Should Amiir Godane have a monument in Moqdisho?

[sahal80]

Al shabaab was founded during the islamic courts rule by a group of somalilanders who studied in pakistan-caraale, godane and their sheikh al afghani who was killed by godane in barawe- these guys had plans to destroy the courts by announcing the international jihad

Its founder and first leader was ismaciile caraale arrested by the CIA in djibouti on his way to sudan to cure his wounds

He was sent to guantanamo but was freed after 3 years and was sent back to hargeysa

His deputy was ahmed madobe but he was replaced by ahmed godane

Adan ceerow was never amir/leader, he was kinda defence minister or a commander of army who conquered the south, the amir was ahmed godane who made his deputy al afghani(maybe they were afraid to involve in this publically for clan reasons but they had the foreing connections who decided who will be the leader bc of their financial roles)

Ahmed godane use to be a fellow of hassan dahir during the al itixaad era and use to ask him logistics for his waqooyi bases but he has changed into an international jihad

These guys who had jihadist influence on the islamic courts have used indhocade the defence minister of the courts to attack ethiopia so they can change the mission from a somali to an international jihad.

[Substance]

Right next to the monument of Museveni.


Would TS have the same opinion if the coward Godane took his wars to waqooyi galbeed?

[samatar133]

Al shabaab was founded during the islamic courts rule by a group of somalilanders who studied in pakistan-caraale, godane and their sheikh al afghani who was killed by godane in barawe- these guys had plans to destroy the courts by announcing the international jihad

Its founder and first leader was ismaciile caraale arrested by the CIA in djibouti on his way to sudan to cure his wounds

He was sent to guantanamo but was freed after 3 years and was sent back to hargeysa

His deputy was ahmed madobe but he was replaced by ahmed godane

Adan ceerow was never amir/leader, he was kinda defence minister or a commander of army who conquered the south, the amir was ahmed godane who made his deputy al afghani.

Ahmed godane use to be a fellow of hassan dahir during al itixaad era and use to ask him logistics for his waqooyi bases but he has changed into an international jihad

These guys who had jihadist influence on the islamic courts have used indhocade the defence minister of the courts to attack ethiopia so they can change the mission from a somali to an international jihad.

You know your staff
but don't you agree the Amiir deserve a monument for his achievement against Ethiopia and other infidel invaders?

[sahal80]

Al shabaab was founded during the islamic courts rule by a group of somalilanders who studied in pakistan-caraale, godane and their sheikh al afghani who was killed by godane in barawe- these guys had plans to destroy the courts by announcing the international jihad

Its founder and first leader was ismaciile caraale arrested by the CIA in djibouti on his way to sudan to cure his wounds

He was sent to guantanamo but was freed after 3 years and was sent back to hargeysa

His deputy was ahmed madobe but he was replaced by ahmed godane

Adan ceerow was never amir/leader, he was kinda defence minister or a commander of army who conquered the south, the amir was ahmed godane who made his deputy al afghani.

Ahmed godane use to be a fellow of hassan dahir during al itixaad era and use to ask him logistics for his waqooyi bases but he has changed into an international jihad

These guys who had jihadist influence on the islamic courts have used indhocade the defence minister of the courts to attack ethiopia so they can change the mission from a somali to an international jihad.

You know your staff
but don't you agree the Amiir deserve a monument for his achievement against Ethiopia and other infidel invaders?

supposed to become a security officer lol

I consider him an arab agent who destroyed the islamic courts from inside. His time is up!

[GIJaamac]

No, but morgan should have a one in Hargeysa.


Sahal

Ayrow was the amir and the founder of Al-shabaab and he was true to his cause. That's why his U.S had to spend millions of dollars to kill him.
Don't you ever wonder why westerns don't try to find godane the same way as Cayrow. I think he's on CIA's payroll.

[samatar133]

Sahal
A security officer in Somalia?
War hooy aayar chips taada isaga cun UK . I know this murusade guy from the UK who was a high ranking intelligence officer in Muqdiosho. last time I have seen he was back to the UK running for his life after he was accused of illegally assassinating three HG alshabaab prisoners and then dumping their bodies in Jaziira beach Of-course he denies that.

I don't think Godane is an Arab agent but what do you consider Axmed Guray and Sayidka Cabulle xassan? do they deserve monuments in the capital?

[BigBreak]

there should be a monument for both abdullahi yusuf and general gabre together in mogadishu while there should be a monument of maxamed f. caydiid (aun) in either kismayo or bosaso

[Warabaha]

Siyad in hargeisa, godane in mogadisho, caydiid in bosaso and kismayo,

[sahal80]

No, but morgan should have a one in Hargeysa.


Sahal

Ayrow was the amir and the founder of Al-shabaab and he was true to his cause. That's why his U.S had to spend millions of dollars to kill him.
Don't you ever wonder why westerns don't try to find godane the same way as Cayrow. I think he's on CIA's payroll.

bro, cayrow was never ever an amir of al shabaab rather a defence minister if you want an idependent experts i will show you. al shabad had only two amirs; ismael arale and ahmed godane.
maybe the first amir was an abgaal but him, godane, al afghani have been into pakistan and visited afghanistan so they had the foreing connections, he was replaced by godane after his arrest.
http://www.voanews.com/content/somalia_ ... 33919.html


“After a long meeting we agreed to unite under a Jihadi system different from other systems," said Madobe. "We took the name al-Shabab. They proposed Ismail Arale, who studied in Pakistan, to be the leader and I was chosen the deputy on behalf of Raskamboni.”

The group attempted to establish a small Islamic emirate within in the UIC but this move was interrupted by the incursion of Ethiopian troops into Somalia. By late 2006, the UIC was routed and many of its leaders fled the country. In February 2007, Ahmed Madobe was wounded by U.S. airstrikes in the Lower Jubba region and subsequently captured by the Ethiopian troops.

Three months later in May, al-Shabab’s leader, Ismail Arale, was captured in Djibouti by CIA on his way to Eretria and sent to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Al-Shabab reacted swiftly and replaced them both. Ahmed Abdi Godane, also known as Mukhtar Abu Zubayr, took the helm and remains the group’s emir."



as i dont know his clan im not sure if he is this guy because his name is mohamed ismacil carale and this one says sudi an abgaal name


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdullahi_Sudi_Arale

"Ahmed Godane, Alshabab Supreme leader who often imitates Mullah Omar is from Somaliland. Shirwac the Alshabab-American, blew himself in Hargeisa was from Somaliland., American-Aslbabab martyr, is from Somaliland. Mohamed Almuhajiri, Alshabab martyr, is from Somaliland.Mohamed Al-Muhajiri, Alshabab from Toronto was also from Somaliland.Two Somali detainees, Mohammed Soliman Barre and Ismael Arale, were transferred to regional authorities in Somaliland.The Danish cartoonist attacker was also from Somaliland.


samatar just ate it a hour ago

[zidane88]

A "burka" wearing monument would be good for Godane.

[XimanJaale]

Sahal,

Al-Shabaab first ever leader was Ceyroow. His group were of Abu Roboow, Shongole and the likes.

A "burka" wearing monument would be good for Godane.

[sahal80]

Sahal,

Al-Shabaab first ever leader was Ceyroow. His group were of Abu Roboow, Shongole and the likes.

A "burka" wearing monument would be good for Godane.

no, we have an independent experts on al shabaab!
adan cayrow was the head of the military/jihadist wing in the islamic courts and one of the guys who spoiled it by pushing for to declare jihad againist ethiopia so that the islamic project can change from from an islamic somali project to an international jihadist project!

when we are talking about who is the founder of al islaax, it will be sheikh garyare from aw khudub regardless of its other founding members from sheekhal, reerow hassan and hawadle in 1979 in saudi arabia but that doesnt mean he is the one who brought dacwat al ikhwan to somalia, the man who did that was sheikh mohamed macalin. the difference is that sheikh mohamed mocalin did not make contacts with the international ikhwan for fear that he may got fired from his egyptian university-al azhar in the 50s as he revealed to the somali bbc
the same way, it was ismael arale who founded al shabaab and his deputy was ahmed madobe. after caraale was arrested, he got replaced straight by godane and abu mansour was made his deputy and the spokesperson, afghani kinda monazir-theorist-shangole head of dacwa, aden cayrow head of maktab al difaac. because of his military leadership people mistakingly think of him being the predecessor of godane. FACTS!!.

[XimanJaale]

Sahal,

Al-Shabaab first ever leader was Ceyroow. His group were of Abu Roboow, Shongole and the likes.

A "burka" wearing monument would be good for Godane.

no, we have an independent experts on al shabaab!
adan cayrow was the head of the military/jihadist wing in the islamic courts and one of the guys who spoiled it by pushing for to declare jihad againist ethiopia so that the islamic project can change from from an islamic somali project to an international jihadist project!

when we are talking about who is the founder of al islaax, it will be sheikh garyare from aw khudub regardless of its other founding members from sheekhal, reerow hassan and hawadle in 1979 in saudi arabia but that doesnt mean he is the one who brought dacwat al ikhwan to somalia, the man who did that was sheikh mohamed macalin. the difference is that sheikh mohamed mocalin did not make contacts with the international ikhwan for fear that he may got fired from his egyptian university-al azhar in the 50s as he revealed to the somali bbc
the same way, it was ismael arale who founded al shabaab and his deputy was ahmed madobe. after caraale was arrested, he got replaced straight by godane and abu mansour was made his deputy and the spokesperson, afghani kinda monazir-theorist-shangole head of dacwa, aden cayrow head of maktab al difaac. because of his military leadership people mistakingly think of him being the predecessor of godane. FACTS!!.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aden_Hashi_Farah

[FarhanYare]

No cuz he is Isaaq.

[sahal80]

ximan why dhago adeeg? do you hate the facts? all that is a bulshit!!

this link says the leader araale was a somalilander also calls ayrow a training amir wich is a wrong transilation of maktab al difaac
http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=9NlM ... nse&source
http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=qZaJ ... e=bl&ots=E

"Three months later in May, al-Shabab’s leader, Ismail Arale, was captured in Djibouti by CIA on his way to Eretria and sent to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Al-Shabab reacted swiftly and replaced them both. Ahmed Abdi Godane, also known as Mukhtar Abu Zubayr, took the helm and remains the group’s emir.

How al-shabab operates"

the northerners had the foreing connections and all the resources, these guys have focked up the south because if the leaders were from south they would have accepted the reconciliation but the arab financiers were controlling the movement through the northeners. this is why if the northern leaders were killed a change may happen in its direction.