burcaawi14 wrote:
How is pre Mohammed(scw ) the arab pagan era? The people alive during the stage between two messages, when one becomes corrupt and the other not revealed is known as fitrah and those who fell into jahilihya before the new message was revealed, well their judgement is different with Allah than those who made kufr( reject/deny) the holy message. The vast majority of ulama consider the prophets parents as muwaahidoon. The rituals are in essence monotheistic as they weren't intitially about worshiping tangible objects. Your small mind can't comprehend the fact of symbolism. Allah is free of time, space, direction etc and other vices of creation therefor you cant face allah in prayer. Before muhammad scw there were many prophets. The rituals have their basis in monotheism, just like many Christian texts have their basis in monotheistic beliefs although they were corrupted over time. & there is no contradiction between the quran and hadith, the contradiction is between your intelllect and your understanding. The actual foundation of he kaba itself was there before Abraham(as) built on it. Even early on in Muhammad's time they weren't facing the kacba but were facing AL Quds in Jerusalem, so your argument of Arab worship is debunked in every way .
Takale the crescent has NOTHING to do with Islam. It was adopted by the ottomans and doesn't have a basis in early Islam, so cut the bullshit about worshipping the moon because this symbolism is not in the foundation of Islam.
I'm fully aware of what Islamic dogma propounds but I have no good reason or evidence to believe it's remotely true.
Nothing was ever corrupted because Islam is syncretic religion combining Jewish, Christian and pagan Arab ideas. To rationalize the blatant aping of Jewish and Christian doctrinal concepts, Muslims invented the red herring of "corruption." And to repudiate pre-Islamic pagan Arab practices Mohammed wanted to change, Muslims again concocted another red herring of Jaahiliya.
What do you mean rituals are monotheistic? The Hajj was pagan/polytheist Arab ritual; polytheism is the antithesis of monotheism. And you are also wrong about the Christianity originating from monotheism. Both Judiasm and Christiniaty originated from existing pagan or polytheistic believes. This is how all religions evolve; there's nothing new under the sun just rehashing of old ideas under new garb.