SomaliNet Forums

If we take clannism aside and produce a feasible federal states then this the way forward. Somalia will have six federal states. Also no more land shit.

Awdal, Waqooyi Galbeed, Togdheer= Adal State (3 region union)

Sanaag and Sool= Dervish State (2 union region)

Bari, Nugaal, Mudug= Punt State (3 region union)

Galgaduud, Hiiraan, Middle Shabelle= Shabelle State ( 3 region union)

Bay, Bakool, Lower Shabelle= Marka State (3 region union)

Gedo, Middle Jubba, Lower Jubba= Jubba State (3 region union)



Mogadishu= non-federal (capital)

Jubbaland does not exist, no chance of qaxooti Ethiopians stealing that land.


SNM rule all of north Somalia.


XimanJaale (Sade) I respect you, your the only D-block with balls too bad the Puanis and Lascanod ones are pussies.

there is no such thing as Dervish state, that land belongs to Somaliland and Somaliland alone. It is not up for negotiations whatsoever.

jamal9 wrote:there is no such thing as Dervish state, that land belongs to Somaliland and Somaliland alone. It is not up for negotiations whatsoever.

SomaliDefenceCouncil wrote:Jubbaland does not exist, no chance of qaxooti Ethiopians stealing that land.


SNM rule all of north Somalia.


XimanJaale (Sade) I respect you, your the only D-block with balls too bad the Puanis and Lascanod ones are pussies.

Brother I thank you for respecting the Noble Sade clan. But if you really want dowladnimo, then quit hating on my fellow Daarood cousins. Somalis need to quit the clan grudges and rebuild our country, we are already a laughing stock to the world. We can change that easily if we unite

Now support my federal region proposals.

jamal9 wrote:there is no such thing as Dervish state, that land belongs to Somaliland and Somaliland alone. It is not up for negotiations whatsoever.

This thread is not for secessionist filthy eydoors but for Noble Isaaq that believe in Somalia. If you are a filthy eydoor (secessionist) then no point participating in this thread.

Retard Somalis arguing about their own lands when they should be fighting tooth and nail for their occupied lands that you all know off.....

STARKAST wrote:Retard Somalis arguing about their own lands when they should be fighting tooth and nail for their occupied lands that you all know off.....

This map is not clan based and I wish Somalis not too attack this suggestion because of clan. I put Marehan land with Shabelle State and put Habar Gidir land with Punt State. Somalis need to work together and realise that federal system is not clan based.

Doesn't look realistic to me because Puntland and Galmudug would never unite. Clannism or not, Puntland has been established for a long time and it intends to stay that way; its a done deal. Secondly if this is just based on what your ideal map of a somalia; then i would say it has major flaws. You cant expect Hobyo which is hundreds of miles away to economically be tied to Bosaso port - it is simply too far away ; also the communities in the two differ culturally and historically have not been tied to one another. What would be better is that Galmudug unites with shabelle land.

STARKAST wrote:Retard Somalis arguing about their own lands when they should be fighting tooth and nail for their occupied lands that you all know off.....

Like the qaxooti's want to be free, seems like they are happy being Ethiopians.

Estarix wrote:Doesn't look realistic to me because Puntland and Galmudug would never unite. Clannism or not, Puntland has been established for a long time and it intends to stay that way; its a done deal. Secondly if this is just based on what your ideal map of a somalia; then i would say it has major flaws. You cant expect Hobyo which is hundreds of miles away to economically be tied to Bosaso port - it is simply too far away ; also the communities in the two differ culturally and historically have not been tied to one another. What would be better is that Galmudug unites with shabelle land.

We can divide the 18 regions of Somalia otherwise every region would want to divide. For instance the Isaaq community in Western Sanaag would want to split, the Marehan community in North Galgaduud would want to split etc. The clans need to compromise because the reality is that federalism should not be mixed with clans. The Habar Gidir in Mudug have to join Punt state simple as that.

XimanJaale wrote:

Estarix wrote:Doesn't look realistic to me because Puntland and Galmudug would never unite. Clannism or not, Puntland has been established for a long time and it intends to stay that way; its a done deal. Secondly if this is just based on what your ideal map of a somalia; then i would say it has major flaws. You cant expect Hobyo which is hundreds of miles away to economically be tied to Bosaso port - it is simply too far away ; also the communities in the two differ culturally and historically have not been tied to one another. What would be better is that Galmudug unites with shabelle land.

We can divide the 18 regions of Somalia otherwise every region would want to divide. For instance the Isaaq community in Western Sanaag would want to split, the Marehan community in North Galgaduud would want to split etc. The clans need to compromise because the reality is that federalism should not be mixed with clans. The Habar Gidir in Mudug have to join Punt state simple as that.

Isaaq have real power i.e the gun, good luck trying to give their lands to lax lax.