida or Magidle, but Makidor has always been used.

A Isaaq of the Habar Magaadle can't say I'm AbdAllah of Magaadle , because Magaadle in itself is a whole different clan.

But just like the (Habr) Garhajis the (Habr) Makidor practice the same culture of occasionally removing the Habar pre-fix.

Husain Musa Bin 'Abd Allah Makidor.

We already discussed that the ya written in Arabic could've actually been an raa.

I can even connect Husain Musa Bin AbdAllah to the abtirsi.

Adler wrote:
Amazing regarding Husain Musa Bin Abdallah, my abtirsi ends in Sahel-Musa-Abdalle-Makahil-Makadoor-Samaroon-Sicid. Could he have been a brother of Sahel?