Triangle state

[Xildiiid]

I want the users of this term to define it properly.

[LightAtNight]

Hargeisa, burco and Berbera. These are the main cities that together make up the triangle state

[Xildiiid]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

[HusseinHassan]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

[LightAtNight]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

I dont think Somaliland consists of just isaac, but mainly isaac. The reason why these three cities are cited is because they are the main cities that make up Somaliland. Other settlements are too insignificant to be considered.

[waraabe251]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

I dont think Somaliland consists of just isaac, but mainly isaac. The reason why these three cities are cited is because they are the main cities that make up Somaliland. Other settlements are too insignificant to be considered.

so by that reasoning, Somalia is only Mogadishu and boosaso

[Xildiiid]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

Cerigaabo, Caynaba and Oog = major Isaaq towns now gtfo

[Hawdian]

Triangle is a very interesting shape and certainly there is such thing as triangular systems, administrations and even states. One of the best example is the AMISOM triangle also known as AMISOMIA in Tri-Ugandisho. It controls three institutions in a refugee camp the size of two suburbs in Nairobi.



Wanna kill a Hutu? Why not hire sniper Hawdian (The Geeljire Blackwaters)

[LightAtNight]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

I dont think Somaliland consists of just isaac, but mainly isaac. The reason why these three cities are cited is because they are the main cities that make up Somaliland. Other settlements are too insignificant to be considered.

so by that reasoning, Somalia is only Mogadishu and boosaso

Bossaso is too insignificant. I would say mogadishu, Kismayo

[thegoodshepherd]

This what they mean:

The three main isaaq cities are each 100 miles from the other.
Oog, caynabo and ceerigabo are villages, let alone towns.

[ZubeirAwal]

Triangle is a very interesting shape and certainly there is such thing as triangular systems, administrations and even states. One of the best example is the AMISOM triangle also known as AMISOMIA in Tri-Ugandisho. It controls three institutions in a refugee camp the size of two suburbs in Nairobi.



Wanna kill a Hutu? Why not hire sniper Hawdian (The Geeljire Blackwaters)

[HusseinHassan]

This what they mean:

The three main isaaq cities are each 100 miles from the other.
Oog, caynabo and ceerigabo are villages, let alone towns.

you forgot to add that ceerigaabo is shared between darod and isaaq.

[waraabe251]

Ceerigabo is not shared dhabacyo boy, it is a HY city. Few hj and wsgeli live there but they are just guests

[Xildiiid]

So by your definition - Isaaq inhabit these three towns only. Somaliland = Isaaq and therefore these three towns make up Somaliland hence the "triangle state".


What about other major Isaaq towns such as Cerigaabo, Caynaba, Oog. When did Somaliland become Isaaq? How accurate is this so called "triangle" when Isaaq live both to the west and to the east of it?

I dont think Somaliland consists of just isaac, but mainly isaac. The reason why these three cities are cited is because they are the main cities that make up Somaliland. Other settlements are too insignificant to be considered.

The weakest argument I've ever seen and you disproved yourself in your response. A country's territorial claims does not consist of towns and cities only but rural land as well which is the waste majority. It doesn't matter if the three major towns of SL are Hargeysa, Burco and Berbera. It still doesn't make Somaliland a "Triangle state"

[thegoodshepherd]

The weakest argument I've ever seen and you disproved yourself in your response. A country's territorial claims does not consist of towns and cities only but rural land as well which is the waste majority. It doesn't matter if the three major towns of SL are Hargeysa, Burco and Berbera. It still doesn't make Somaliland a "Triangle state"

Bro the total population of Berbera in July is sometimes estimated at 40,000 people. The two main cities are Burco and Hargeisa.