JaMaaL-23 wrote:Bro Yalahow has a point of argument that needs to be debated, I don't understand why ppl are resorting to namecalling and cheap shots.
Bro Yalaxow,
you have mentioned above that you are a Qurani (only Quranic daliil) but what about the actions of the Rasuul SCW? He carried out stonning of Adultarers in his time.
is that enough for you?
problem of claiming that rasuul scw that he carried out stonning its from hadiiths and man made history,almost all hadiith claimes that rasuul scw did that or he did not do that. so if hadiith conradics what allah said so thats is uncorrect. quran not in one suurah and 2 suurahs, SUURATUL NUUR AND SUURATUL NISAA allah clearly says punishment for adultry is( 100 lashes) and not only 100 lashes you even need 4 witness. there is no one singel place which GOD ALLAH says punishment for adultry is(killing stoning) sxb stoning and lashing karbaash is tottaly 2 different thinks.
thats why hadiith is conradicts what allah said, allah said 100 lashes and hadith which wich was collected 200 years after rasuul scw died. which one we take QURAN OR HADIITH?
of course quran is the only autentic nr 1 source in the quran.
sxb xitaa waxaa jira HADIITH whichs says rasuul scw KILLED pregnent women whichs called( Asma bint Marwan) he killed here becouse gabay rasuulka lagu caynayo ayey tirisey. sxb ma rumeysanaa xadiiskaas oo kale waa maya.
marka xadiiskaas dhahaya rasuulkaa sameeyey wax aan quraanka ku oolin ee ah stoning some to death waa fake one.
dhamaan axadiista waxaa aruuriyey dad aan waligood arag asxaabihii rasuulka xitaa asxaabihi dadkii ay dhaleen aan arag.
axadiista saxda ahna waa kuwa kaliya ee aan ka hor imaaneynin quraanka. xadiis ka hor imanaya quraanka waxba kama jiraan waa sida aan aniga aaminsanahay.
: . waraaa xaarweyne wax kale waa la imaan weeyday soo maaha.