SomaliNet Forums

Hildiid,

Your comprehension of the posted articles, and of DNA in general, is abysmal. Just on a lark, try this one, showing early migration from the Levant to Africa and later migration of the Cardial culture ( Pottery-making Pre-pottery Neolithic descendants from Biblos/northern Levant) crossing ...

E1b1b is African.The Natufians just happen to carry this haologroup as well.

Somalis are not descendants of Natufians but some of our autosomal DNA share similar origin with that of Natufians and its not surprising given that these autosomes represent our common ancestry (Afro-Asiatic).

In ...

E1b1b is African.The Natufians just happen to carry this haologroup as well.

Somalis are not descendants of Natufians but some of our autosomal DNA share similar origin with that of Natufians and its not surprising given that these autosomes represent our common ancestry (Afro-Asiatic).

In ...

You're not a Natufian descendant.

One of your ancestors (Y-DNA) comes from the Horn of Africa. Your autosomal DNA is European.


I am absolutely a Natufian descendant. I am E1b1b1c1a, which traces directly back. E1b1b = M123. E-L29 is just downstream.

https://yhrd.org/tools/branch/E1b1b ...

It's normal scholarly caution to use alleged and claims since no study has been done, but she never called it fake either.
[/quote]

I read that very differently from you. She doesn't use that language anywhere else in the paper, nor anywhere else at all that I have seen. My thinking is that Sada ...

Grant is Jewish he hates anything Somaliland and Isaaq and he knows sadaat nation will hunt his people down in the end of times...


My 23andme says I am E-L29 = E1b1b1c1a. These are Natufian descendants, farmers who first settled Europe after the Ice Age and the same folks who provided the ...

The PDF isn't available and no where has Sado addressed these artifacts to my knowledge that's why I am skeptical.



I use quotation marks when I am quoting someone and leave them off when I am speaking for myself. Here Sada is using quote marks to show she is quoting someone else, and not ...

Sada Mire :

https://www.academia.edu/14372861/Mapping_the_Archaeology_of_Somaliland_Religion_Art_Script_Time_Urbanism_Trade_and_Empire

The objects are associated with rock cairns, which means they have no context or provenience and therefore no meaning or historical value. No archaeologist ...

Grant is Jewish he hates anything Somaliland and Isaaq and he knows sadaat nation will hunt his people down in the end of times...


My 23andme says I am E-L29 = E1b1b1c1a. These are Natufian descendants, farmers who first settled Europe after the Ice Age and the same folks who provided the ...

Sada Mire :

https://www.academia.edu/14372861/Mapping_the_Archaeology_of_Somaliland_Religion_Art_Script_Time_Urbanism_Trade_and_Empire

The objects are associated with rock cairns, which means they have no context or provenience and therefore no meaning or historical value. No archaeologist ...

Sada Mire :

https://www.academia.edu/14372861/Mapping_the_Archaeology_of_Somaliland_Religion_Art_Script_Time_Urbanism_Trade_and_Empire

The objects are associated with rock cairns, which means they have no context or provenience and therefore no meaning or historical value. No archaeologist will ...

The Somali Peace Corp group, which has a fair number of Jewish members, has sent Ilhan a letter of support. I found this comment from the group (not in the letter) especially to the point.

"As one with a Jewish background and a lover of Israel who lived there for three years and wrote a ...

Daleys,

https://www.bloomberg.com/quicktake/japan-s-shrinking-population

"Japan’s population of 127 million is forecast to shrink by about one-third in the next five decades. The proportion of over-64-year-olds — currently about a quarter — is expected to reach 38 percent in that time frame ...

Grant

I heard you're an American Jew. Whats up with that. Why were you hiding behind an Anglo-American identity?


We have been through this many times. I was raised Mormon but left the Church when I turned 18 and could. I served in the Peace Corps in Somalia rather than a Church mission as ...

The Somali Peace Corp group, which has a fair number of Jewish members, has sent Ilhan a letter of support. I found this comment from the group (not in the letter) especially to the point.

"As one with a Jewish background and a lover of Israel who lived there for three years and wrote a doctoral ...