melo wrote:abdalla11 wrote:melo wrote:Abdalla: This concept of Jihaad being fought for religion, is what Sheikh Umal, and Cumar faaruuq and Co were arguing about in recent times. Umal says that ONLF should not be supported because they have no Islamic agenda. But the other sheikhs, correctly showed, that Jihaad at its core is about defending your rights and your property from oppression. It doesn't always have to be about fighting for Islam in its proper sense. You might be able to do search about what they said back to Umal.
I am aware of the one who is defending his country, the one who´s defending his property and his dignity are all doing Jihad. But what i´ve seen you doing alot is applying a general statement to specific evens that occured. Not a single somali fraction except for Al-Itixad was fighting based on religious grounds. There is no religious justification for what Caydiid did to the poor people of Baidoa nor was there any reason to sneak in at night in Gaalkacyo, the home of the first people who refused the oppression, and kill hundreds of unarmed people. Mujahidin were always welcomed by the people, they're not called
Mukulaal Madow
ONLF are fighting against armed army, they didnt starve Eelays to death.
So overthrowing Siyaad was not Justified? Even though he was a tyrant, who left Islam?
You need stop conflating issues, as i said. I am talking about a specific fight. In that regard, they were mujaahiddin. Now did actions later on, remove this title? Yes they did.
The title of Mujaahid is situational. You can be a mujaahid one day, and a mujrim the next day. It is not an absolute term. Similarly, a fight can begin as Jihaad, then turn into an opressive war.
Are you saying that Caydiid fought against the whole regime? He selected his opponents based on clan, he fought against some members of that regime while he left others alone. Kulmiye Afrax was the Head of the Police and he was walking free, there´s a tape of Caydiid and Cumar Carte Qaalib (Isaaq) discussing talking. Cumar Carte was a minister under Siyaad and the examples are many.
Which fight are you talking about? The capture of Mogadishu in jan 1991? Two months laters they attacked another city that had nothing to do with the regime. Never seen mujahidin doing so fast a U-turn and then they started slaughtering each other
Many scholars talked about the fitnah in 1991, including Boqolsoon and Cukaashe but you are the first to label some fractions as Mujahidin. Never did i see such claim.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Murax wrote:Welcome to the new age Somali Internet Wadaad/Hypocrite/Mujaahid/Clannist

lol horta how come this new age wadaado have soft spot for their clan leaders. I remember the idiotic Somali-star and how he use to praise Cumar Jees while using religion