Qodobada kasoo baxay shirka beesha direed

[BestPlaya]

Those "white guys" had PhD in linguistics. Show us your credentials? Where's your study?



Nonsense, Isaaq is king when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Cagdheer and Qurji adopted this culture from Isaaq because its absent in other Dofaar Ismaciils that do not border Isaaq.

Yeah ,probably they have PHD in linguistics but Somali is not their area of expertise .A white man with a PHD doesn't know it all .He's not answer to everything contrary to your weird beliefs


I repeatedly thrashed hordes of iidoor lowlifes .let them just keep coming .


What do you know about poetry iidoor nigga .Ogaden poets and poetry are the finest in history .


Poetry is not absent from others Daarood clans it is only that you don't know .

Unlike you, an Cagdheer driven by emotions, these men were authorities in their field and the result of their study was something we Isaaq always knew.

Isaaq dialect = standard Somali

Who did you trash and what did you prove? You are truly delusional

Isaaq are kings when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Your own Dofaar Ismaciil testified in front of Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their times was Isaaq and that Raage Ugaaz envied and feared Axmad Adan Dubbe aka Gabay Xoog

Luigi who ? Another divine scholar from white race

Walee qoloda iidoor dhib wayn baa haysta .


Dee waligaaba malo awaal iskugu sheekee .runta cidina ma badali karto .

[Xildiiid]

Yeah ,probably they have PHD in linguistics but Somali is not their area of expertise .A white man with a PHD doesn't know it all .He's not answer to everything contrary to your weird beliefs


I repeatedly thrashed hordes of iidoor lowlifes .let them just keep coming .


What do you know about poetry iidoor nigga .Ogaden poets and poetry are the finest in history .


Poetry is not absent from others Daarood clans it is only that you don't know .

Unlike you, an Cagdheer driven by emotions, these men were authorities in their field and the result of their study was something we Isaaq always knew.

Isaaq dialect = standard Somali

Who did you trash and what did you prove? You are truly delusional

Isaaq are kings when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Your own Dofaar Ismaciil testified in front of Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their times was Isaaq and that Raage Ugaaz envied and feared Axmad Adan Dubbe aka Gabay Xoog

^ Idoorku xishood ma leh. kkk, walee yaab anagaa aragnaay. Who tf is Gabay Xoog? It sounds like the guy was overcompensating for his inadequacies not to mention the fact that he is unknown.


Northern dialect isnt exclusive idoor, its a regional dialect. Their isnt a clan dialect per se.


Dhulbahante and Ogadeen poets are revered in Idoor households and not even the idoors can name you 4 idoor poets off the bat.

in myrhh and Gums. Poetry originated from the Dolbahanta country and made its way into the Ogaden highlands. The gulbed clans who settle the great expanse of lifeless plains called the Guban are not known for their prose but rather their gallantry.

Here is an excerpt from Richard Burton

Gabay Xoog is the man Raage Ugaaz envied and feared.

Linguistic scholars already proved Isaaq dialect = standard Somali.

Thats Richard Burtons opinion. Nothing else.

[Xildiiid]

Yeah ,probably they have PHD in linguistics but Somali is not their area of expertise .A white man with a PHD doesn't know it all .He's not answer to everything contrary to your weird beliefs


I repeatedly thrashed hordes of iidoor lowlifes .let them just keep coming .


What do you know about poetry iidoor nigga .Ogaden poets and poetry are the finest in history .


Poetry is not absent from others Daarood clans it is only that you don't know .

Unlike you, an Cagdheer driven by emotions, these men were authorities in their field and the result of their study was something we Isaaq always knew.

Isaaq dialect = standard Somali

Who did you trash and what did you prove? You are truly delusional

Isaaq are kings when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Your own Dofaar Ismaciil testified in front of Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their times was Isaaq and that Raage Ugaaz envied and feared Axmad Adan Dubbe aka Gabay Xoog

Luigi who ? Another divine scholar from white race

Walee qoloda iidoor dhib wayn baa haysta .


Dee waligaaba malo awaal iskugu sheekee .runta cidina ma badali karto .

Your illiterate Dofaar Ismaciil told Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their time was Isaaq and he wrote it down in his journal.

[BestPlaya]

Unlike you, an Cagdheer driven by emotions, these men were authorities in their field and the result of their study was something we Isaaq always knew.

Isaaq dialect = standard Somali

Who did you trash and what did you prove? You are truly delusional

Isaaq are kings when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Your own Dofaar Ismaciil testified in front of Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their times was Isaaq and that Raage Ugaaz envied and feared Axmad Adan Dubbe aka Gabay Xoog

Luigi who ? Another divine scholar from white race

Walee qoloda iidoor dhib wayn baa haysta .


Dee waligaaba malo awaal iskugu sheekee .runta cidina ma badali karto .

Your illiterate Dofaar Ismaciil told Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their time was Isaaq and he wrote it down in his journal.

He wrote what he was told by a Daarod person and since it was written down by a Liugi ,a white scholar, it proves a point that iidoor poet was the best and therefore ,because that one incident ,iidoor are best in poetry

Isnt that all you want say ?.According to you all whites are literate ,PHD holders and their words are final

Just present great known iidoors poets with their best poems and let's see all see how good are eeyduur poems instead of you saying gaalbaa saa qoray ,wuu na amaanay bla bla ..That's nonsense

[Xildiiid]

Luigi who ? Another divine scholar from white race

Walee qoloda iidoor dhib wayn baa haysta .


Dee waligaaba malo awaal iskugu sheekee .runta cidina ma badali karto .

Your illiterate Dofaar Ismaciil told Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their time was Isaaq and he wrote it down in his journal.

He wrote what he was told by a Daarod person and since it was written down by a Liugi ,a white scholar, it proves a point that iidoor poet was the best and therefore ,because that one incident ,iidoor are best in poetry

Isnt that all you want say ?.According to you all whites are literate ,PHD holders and their words are final

Just present great known iidoors poets with their best poems and let's see all see how good are eeyduur poems instead of you saying gaalbaa saa qoray ,wuu na amaanay bla bla ..That's nonsense

If you read his book you would find out that it was the general concensus among Somali people but the interesting part is that Dofaar Ismaciil agreed with the rest of Somalis that an Isaaq man was the best poet of their time.

[Ben Dover]

Demented drooling Cagdheer, malaha waad isku yaacdey, you are spamming the thread now to cover up the humiliation.

I gave you homework to do you jaahil, go and educate yourself.

[Ben Dover]

A renowned linguists is not credible enough because his impartial, extensive field study disproved Dofaar Ismaciil lies.

Not to mention that the study was carried out during the reign of Afweyne before they accuse Iidoor of funding the study.

Poetry is Isaaq culture! Only Dofaars (Cagdheer and Qurji) that border Isaaq adopted this culture from us.

Where are the MareXaar poets? Leelkase? Awrtabla? Gerri? Jidwaaq? maJAREERteen?

This further proves my point.

Xildid, the study done during Afweyne's reign is single the most extensive study ever conducted on Somali dialects, the other study was concluded even before Afweyne in 1965.


The demented cagdheer resorted to the tried "Bu..bu..buut my mother told me otherwise" defence

[Khalid Ali]

Waalida daarood thinking they can match Isaaq in poetry suugaan iyo hal abur. Intanu maahmaahkusodarnay the Somali language cidiba masheegin qamaan bulxan iyo saahifqamaan were the only 2 of the darood oo halhayskahadhay iyo hal abur. Sayid siigeyste wixisu murti maahayn futto iyo ceeb iyo qoodho iidoorbu ka gabyi jiray oo keliyaa. And I will give credit on dhoodaan luuqaysi. Non of those guy can match aflow jamac haabil xuseyn xassan iyo salaan carabay and salaxmalaydiray.

[BestPlaya]

..

[Xildiiid]

A renowned linguists is not credible enough because his impartial, extensive field study disproved Dofaar Ismaciil lies.

Not to mention that the study was carried out during the reign of Afweyne before they accuse Iidoor of funding the study.

Poetry is Isaaq culture! Only Dofaars (Cagdheer and Qurji) that border Isaaq adopted this culture from us.

Where are the MareXaar poets? Leelkase? Awrtabla? Gerri? Jidwaaq? maJAREERteen?

This further proves my point.

Xildid, the study done during Afweyne's reign is single the most extensive study ever conducted on Somali dialects, the other study was concluded even before Afweyne in 1965.


The demented cagdheer resorted to the tried "Bu..bu..buut my mother told me otherwise" defence

Caadi ayuu u waashay

[theyuusuf143]

Caruur caruur aan lala ciyaarin baa jira, Ben dover weligii lagama gar helin , wuxuuna aqoon u lahayna iskama galo . Intaasi cashar hawgu filnaato bestplayo .

[BestPlaya]

√. Waxyi buuna gaal warkii noqon iyo waano ilaahay'e

√.Waraaqihii la dhigana ,haw malayn weedh kama dambaysa

√.Waa aadmi gaalkaa yurub ,aan ahayn wali islaameede

√.Kol haduu wales ka yimid ,Warsaw iyo Paris

√.Oo wuxuu sheegaba aamin iyo "waa sax" kula boodo

√.Waxaadika Eeboo sawaabka ku waafaja mooyaane

√.Iga Walle miskiinow aduun ,wareer inaad la joogtaaye






√.Warka sugan ,weedha saxan iyo wadarta suugaanta

√.Halkay weeydaaratee ,waafi looga sheego

√.Wardheer ,Danoodiyo Walwaal iyo intii wabiga loo gaadho

√.Waa rugtii sarbeebta gabay iyo ,tixaha waawayne

√.Waa halkay Weerar iyo qamaan,wacdaro ka sheegeene ,

√.Waa hibo Eebahay baxashoon ahayn wadhadhac gaalaade




















√. Waxyi buuna gaal warkii noqon iyo waano ilaahay'e

√.Waraaqihii la dhigana ,haw malayn weedh kama dambaysa

√.Waa aadmi gaalkaa yurub ,aan ahayn wali islaameede

√.Kol haduu wales ka yimid ,Warsaw iyo Paris

√.Oo wuxuu sheegaba aamin iyo "waa sax" kula boodo

√.Waxaadika Eeboo sawaabka ku waafaja mooyaane

√.Iga Walle miskiinow aduun ,wareer inaad la joogtaaye






√.Warka sugan ,weedha saxan iyo wadarta suugaanta

√.Halkay weeydaaratee ,waafi looga sheego

√.Wardheer ,Danoodiyo Walwaal iyo intii wabiga loo gaadho

√.Waa rugtii sarbeebta gabay iyo ,tixaha waawayne

√.Waa halkay Weerar iyo qamaan,wacdaro ka sheegeene ,

√.Waa hibo Eebahay baxashoon ahayn wadhadhac gaalaade

[BestPlaya]

You're miserably repeating yourself like a broken record .


You may believe in all that's said by a white scholar and use to to satisfy your delusional state of mind but the obvious fact is that they messed up things regarding Somali dialect .


Somali dialects are best classified according to geographical zones not based on clans .The undeniable truth is , Ree Hawd ,Doollo and Ciid has great dialects that dwarf all the rest .

One should consider in the first place , the dielects that dominate the poetry and other folklore songs that forms the basis of the rich linguistic history of any language.

Af-gudbursi AF iidoor etc is just a nonsese and only a certified dimwit will ascribe to such a thing

No one is interested in the opinion of a drooling jaahil cagdheer. You actually admitted to not being educated, yet somehow think its ok to still argue against consensus of scholarship

What we need is not your mother's opinion, instead try and bring unbiased reports from reputable scholarship on the subject. We have years of scholarship by some of the most reputable academics in the field proclaiming Isaaq to be the most purest form of Somali. The single most extensive study of Somali dialects comes to the same conclusion. Substantiate your argument or STFU.

You got humiliated, take it on the chin and move on. Learn the importance of educating yourself, learn about the scientific method.

Let this be a lesson to you.

Concesus of scholars ?

You sound a little bit ambiguous here .Do you exactly mean the white guys that your consider their work holy and final or the club of iidoor nerds lead by his majesty the boqor of iidoor lunatics which they adorably called Baruur-Madow

[BestPlaya]

Demented drooling Cagdheer, malaha waad isku yaacdey, you are spamming the thread now to cover up the humiliation.

I gave you homework to do you jaahil, go and educate yourself.

I have destroyed a number iidoor trolls in this particular thread

The Yuusuf
Saalaxbaashe
Dayire
Xildiid
Sauron


You are their last hope .And you couldn't stop the Bestplaya you are now censoring my posts .Cowardice at its best .Iidoor run to the delete button when their ultimate Big gun,the Inagumeed Bendover fails with his despicable art of name calling antics .Bendover ,you disappointed the ignoble iidoor hordes .


Doqonyahay iidoorka ah ee waliba Xaabusho injireey kasii haybsata ,waliba qoloda layasee laangaabka ah Gaalo-gudan aka Caasho Barre or Cali Barre ...waxaad ogataa Gaal baa waxyooday iyo hooyaday baa garac rintay kaa saari mayso.


Lahjada Somali igu Sidata waa ta ay ku hadlaan reeraha dhaqanka iyo suugaanta xambaarsan loona yaqaano .Waa lahja Ciid ,Doollo,Qoraxay ,Hundaha celiseed iyo hawdba looga hadlo .Waa lahjada Abwaanada ugu magaca dheer Somali ku hadli jireen .

Sayyid M.C.Xasan
Qamaan Bulxan
M.C.Beenaleey
M.C.Dage
Xarbi Ismaaciil
Faarax Caytame
Buraale Cali Seexde
Maax Dhagoole
Weerar Bulxan
Saahid Qamaan
Khaliif Xarbi
Dhoodaan
Cabdi Gorod
Baarleex
Baarxawle
Feetin
Gaani
Guraase

[Xildiiid]

^
You lost the debate yaa Cagdheer. You couldnt disprove any of the sources brought to the table.

Standard Somali = Isaaq dialect.

Waxba ha isku kaaya hor qaawin ee meesha ka carar