Muslims Against Sharia

[QansaGabeyle]

I call for this topic to be deleted and that link removed immediately. You are not even a muslim if you are against the sharica laws.

[Wareer]

It is crazy how these people think that Somalis comply not by the Sharia.

[Shilling]

You are not even a Muslim if you are against the sharica laws.

If you import xaran substance such as pork or alcohol in Somalia you might risk losing your life, Somalis practice what the homeless group in Asmara seems to preach by mouth. Before this Al-shabaab group even surfaced people that had blood on their hands were dealt with according to the teaching of our religion, I have heard of this myself since it was widely forced in Puntland. My point is Sharia Law is already in affect in Somalia and if those that seem to be preaching it now want to contribute, then lets do it in a fashionable way without calling for peoples heads. I doubt this is too much to ask.

[Madd_Scientist_]

You can't be a muslim and against Sharia laws.

[Enlightened~Sista]

The following verses promote divisiveness and religious hatred, bigotry and discrimination. They must be either removed from the Koran or declared outdated and invalid, and marked as such.

Wow ..these people are not Muslims..who do they think they are fooling

[Diyeeshaha_Tolka]

there are so many websites using muslim names but are owned by yahuudiin and this one is one of them ,ha layska ilaaliyo and i would ask the mod to deleted this topic,,

[934]

[quote="Brav3Heart"]

My question is can you be a muslim and be against the sharia?
quote]

Yes and NO!

One can be agaisnt the People rallying for Islamic Sharia law to be implimented, and still be muslim.

From the whole of the muslim populatin in the world how many country can be said their Islamic Sharia law is anything to be desired? Saudi Arabia? Farax please!

[eternauta]

From the whole of the muslim populatin in the world how many country can be said their Islamic Sharia law is anything to be desired? Saudi Arabia? Farax please!

Most everyone (except you and a few others) knows Saudi Arabia's is a secular monarchy. Besides, for secular Muslims (such as you), they wouldn't find anything to be desired in Islamic Sharia law. So, don't make it sound like you support or care about Islamic Sharia law.

[Grant]

Were the Hudud laws in Pakistan Sharica? How about the "strict" Wahaabi interpretation of Sharica as in Saudi Arabia? How about what is going on in the Sudan?

I would like someone to define what Sharica is before we get too carried away. As far as I have been able to tell this concept is about as well defined as is "muslim", i.e. much of it is cultural and there is NO general agreement.

[eternauta]

I would like someone to define what Sharica is before we get too carried away.

This issue concerns Muslims. An atheist isn't part of we.

[Enlightened~Sista]

eternauta..hes not athiest! He's a believer.

[Grant]

I would like someone to define what Sharica is before we get too carried away.

This issue concerns Muslims. An atheist isn't part of we.

This post is outrageous on several levels.

You want to impose an undefined system of laws on the entire world. You will not give non-Muslims any say in what these laws are, and you are saying non-Muslims should not be concerned with what these laws are?

I think we ALL need a definition here. So far you are just talking pie-in-the sky...

[Aliyah99]

A muslim can be against Sharia law that is not implemented fairly like in Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan under Taliban.

[Enlightened~Sista]

There are many problems with Sharia law..as it has been interpretated by men(fuqaha)..and it is not error free..and which faqeeh should we follow? Malik, Shaficii hanafi? hanbali?

In any case guidance should be sought from the Qur'an, the authenticated sayings of the Prophet (p) which correspond with the Qur'an..and local customs/traditions ('urf) that dont conflict with the Qur'an for instance.

The problem is people mixed ignorance with religion and are passing it off as 'Sharia'

[Quadratic]

Enlightened,

The schools of jurisprudence(the mad-habs) follow the Quran and the Sunnah. All the leading scholars, the most famous jurists, the four, said if what they have as evidence contradicts the Quran or the Sunnah, it is not part of their Mad-Hab. Sometimes the scholars used a weak Hadith to come to a conclusion about something, you pick and choose out of the four based on the strongest evidence, that way, you are not blindly accepting anyone's take on a religious view but merely agreeing with the Scholar. Hope that clarifies something for you. There is never a problem with Sharia law.


Grant


Here is a good start, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharia