Sh'Mohamed Idris

[Lillaahiya]

Yes we should claim this guy as a Somali but deny countless others who have ajnabi fathers

[SecretAgent]

Hes eritrean,american,puntland citizen not somali

[Murax]

He's Xabashi (Eritrean). His Mom is Somali/Majerteen.

[Advo]

This shiek waa 100% Somali and has more right to our lands than tankar, abdi johnson, xplaya et , ilaahay noo daa I really enjoyed the maxaadiro.

[SecretAgent]

So a xabashi is closer to u then a somali

[Murax]

This shiek waa 100% Somali and has more right to our lands than tankar, abdi johnson, xplaya et , ilaahay noo daa I really enjoyed the maxaadiro.

No he's not, and this isn't a matter of if He's a good person or not. Somalis are a failure so Him not being Somali is hardly a indictment of His character. You are what Your Father is lineage wise and His Father is not Somali thus He's not Somali.

[JamalAddow]

This shiek waa 100% Somali and has more right to our lands than tankar, abdi johnson, xplaya et , ilaahay noo daa I really enjoyed the maxaadiro.

No he's not, and this isn't a matter of if He's a good person or not. Somalis are a failure so Him not being Somali is hardly a indictment of His character. You are what Your Father is lineage wise and His Father is not Somali thus He's not Somali.

Does it say in the Quran you are Somali because your father is. Bilal ra was an Arab from his father's side but his mother was a Xabashi. Qabil=/Somali. Bajunis, Barawaanis, Xamaraawis, Arab Salah and anyone else born in Somalia and can speak Somali is a Somali.

His mother is MJ so thats Somali enough for me. Obviously a Marehan or Dhulbahante wont feel the same.

What does 'fashilinteen' mean?

Race is a social construct. It doesn't exist same thing as Qabil. Only your sub clan exists i.e your direct extended family.

Sh' Idris is a patriotic person who cares deeply about Somali lands. He should get Somali nationality, was he born in Eritrea ?

He was born in Qandala.

[AbdiJohnson]

This shiek waa 100% Somali and has more right to our lands than tankar, abdi johnson, xplaya et , ilaahay noo daa I really enjoyed the maxaadiro.

First of all, I want nothing to do with that sad excuse you call a country that is now an AMISOM military base. Second of all, Somalis are a patrinlineal society so no you can't just accept anyone and anything into your ethnic group just because he can memorize a few lines in Arabic. But i guess that doesnt apply anymore the day you traded your rich ancient culture for a khameez. You will be using the same criteria for an Arab or anyone who is Muslim anyways and that fake constitution written up by your Turkish Funded Government (TFG) pretty much allows you to since the only criteria of becoming a Somali is by obtaining a passport from Bakara market fraudsters.

I am,

Abdi "Somali lands are now AU lands" Johnson

[Even123]

Focksake all this bickering for nothing!?!?!?!?!?!?!

Waryadaa this man is simply by ethnically Xaabashi while still being Somali by nationality!,......just like how we are ethnically Somalis while being ---- by nationality!

So yes he's by nationality,end off!

[Cherine]

It's not like he's dying to be a Somali.

[LobsterUnit]

It's not like he's dying to be a Somali.

naaya,how r u?

[GeoSeven]

This shiek waa 100% Somali and has more right to our lands than tankar, abdi johnson, xplaya et , ilaahay noo daa I really enjoyed the maxaadiro.

I disagree. Bless the Sheikh but in my books, an atheist Somali still has more rights to the country than a Muslim non Somali. Somalia isn't an international Muslim theme park, it's the land of the Somali.

[hydrogen]

This shiek waa 100% Somali and has more right to our lands than tankar, abdi johnson, xplaya et , ilaahay noo daa I really enjoyed the maxaadiro.

I disagree. Bless the Sheikh but in my books, an atheist Somali still has more rights to the country than a Muslim non Somali. Somalia isn't an international Muslim theme park, it's the land of the Somali.

[STARKAST]

@ Lillaahiya - Nope, we only deny those who are not worthy of being Somali also Somali mother Xabesha father is somewhat an exception same as Arab.

Qandala, the ancient port of the kingdom of Majerteenia. So he is of noble birth and is more noble than 100% of Somali public actors today aka Hasaan sheik etc etc.
@ GeoSeven, isn't that dated. You do know your a Arab if you speak Arabic and your from a Arab country.

Nonetheless i'm sure you can't argue at him being a Somali national.

[LiquidHYDROGEN]

This sheikh is eritrean, stop begging. A good man nonetheless.