The only way this plan can happen if force is applied on puntland via a army. Now do you honestly think this will happen ? The gov better focusing on lower shabelle land grab, and al shabab in villa somalia instead of foreign admins.
Geoseven, PL will only accept with whats in their interest, as any region will do.
Ximaanjalle, quit with this fake facade, somalia is all about clans and will always will be until new gen comes of age. after true reconciliation is completed, we just can't trust xamar with even running our garbage service. Now you understand
quark wrote:
lol you mistaken me for someone else. i don't believe in somalia as a nation let alone federalism and that's how i have been for many yrs. The faster we part ways the better as far as am concerned. Worst case scenario, PL will remain an autonomous state. Move along and concentrate on your lands
Let see where that takes you. I doubt every clan isolating itself will make individual clan rich, all it will do is make the country more fragmented and poor. If Majerteen thing they can leave the rest of Somalia, the desert hell-hole will remain a shithole.
Don't let those few mud-houses and aluminium roofs fool you. Puntland is in a worse living condition than the chaos of South-Central. The faster we part ways the more poor Puntland become. You dumb fool
STARKAST wrote:The only way this plan can happen if force is applied on puntland via a army. Now do you honestly think this will happen ? The gov better focusing on lower shabelle land grab, and al shabab in villa somalia instead of foreign admins.
Geoseven, PL will only accept with whats in their interest, as any region will do.
Ximaanjalle, quit with this fake facade, somalia is all about clans and will always will be until new gen comes of age. after true reconciliation is completed, we just can't trust xamar with even running our garbage service. Now you understand
Do you think the government forces are only in Mogadishu? From Gedo to Bakool to Hiiraan to Bay there are government forces. If Somali government armies wants to invade Puntland they can use the government forces in Galgaduud and Mudug specifically ciidamada qeybta 21AAD.
p.s. there is no land grab in Lower Shabelle. There was some clan fight but it has resolved. You don't hear of clan war in Lower Shabelle today do you?
But will they ? No ? Stop acting like a doqon, your Marehan. Go read a politics book or something.
Puntland is about 15 times the size of Djibouti with a port, all we need are ourselves, Xamar never has never and will never order reer bari to do anything, even MSB tried and failed
Nabadgaylo.
Last edited by STARKAST on Wed Aug 06, 2014 1:38 pm, edited 2 times in total.
GeoSeven wrote:It's wishful folly to think that Puntland would cede Northern Mudug to another federal state. It's all about rattling Puntland in order for them to accept an amending of the constitution since it would be in their best interest now. The only reason they were adamant that the constitution not be altered was because they might have flirted with the idea of incorporating Southern Mudug but that clearly won't happen now. They were always the only obstacle to adopting a new amendment regarding the assemblage of a federal state.
You are making out that Puntland wrote the constitution. It weren't Puntland that suggested the two region requirement. This whole process has nothing to do with rattling Puntland. If the government wants to alter the constitution they can do so. You are making out that Puntland owns the constitution.
This whole federal formation is a sincere process for the vision 2016. Since Somalia adopted the federal system it is time for the government to finalise it. The only time people can reject federalism is during the public vote for their constitution.
Ximan, if were talking about Somalia...Puntland is an integral part of the country and it really doesn't make sense to content for control of their second largest city (North Gaalkacyo if you want). Let's not kid ourselves, having designs on North Mudug is about as ridiculously counter productive as it can get and I doubt that's the case.
STARKAST wrote:But will they ? No ? Stop acting like a doqon, your Marehan. Go read a politics book or something.
Puntlnad is about 30 times the size of Djibouti with a port, all we need are ourselves, Xamar never has and never will order reer bari to do anything, even MSB tried and failed
Nabadgaylo.
I know the mentality of Puntlanders, it is I rule you or I will cut ties.
Well I got news for you dhabacyo's, you either come under the rule of the Somali government or you will forever remain a shithole. Djibouti is a recongised country and a multi-ethnic population. Whereas Puntland is not a recognised country and therefore when the federalism is finalised, no foreign investment can occur in Puntland without the consent of the Somali government.
We have seen when things went apeshit for Puntland when they try to bring oil companies there.
Whatever happens in Somali soil, the government of Somalia has the ownership and final say.
GeoSeven wrote:It's wishful folly to think that Puntland would cede Northern Mudug to another federal state. It's all about rattling Puntland in order for them to accept an amending of the constitution since it would be in their best interest now. The only reason they were adamant that the constitution not be altered was because they might have flirted with the idea of incorporating Southern Mudug but that clearly won't happen now. They were always the only obstacle to adopting a new amendment regarding the assemblage of a federal state.
That's what I like, Federalism or no Federalism is no longer the debate. The debate is now is How, and that's a debate I welcome. Personally I think half a gobol shouldn't make or break anything. Central State and Puntland can come to some sort of an agreement
GeoSeven wrote:
Ximan, if were talking about Somalia...Puntland is an integral part of the country and it really doesn't make sense to content for control of their second largest city (North Gaalkacyo if you want). Let's not kid ourselves, having designs on North Mudug is about as ridiculously counter productive as it can get and I doubt that's the case.
I never denied that Puntland is an integral part of the country. But they are not the owners of Somalia they are citizens just like the rest of Somalis. They have to follow the rules just like the rest of Somalis.
Nothing ridiculous of the Galgaduud and Mudug formation, what is ridiculous is people breaking the rules. Puntland has to accept that whole of Mudug is part of this federal state.
GIJaamac wrote:Cadaado is gonna be the capital of the of Mudug and Galgaduud. It's either our way or the highway !
brother this attitude is what is holding the great HabarGidir clan down. walaahi.
Reer Xaaji waa lagu qasbay ineey aqbalaan maamulkaan sababtoo ah dhoor maalin ka hor ayuu diiday Baarleex in Maamul loo dhiso Gobolada Dhexe hadana qasab ayuu ku aqbalay ee kuma uusan aqbalin jaceyl uu u qabo walaalihiisa HabarGidir.
this is how the maamul gonna be i think, the name will be Galmudug, the Capital will be Dhuusamareeb, and the President will go to Reer Xaaji Saleebaan.
sxb HabarGidir waa ineey isku sabraan oo walaaltinimo muujiyaan hadii kale walaahi meel xun ayaa u danbeen doonto.
i think the only way this Maamul is gonna work is if Caabudwaaq becomes the Capital, or Mareexaan or Ceyr becomes President because Ceyr and Mareexaan are more powerful in Galgaduud then any other clan.
Ximaan xeeb was very much against this last i checked. How does it work though when you disrespect ximaan folks by forging a signature of one of their representative to prove they've accepted the deal, and now wala they've accepted it? I suspect something is fishy here
My laf (sub sub sub clan) in Galgaduud are against this.
1moonlight wrote:i think the only way this Maamul is gonna work is if Caabudwaaq becomes the Capital, or Mareexaan or Ceyr becomes President because Ceyr and Mareexaan are more powerful in Galgaduud then any other clan.
I think Reer Galgaduud should be the governor and Reer Mudug the vice governor and then rotate in every election period.
Remember qabil malaga dhiso mamuul. We choose leaders for their competent's and qualification not their qabil. I don't care if the leader is Dir, Mareexaan, Habar Gidir, Majerteen, Leelkase, Murursade, Duduble or Abgaal.
Hawiye themselves baa ku leh the capital will be Cadaado or Dhuusamareeb and Ximanxaare is busy talking about a state that has nothing to do with this Central so called Mamuul. XimanXaare, what happened, wasn't the trolling with your SomaliDefence & Somali-Transporter accounts enough Hahahaahha f-king faggot Deh
Last edited by Chinaman on Wed Aug 06, 2014 3:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.