4.5 system is a racist institution

[peace-]

lol somalis...........walahay they are the most strange people on earth................they are permanently divide by the most artificial social construction ever(qabil) and the only time they unite is they are talking about their hopelessness........ they would say " somalia is fuc.ked" they will agree on this but once you asked why they will say well "it is all becuase of tribe x"

[FAH1223]

lol somalis...........walahay they are the most strange people on earth................they are permanently divide by the most artificial social construction ever(qabil) and the only time they unite is they are talking about their hopelessness........ they would say " somalia is fuc.ked" they will agree on this but once you asked why they will say well "it is all becuase of tribe x"

somalia is focked cause of all somalis

no hope, no future

[Somaliman50]

sxb if there are to be leaders, it has to be a hawiye and a southern darood. no way should a harti be allowed to take office. ma laba madaxweyne oo majeerteen aa dalka ka talinaya? waa xaq daro sxn

[Muhammad bin Harti]

4.5 is the only sensible thing we can agree. If anything darood should get another .5, because we got the most land and probably the biggest population in somalia.

[The_Emperior5]

4.5 is the only sensible thing we can agree. If anything darood should get another .5, because we got the most land and probably the biggest population in somalia.

Not really Darod most of their land is outside Somalia puntland 3 province and gedo and parts of the jubba . and that’s it But 4.5 is oke deal for somalia for now.

[Muhammad bin Harti]

Darood:

Bari,
Nugaal,
Sanaag,
Gedo,
Lower Juba,
Middle Juba
1/2 Galgadud
1/2 Mudug,
1/2 Sool

Total = 7.5


Hawiye:

1/2 Galgadud
1/2 Mudug
Hiiraan
Benadir (post 1991)
1/2 Lower Shabelle
1/2 Middle Shabelle

Total = 4

Isaaq:

Togdheer
Waqooyi Galbeed
1/2 Awdal
1/2 Sool

Total = 3

Others:

Bay
Bakool
1/2 Lower Shabelle
1/2 Middle Shabelle

Total = 2

CONCLUSION: Darood should get more seats!

[The_Emperior5]

Muhammad bin harti we should not confuse things Somalia has 12 provinces the t f g charter is 4.5 only counts those 12 province. And since when did upper jubba became the land of the jeberti. And since when did cabuudwaaq became 50 of galguduud..

ps u added sanaag in to the jeberti gobols while its the brith place of beesha iidoor atleast say it 50 50 like you said with the other regions. such as sool

[Bazuuka]

4.5 Is the best system we have 6 MP and got nothing to complain

[The_Emperior5]

bazuuka what is ur clan.

[AhlulbaytSoldier]

I see 4.5 system as dooro and eelay conspiracy against Hawiye

[snoop12]

i think this is a racist system and i'm not saying this because i have any sympathy for the .5, but the whole concept of building a country via tribal means discusses me, it should be build with some basic SHARIA

i will support a government who has no dependence on tribal culture!!!

i want a government that consist of educated individuals who have been chosen from each region NOT selected from each tribe!!

we should have a government who fight racism first and foremost, i know tribalism cannot be completely eradicated but i am confident that a government can reduce it significantly, so that this disease does not hold back the country from reaching its potential.


i believe this was what MSB AUN fought for and thanks to his struggle and Gods blessings a marexan loved their mursade neighbor, a majerten respected their raxanweyn neighbor without any tribal influence.

even if we deny MSB AUN struggle and achievements due to present tribalism/racism or due to political reasons, we should not hesitate to destroy racism as it is the cancer of the mind and the land.

[Cumar-Labasuul]

Horta why are Hawiye complaining they at least have 1 of the 4.5 whilst Isaaq part of the big 3 clans of somalia have to share 1 with the small population samaroon and issa. Also Isaaq shouldn't have to share 1 because we are not even Dir. It should be 7 system where:
Hawiye = 1.5
Darood = 1.5
Isaaq = 1.5
Dir = 1
D&M = 1
Others = 0.5

[The_Emperior5]

labasuul we are not part of somalia calan ba ino tagaan there for we do not need seats in the so called government in the south , we do need some influance so but kuwa dirta sheegta ha iska tagaan meeshaas. and we will see what they get. 28 kursi.

[FAH1223]

82%

maybe somalis have some principle left in their brains

or maybe they voted yes because their clan is "underrepresented"

[PosH]

The 0.5'ers voted multiple times.