French Butler,Jabuutawi wrote: Sun Aug 04, 2019 4:11 pm Gaalamadow,
Your only counterpoint is that sampling is too small to make definitive answer on the haplogroups. Gloss over as you wish but the reality, not withstanding STRs, is that your ignoble clan has two, perhaps more, haplogroups which split 50,000 years ago! Is that when the fake ‘Sheikh’ came to northern Somalia?
STRs splits are only few hundred years or thousands, not the 50, 000 years of separation.
Some of you were hunter and gatherers, no doubt. Check the habr Jeclo results.
As for Zeilac, it was long abandoned (continuous bombardment by the Portuguese) before your Idoor uncle, several hundred years later, begged the Yemenis to take over the crumbling fort with their assistance. He dare not venture outside. His own son was slaughtered by an Ciise man, and he couldn’t do squat about it. The countryside belonged to us and will in the future.
You have a problem with basic comprehension.
As I’ve pointed out, larger clans have diverse origin with different genetic markers.
In Darod you’ll find find individuals carrying E-V32, J1 and T-M70.
In Hawiye you’ll find E-V32, R1a (some Sheikhaal) and T-M70.
In some cases, some of the individuals carrying E-V32 within the same clan are not closely related and based on STR share a common ancestor that lived thousands of years before the alleged clan patriarch existed. Belonging to the same subclade doesn’t automatically mean you’re closely related.
Isaaq is not different in this regard because of the size of our clan. You’ll find E-V32, T-M70 and E-V16.
Paleolithic Horn of Africans carried E-V16 and most likely the related E-M35 as well, the quintessential Afro-Asiatic marker. Calling a specific haplogroup “Hunter Gatherer” is an indication of your xaywaan brain.
Stop lying about Zeila. Emir Sharmarke Ali Salih conquered the land and coast from the Yemeni Ayrabs. The same Ayrabs that ruled the town and forbade your kin and Gudabirsi from entering.
Another baseless lie. The Emirs son was based in Berbera and never came into contact with the pagan Ciise Waraabe. He was wounded and killed in intertribal war in Berbera.
We rule Zeila today just like 1825 and there’s nothing you or your French master can do about it.