Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Daily chitchat.

Moderators: Moderators, Junior Moderators

Forum rules
This General Forum is for general discussions from daily chitchat to more serious discussions among Somalinet Forums members. Please do not use it as your Personal Message center (PM). If you want to contact a particular person or a group of people, please use the PM feature. If you want to contact the moderators, pls PM them. If you insist leaving a public message for the mods or other members, it will be deleted.

Would Somalis Have Used Defense Budget To Fund Clan Warfare?

No - 4.5 system in recruitment would have sorted this out.
1
6%
No- We have divided the regions between major clans and each clan can rule 'their own people'.
3
17%
Yes - Somali clans each want to dominate a region and therefore minorities in each region will be subjected to violence.
11
61%
No- Other (please state)
3
17%
Yes - Other (please state)
0
No votes
 
Total votes: 18

User avatar
SultanOrder
Posts: 21697
Joined: Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:10 pm
Location: Peace!

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by SultanOrder »

Estarix wrote:I think certain clans like the Habar Gidir are fed up off fighting. Most of the issues they have is internal, and they seem to be content with Abgaal hegemony in Mogadishu. I think in the next 10-20 years there wont be any major clan wars happening in Somalia (excluding somaliland), but i doubt the clan system in place will disappear.
That is a rosy picture. When push comes to shove fiqii tolkii kama jano tago, and if clan hostilities happen again everyone will side with their qabil. I just hope that investments are so large war will not be seen as a good choice. But it's important that the government controls Xamar instead of any one qabil, it's the only way to maintain peace and prosperity.
Estarix
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 2707
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 3:39 am

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by Estarix »

Perfect_Order wrote: That is a rosy picture. When push comes to shove fiqii tolkii kama jano tago, and if clan hostilities happen again everyone will side with their qabil. I just hope that investments are so large war will not be seen as a good choice. But it's important that the government controls Xamar instead of any one qabil, it's the only way to maintain peace and prosperity.
But will do the pushing now? there's no such thing as clan oriented leadership since the maxamed dheere days. Dam Jadiid are hardly ever concerned themselfes with increasing Abgaal dominance (atleast at the expense of H.Gidir). I think it's good to be optimistic when it comes to Mogadishu, i cant see anyone wanting to destroy the hard earned peace that exists at the moment.
User avatar
SultanOrder
Posts: 21697
Joined: Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:10 pm
Location: Peace!

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by SultanOrder »

Estarix wrote:
Perfect_Order wrote: That is a rosy picture. When push comes to shove fiqii tolkii kama jano tago, and if clan hostilities happen again everyone will side with their qabil. I just hope that investments are so large war will not be seen as a good choice. But it's important that the government controls Xamar instead of any one qabil, it's the only way to maintain peace and prosperity.
But will do the pushing now? there's no such thing as clan oriented leadership since the maxamed dheere days. Dam Jadiid are hardly ever concerned themselfes with increasing Abgaal dominance (atleast at the expense of H.Gidir). I think it's good to be optimistic when it comes to Mogadishu, i cant see anyone wanting to destroy the hard earned peace that exists at the moment.
Dude, Dam Jadid would be a nobody without Amisom backed System. This was not a result of the natural way of things. If Amisom left right now, who would recognize XSM for one day?
User avatar
GIJaamac
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 4962
Joined: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:05 am

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by GIJaamac »

lol @ these two niggas. There will never be a clan war in Xamar again. Taas ku seexda. It's the only somali city in the world which is actually progressing. No amount of habaar will send us back to darkness. :stylin:
User avatar
AbkoowDhiblaawe
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 14237
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 7:02 pm
Location: chilling in Liido beach

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by AbkoowDhiblaawe »

Perfect_Order wrote:I just hope HG and Abgaal don't fight for power in Xamar. Amisom have totally put Abgaal in power in a city hotly contested and HG running most of the economic areas like the port and airport.
:wtf: there is no power struggle between Abgaal and Habar gidir in xamar. Marmarka qaarkod waa iska hadashaa ninyahow.Reer Muqdisho has evolved and have realised qabiil wars doesn't serve their interests.Trust me if there was any beef between Abgaal and habar gidir dagaal mar hore uu dhici lahaa. Worry about Kismayo it wasn't that long ago when there was qabiil fightins in that town. Fyi Abgaal controll the port and the airport.
zumaale
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 3458
Joined: Wed May 04, 2011 5:45 pm

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by zumaale »

Warsheekh wrote:
:wtf: there is no power struggle between Abgaal and Habar gidir in xamar. Marmarka qaarkod waa iska hadashaa ninyahow.Reer Muqdisho has evolved and have realised qabiil wars doesn't serve their interests.Trust me if there was any beef between Abgaal and habar gidir dagaal mar hore uu dhici lahaa. Worry about Kismayo it wasn't that long ago when there was qabiil fightins in that town. Fyi Abgaal controll the port and the airport.
:lol: Xamar unuka leh somaha.
User avatar
SultanOrder
Posts: 21697
Joined: Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:10 pm
Location: Peace!

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by SultanOrder »

Warsheekh wrote:
Perfect_Order wrote:I just hope HG and Abgaal don't fight for power in Xamar. Amisom have totally put Abgaal in power in a city hotly contested and HG running most of the economic areas like the port and airport.
:wtf: there is no power struggle between Abgaal and Habar gidir in xamar. Marmarka qaarkod waa iska hadashaa ninyahow.Reer Muqdisho has evolved and have realised qabiil wars doesn't serve their interests.Trust me if there was any beef between Abgaal and habar gidir dagaal mar hore uu dhici lahaa. Worry about Kismayo it wasn't that long ago when there was qabiil fightins in that town. Fyi Abgaal controll the port and the airport.
LOL save the bed time stories for children. Reer Muqdishu has evolved etc, things have improved, but that is because their is no clan that can fight AMISOM. Let's just hope the government evolves strong enough to maintain peace and order and no clan can fight it.

Did Abgaal control the airport or port before ICU?

Kismaayo, for the most part is safe and secure. I'm not worried about it.
zumaale
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 3458
Joined: Wed May 04, 2011 5:45 pm

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by zumaale »

Slowly by slowly Abgal are regaining full control of their city. That is why you hear non Abgal clans calcalin in the media.
User avatar
AbkoowDhiblaawe
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 14237
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 7:02 pm
Location: chilling in Liido beach

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by AbkoowDhiblaawe »

Perfect_Order wrote:
Warsheekh wrote:
Perfect_Order wrote:I just hope HG and Abgaal don't fight for power in Xamar. Amisom have totally put Abgaal in power in a city hotly contested and HG running most of the economic areas like the port and airport.
:wtf: there is no power struggle between Abgaal and Habar gidir in xamar. Marmarka qaarkod waa iska hadashaa ninyahow.Reer Muqdisho has evolved and have realised qabiil wars doesn't serve their interests.Trust me if there was any beef between Abgaal and habar gidir dagaal mar hore uu dhici lahaa. Worry about Kismayo it wasn't that long ago when there was qabiil fightins in that town. Fyi Abgaal controll the port and the airport.
LOL save the bed time stories for children. Reer Muqdishu has evolved etc, things have improved, but that is because their is no clan that can fight AMISOM. Let's just hope the government evolves strong enough to maintain peace and order and no clan can fight it.

Did Abgaal control the airport or port before ICU?

Kismaayo, for the most part is safe and secure. I'm not worried about it.
bed times stories kulaha. Bro if u know anybody in xamar ask them. Ask around ,talk to people xog ogaal noqo intaadan nala doodin, madax adeyga reer muduga naga dhaaf. Dagaal qabiileed danbe will never happen in xamar.

lol@nobody can fight amisom argument. Cabdullahi yusuf with his xabashi soldiers ayaa xoog wax ku keeni lahaa hada saad sheegeysid wax ka jiraan. In the reality waxkasta waxey ku xiran tahay rabitaanka shacabka. Shacabkana dagaal iyo balaayo ma doonayaan hadeertan. Teeda kale Abgaal iyo habar gidir waa Hiiraab walaalaha waa is dagaalaan waana heshiiyaan.
User avatar
eliteSomali
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 5746
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2011 2:29 pm
Location: Jewnited States of America.

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by eliteSomali »

gedo_gurl wrote:Its pathetic and disgusting. We need to stop hiring these odeyaal who are eating us out of house and home. A visionary is needed....not by my standards, but visionary compared to these baasto lagacla'aan fuuqeystayaal.
Marginalize the "ODAYAASHA WAX GARADKA" and a huge chunk of the problem is fixed.
User avatar
SultanOrder
Posts: 21697
Joined: Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:10 pm
Location: Peace!

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by SultanOrder »

Warsheekh wrote:
Perfect_Order wrote:
Warsheekh wrote:
:wtf: there is no power struggle between Abgaal and Habar gidir in xamar. Marmarka qaarkod waa iska hadashaa ninyahow.Reer Muqdisho has evolved and have realised qabiil wars doesn't serve their interests.Trust me if there was any beef between Abgaal and habar gidir dagaal mar hore uu dhici lahaa. Worry about Kismayo it wasn't that long ago when there was qabiil fightins in that town. Fyi Abgaal controll the port and the airport.
LOL save the bed time stories for children. Reer Muqdishu has evolved etc, things have improved, but that is because their is no clan that can fight AMISOM. Let's just hope the government evolves strong enough to maintain peace and order and no clan can fight it.

Did Abgaal control the airport or port before ICU?

Kismaayo, for the most part is safe and secure. I'm not worried about it.
bed times stories kulaha. Bro if u know anybody in xamar ask them. Ask around ,talk to people xog ogaal noqo intaadan nala doodin, madax adeyga reer muduga naga dhaaf. Dagaal qabiileed danbe will never happen in xamar.

lol@nobody can fight amisom argument. Cabdullahi yusuf with his xabashi soldiers ayaa xoog wax ku keeni lahaa hada saad sheegeysid wax ka jiraan. In the reality waxkasta waxey ku xiran tahay rabitaanka shacabka. Shacabkana dagaal iyo balaayo ma doonayaan hadeertan. Teeda kale Abgaal iyo habar gidir waa Hiiraab walaalaha waa is dagaalaan waana heshiiyaan.
Qabil wars are always perpetuated by the wealthy class, it's always been the case. ICU was able to take power because the merchant class switched sides from financially supporting the warlords to the ICU. As for footsoldiers, that is easy, each qabil can round up a thousand guys to fight if they get paid enough. The majority of people are just bystanders, so of course they are always against war.
User avatar
Murax
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 28303
Joined: Sat Dec 29, 2007 4:45 am

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by Murax »

To be honest I think in some places they would be better without them, some better with them.


Xamar, the Isbaarooyin did not go until they came. This isn't clannism but its just a fact. In Hiiraan I don't think they're needed neither in Middle Shabelle. As for Jubooyinka Kenya, Ethiopia they are not AMISOM and are mere extensions of Kilinka 5nd, NFD in Somalia. I think AMISOM it is simply just business, money but they do not have any real policy, territorial ambitions in Somalia. With Kenya, Ethiopia You name it from Sea, Land, they have ambition for control in Somalia.
Estarix
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 2707
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 3:39 am

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by Estarix »

Perfect_Order wrote:
Estarix wrote:
Perfect_Order wrote: That is a rosy picture. When push comes to shove fiqii tolkii kama jano tago, and if clan hostilities happen again everyone will side with their qabil. I just hope that investments are so large war will not be seen as a good choice. But it's important that the government controls Xamar instead of any one qabil, it's the only way to maintain peace and prosperity.
But will do the pushing now? there's no such thing as clan oriented leadership since the maxamed dheere days. Dam Jadiid are hardly ever concerned themselfes with increasing Abgaal dominance (atleast at the expense of H.Gidir). I think it's good to be optimistic when it comes to Mogadishu, i cant see anyone wanting to destroy the hard earned peace that exists at the moment.
Dude, Dam Jadid would be a nobody without Amisom backed System. This was not a result of the natural way of things. If Amisom left right now, who would recognize XSM for one day?
I think if they left Alshabab would take over. And if that were not to happen then the government would have a long life or a short one depending on the relations the mogadishan clans would have the regime. A very shaky sort of existence. It would obviously need to have a clan system in place where majority of security forces in each district are in line with clan demographics. It would also need to give each clan in the city some position of power.
Estarix
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 2707
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 3:39 am

Re: Are AMISOM Better Than Somali Forces.....

Post by Estarix »

.
Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Return to “General - General Discussions”