Prof. Lidwien (Ladan)Author of Clan Cleansing

[Tanker]

Samatar

This is not a sick debate about what genocide was worst, killing inocent muslim civilians is disgusting and there should never be any debate about that or justification, killing inocent muslims means that you will burn in Hell and I can promise you that Allah will make sure the Fitnah will reach those murders already in this life.....

those women, children, old people, killed in Xamar had nothing to do with what few generals did

and SNM did commit clan killings in Hargeysa and Burco aganist poor inocent Ogaden refugees who got their throat cut and thrown into wells this is fact.

[Kabriid]

Samatar

This is not a sick debate about what genocide was worst, killing inocent muslim civilians is disgusting and there should never be any debate about that or justification, killing inocent muslims means that you will burn in Hell and I can promise you that Allah will make sure the Fitnah will reach those murders already in this life.....

those women, children, old people, killed in Xamar had nothing to do with what few generals did

and SNM did commit clan killings in Hargeysa and Burco aganist poor inocent Ogaden refugees who got their throat cut and thrown into wells this is fact.

Why are you lying? The Ogaden you are talking about were armed by Maxamed Siyaad Barre after the Somali-Ethio war in 1978, inorder to take over the Maroodi Jeex region despite the hospitableness of Isaaq, who fed them and put clothes on their backs. They tried to do the same thing in Hiiraan once again armed by Maxamed Siyaad Barre.


The worst atrocity committed during the civil war is the bombardment of Hargeysa with MiG and Hunter aircrafts while every corner of the northern, southern, eastern and western part of the city had army brigades with rocket artillery, ready to shoot at the fleeing masses. Approximately 100.000 civilians lost their lives only in Hargeysa and that's without including what happened to the civilians in Burco and Berbera. Without including the random executions and all the civilians that lost their lives to landmines.

What about all the Hawiye that had their wells poisoned? Thousands of wells poisoned by the regime inorder to wipe out entire families and their cattle. What about the execution of civilians in central Somalia? The mass rape of women and children?

You say that the women, children and old people in Xamar didn't have anything to with the ideas of the kacaan generals but did the 100's of thousand civilians in northern and central Somalia have anything to do with SNM or USC?