Bro, on the whole, the islamic empire at that time was under Shariica law. Go read the famous islamic history books. Yaziid drinking alcohol doesn't mean shit. The guy who tortured Axmed ibn hanbal believe the Quran was created, which was worse than drinking alcohol, and no one denied that the state he controlled was an islamic state.your still making proboganda when your sayind under yazeeed he in controll some kind a islamic state? NO SXB YAZIIID was the leader of failed state and even hes father mucaawiya was too the leader of failed state because of muslims were in civil war killing eachother
AND how can you say yazeed time sharia was in tact, thats agains pure proboganda yazeed time there was no sharia because yazeed himself according imaam shaafici ( yazeeed) was alkohol dricker and murdare too bacause he kills not only hussein, but he kills even children of hussien. what kind of islamic sharia state is that?
You need to know the fiqi behind what constitutes an islamic state, instead of using your intellect yalaxoow.
An Islamic state is a state whose basis is Shariica law, and who most of its law are in accordance with the Shariica.
Like i said, you are using your faulty intellect, and not following fiqi principles. By fiqh standards, They were both Islamic states. Mucaawiya only become the amiir after Cali died, so i don't know why you mention the fact that he fought Cali.not only yazeed even hes father mucaaawiya had no islamic state or shariica law because, mucaaawiya was fighting cali because of he wanted to become the ruler madaxweyne i dhahaaay, khaliif i dhahaay qabiilkeeyga laandheere bin umayad . power-struggle like laandheere USC VS SNM VS SSDF.
What standard are you using to judge what is an Islamic state or not?
Yes, thats true, and for that Mucaawiya was wrong. That doesn't mean that when he replaced Xasan as amir, he wasn't the rightul amir. All of the major sahaba pledged allegiance to Mucaawiya. Do you think they'd pledge allegieance to a leader who controlled a state that wasn't islamic? Is that how much little faith you have in the sahabah?mucaaawiya took in controll shaaam suuriya, and cali rc was in controll hijaaas mucaawiya was fighting cali because of mucaawiya wanted to become( president) khaliifa( bakuhaana).
Why do you think the shiicas beat themselves every year? Because they regret betraying Xussein. On the day that he died, only his family was left. The shiica who told him to come to iraq, FLED. THEY FLED AND LET XUSSEIN die. Had xussein known that they wouldn't defend him, he would not have gone to iraaq and he would have not gotten killed.MELO ABOUT PEOPLE OF KUFA your blaiming the killings of hussein and hes children not yezeed but people of kuffa.
thats wahaabi excuse again. XUSEEEN fled for hes life. he run away to kuffa ciraaaaq, from xijaaaz. people of makka did not defend xuseeen, he run away for hes live, he knew yazeed is going to kill him, and yazeeed he come after him to kuffa and yes he killed him, he and hes children.
like people of makah could not defend xuseen also people of kuffa could not because of powerfull army of binu umayad clan whichs yazeeed army
It was those people who become the first shiica you see today. The ones who told xussein "COME IRAQ, WE'LL DEFEND YOU" only to flee when Yaziid came. That's why they beat themselves every year.and people of kuffa was civilians they can not defend invading army.. yazeed army they did not kill only hussein but they killed even hes children young as 1 years old subxaana allah.
and you dont blame that yazeed but people he run away kuffa. how stupid is this walaahi.
believe in the time of hussein shiica did not exist.. all shiica was formed purely after xuseen and hes children most disgusting way, because of unger the ay dareemeen people of kuffaaa and other places shiicisim was born in that time.
