Idaajaa got bitch slapped.

[The`Republic]

Xplaya-

Robecci even traveled to Jigjiga and Djibouti. He also did see the Isaaq.

This is a map he drew of British Somaliland



He could have heard anything from the many Isaaq villages he traveled through and probably where he picked up those names.

[X.Playa]

Can anybody post an image of page 3 and 4, so we can at least see this shire script and compare it to muuse and abdulaah script.

[X.Playa]

Xplaya-

Robecci even traveled to Jigjiga and Djibouti. He also did see the Isaaq.

This is a map he drew of British Somaliland



He could have heard anything from the many Isaaq villages he traveled through and probably where he picked up those names.

In his book he says the best of the somali poets he heared it between the country of the mareexaan and ogaden. Its obvious he interviewed these clans. So why even negate what the man himself had said.

[X.Playa]

Here is the link for the list of the scripts and their authors.

http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0015/0 ... 8072eb.pdf

We need an image of page 3 and 4.

The Republic what Goosh and Galaal book that you claim they used shirs script, i dont recall either of these men writing a book of somali poetry using somali script unless you meant the paper on Guba titled somali poetic combat. And the somali script on that paper its far different then the modern script which adds more evidenced against your case if indeed they used shires script.

[X.Playa]

Sorry its page 5 and 6.

http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0015/0 ... 8072eb.pdf

[The`Republic]

The Republic what Goosh and Galaal book that you claim they used shirs script, i dont recall either of these men writing a book of somali poetry using somali script unless you meant the paper on Guba titled somali poetic combat. And the somali script on that paper its far different then the modern script which adds more evidenced against your case if indeed they used shires script.

Andrezejewski and IM Lewis, not Galaal. Galaal was a source.

Here is their book written in 1964, saying on grounds of convenience they have employed the script devised by Shire Jama for best use

http://books.google.com/books?id=_viAAA ... CEkQ6AEwBA

[X.Playa]

I have read that book the book is english. Why won't you show us all three scripts its obvious you don't want to post these two pages 5 and 6 that alone will settle this debate.

[The`Republic]

What debate? Are you drunk or delusional? Wallahi I don't know which is which so can you tell me?

You posted one source in modern times, a woman by name of Sheila Andrezejewski who had nothing to do with your interpretation. Seemeyer also brought a link about the COMMITTEE heads, nothing to do with the men who were the result of the scripts they evaluated. Samatar also brought a link from a modern interview with Kadarre, a man who had his own unimportant script going on.

I posted UNESCO from 1966 in an article co-authored by Andrezejewski saying Shire is best of all these scripts including Muuse Galaal.

I posted a book on Somali literature from Andrezejewski and IM Lewis of British Somaliland in 1963 who said they used Shire Jama for best form in writing the Somali part.

I posted his magazine in 1967 that was the only Somali magazine in print.

I also posted Prof Hussein Tanzania (Isaaq) who said Muuse Galaal threw his lot in with Shire Jama's script.

I also posted a modern Somali book order site that has at it's front page Shire Jama as father of Somali script.

You Isaaq boys went from saying Muuse Galaal is father of the script to Shire Jama might have been primary but he bounced from considerable collaboration.

So what, why couldn't Muuse Galaal couldn't be the base? The UNESCO article from 1966 COMPARES SHIRE JAMA TO EVERYONE including Muuse Galaal and says explicitly the recommendation is that Shire Jama is the foundation.

In 1972, the Somali language commission heeded that recommendation among many others and explicitly endorsed SHIRE JAMA AS THE FOUNDATION for Somali language.

Whether it was tweaked and added to, it doesn't matter in this case.

He is the foundation, the rock and the tier, therefore he is the father of the Somali script. End of story.

[XimanJaale]

What debate? Are you drunk or delusional? Wallahi I don't know which is which so can you tell me?

You posted one source in modern times, a woman by name of Sheila Andrezejewski who had nothing to do with your interpretation. Seemeyer also brought a link about the COMMITTEE heads, nothing to do with the men who were the result of the scripts they evaluated. Samatar also brought a link from a modern interview with Kadarre, a man who had his own unimportant script going on.

I posted UNESCO from 1966 in an article co-authored by Andrezejewski saying Shire is best of all these scripts including Muuse Galaa.

I posted a book on Somali literature from Andrezejewski and IM Lewis of British Somaliland in 1963 who said they Shire Jama for best form in writing the Somali part.

I posted his magazine in 1967 that was the only Somali magazine in print.

I also posted Prof Hussein Tanzania (Isaaq) who said Muuse Galaa threw his lost in with Shire Jama's script.

I also posted a modern Somali book order site that has at it's front page Shire Jama as father of Somali script.

You Isaaq boys went from saying Muuse Galaal is father of the script to Shire Jama might have been primary but he bounced from considerable collaboration.

So what, why couldn't Muuse Galaal couldn't be the base? The UNESCO article from 1966 COMPARES SHIRE JAMA TO EVERYONE including Muuse Galaal and says explicitly the recommendation is that Shire Jama is the foundation.

In 1972, the Somali language commission heeded that recommendation among many others and explicitly endorsed SHIRE JAMA AS THE FOUNDATION for Somali language.

Whether it was tweaked and added to, it doesn't matter in this case.

He is the foundation, the rock and the tier, therefore he is the father of the Somali script. End of story.

It's like talking to a brick with these people!

Not only was he the foundation and father of Somali writing system but he was also the first president of Somali Academy of Science and Culture. (The Written word: literacy in transition - Page 145)

The countless Hero's and Academics we produced before 1969 is tremendous. Indeed we are a big asset to Somaliweyne. My favourite is Cali Mataan Hashi and my relative ancestor Amir Nuur, and how can I forget Adan Low! To many to count

[X.Playa]

Stop wasting our time by constantly spewing the same shit that was debunked unless you are blind argumentive lunatic who sees what he believes this unesco study you refering too included shire jaamacs script on page 6 and it is not the modern somali script, shire jaamac brought nothing new both galaals#4 script and abdulaahis#5 is as good as shire infact #5 and shires script have dh letter and thats the only contribution shire made to somali scripts where as galaal had tow letters chosen from his script the x, c..

Read the damn script once and all and don't bother us with what who and who said when one can simply look at page and finnd by himself.

[The`Republic]

Ex Premier Saacid Shirdoon,, deputy speaker Jaylaani, Defense Minister Fiqi, and Interior Minister Abdikariim visiting the biggest secondary school in Galgaduud, Shire Jaamac Axmed secondary school in Caabudwaaq

Caabudwaaq, March 06,2013——-Ra’iisal Wasaaraha Xukuumada Federaalka Soomaaliya Mudane Cabdi Faarax Shirdoon Saacid ayaa saaka booqday Dugsiga H/dhexe iyo sare ee Shire Jaamac Axmed, kaasoo ah Dugsiga ugu weyn ee ardayda degmadu wax ka bartaan.

Shire Jama has much more to his history tha. being the father of the Somali script. He wrote the first Somali language novel, he wrote the first English-Somali dictionary printed by Columbia University in US, he published the first Somali magazine Iftiinka Aqponta and he was the first President of the Somali Academy of Arts.

Like his other Sade brothers like Dr Mohamed Adan Sheikh (first Somali qualified surgeon), Dr Lawaaxe (cited by evem Caydiid as first Somali to graduate from Western 4 year university, Cali Mataan Hashi first Somali to fly a jet, and Dalays, first Somali woman to break gender norms and sing publicly, along with Siyaad Barre longest leading Somali leader in history and it's most powerful, not to mention even as far as Nur Mujahid who built the walls of Harar.

This is pure recorded history.

Continue yapping about Kacaan if it makes you sleep.

[XimanJaale]

Ex Premier Saacid Shirdoon,, deputy speaker Jaylaani, Defense Minister Fiqi, and Interior Minister Abdikariim visiting the biggest secondary school in Galgaduud, Shire Jaamac Axmed secondary school in Caabudwaaq

Caabudwaaq, March 06,2013——-Ra’iisal Wasaaraha Xukuumada Federaalka Soomaaliya Mudane Cabdi Faarax Shirdoon Saacid ayaa saaka booqday Dugsiga H/dhexe iyo sare ee Shire Jaamac Axmed, kaasoo ah Dugsiga ugu weyn ee ardayda degmadu wax ka bartaan.

Shire Jama has much more to his history has being thr father of the Somali script. He wrote the first Somali language novel, he wrote the first English-Somali dictionary printed by Columbia University in US, he published the first Somali magazine Iftinka Aqponta and he was the first President of the Somali Academy of Arts.

Like his other Sade brothers like Dr Mohamed Adan Sheikh (first Somali qualified surgeon), Dr Lawaaxe (cited by evem Caydiid as first Somali to graduate from Western 4 year university, Cali Mataan Hashi first Somali to fly a jet, and Dalays, first Somali woman to break gender norms and sing publicly, along with Siyaad Barre longest leading Somali leader in history and it's most powerful, not to mention even as far as Nur Mujahid who built the walls of Harar.

This is pure recorded history.

Continue yapping about Kacaan if it makes you sleep.

Alhamdulilah Indeed we have created countless elites and hero in the past. And to this day were are still creating these hero's for the Somali nation. The most popular, patriotic, effective and loved Somali leader in this century his excellence Farmaajo.

[X.Playa]

This is shires script

b, d, t, dh, g, k, q, f, s, sh, kh,0.oh, h. J, m, n, r, l, w, y.

He got modern x wrong and modern c wrong, so tell me how are we using his script.?

[X.Playa]

This is muuse galaals script.

b, d, t,&, g,.k,q,f, s, sh, kh, c, x, h, j, m, n, r, l, w, y.

Muuse galaals script only got the letter& which is my repersentation of his a look like symbol for the letter dh wrong.


So any sane human can say the modern somali script is closer to galaals by 20 out of 21 letter.

Where as shire got 19 out of 21.


Now stfu and stop wasting our time with
Your tribal shit.

[X.Playa]

If we for example try to right your clan using shires script this how it would be

Mareeohaan lol, another daarood myth of greatness bites the dust.