SomaliNet Forums

He says all the progress Somalia made under Farmajoo is now gone ruined by Xassan Shaikh who has turned our country into a criminal enterprise do you agree with the Ogaden MP from NFD ?

Darood kooda jooga kenya macal qabilste weyan.waliga ma maqleysid dir iyo hawiya degha kenya oo siyasada somalia ka hadla. Kenya darod wa ku minority sida ey ku yaheen somalia .

Given the fact this faarax was a leading figure in the now defunct CBB and zealous formajite to boot, it is unlikely any judgement he forms of the current Villa Somalia occupant, Mr. gurguurte, will be impartial.

barbarossa wrote: Sat Apr 22, 2023 6:14 pm Given the fact this faarax was a leading figure in the now defunct CBB and zealous formajite to boot, it is unlikely any judgement he forms of the current Villa Somalia occupant, Mr. gurguurte, will be impartial.

I don't mean to pick on you, but you just engaged in the single most irritating illogical fallacy that so many layman resort to (so irritating to me because of its pervasiveness).

This is called the Correlation/Causation fallacy

The argument here is Mr Farah says Mr. HSM turned the government into a criminal enterprise.

You did not address the argument.

You took a well known correlation to dismiss the very nature of addressing the causation important to an answer to the argument.

Namely, we know Mr Farah is opposed to HSM. Without even needing to deal with the substance of that like maybe that is the case because we all know HSM is a 'well known crook' who showed us his ethics during a previous term----without even needing to deal with that, his opposition or support to HSM is independent of HSM's 'actions' as President. It is a "Correlation."

The argument still is unaddressed unless there is an indictment of the "causation" to his charge.

Namely, unless you can disprove that HSM is a crook who has turned the government into a criminal enterprise.

To disprove that, one has to address 'what' Mr. Farah said, not 'who' he is.

Maalim made observations of the low corruption in the Farmajoo administration and apparently according to Barbarosso that makes you a fanatical Farmajoo supporter

Eid Mubarak
Hsm …waa toog toog dhalay