SomaliNet Forums

Jugjugwacwac wrote:Women's right lool. Ninyahow dadkani waa imtixaan.

Bro, do you remember on a previous thread have how some Somali do not realise that Western ideals and mores have subconsciously skewed their ability to reason. They are very quick to dismiss some Islamic facts as extremism without scriptural research.

Jahil foqal jahil imtixan.

It's funny how a band of alcoholics, and part time muslims are criticizing well known somali scholars
Lama is the guy who thinks he is a european swede, kulaha "we like to drink alcohol to loosen up"
Another, odeygan la dahah Lejusticier waa suufi/qabyalaad ku aasan
Midkan dameerka Yalaxow waa qabyaladeysti single ku ah 50, wuxuu aaminsanyahyna aan la ogeyn.

Shekhyadu tol bey ka dhasheen la socda xerta suufi wal cilmaniyiin. wa tolka islaamka.

To criticize a particular scholar on particular position is understandable, to attack Somali Scholars based on the title and the role they play in our society is an indirect attack on the ideals they hold.

Our resident mods, old men in their 50s, are out of touch with the beliefs of the vast majority of somalis.

Lamagoodle wrote:Jaidi and LJ,
View this

Walaalo I watched the whole video and I didn't see him call for the killing of the author. Marka hore diinta aqoon uma laho, laakin from what little I know it is not allowed to kill anyone (including someone committed murder in front of you) without due process in court. What I see in this video is a man exposing the blatant lies of another man. The book's cover is grotesque, and that in itself should be a clue to the low quality of the book. Sheekha xumaan kuma arag in this video (admittedly, I don't listen to many Islamic lectures so I don't know of too many Sheikhs).

Many (not all) Orientalists are veiled Islamophobes, and to me, Islamophobes and Islamic extremists are two sides of the same coin. I'm not interested in their rhetoric and insults, and I wish they allowed us to practice our faith in peace without playing "tug-of-war" with the majority of the Muslims like you and me.

zumaale wrote:

BaastoUnit wrote:Umal defended kenya against as so many times.he is as' s most hated sheikh.this makes no sense.braindead kenyaati.

Bro, I cannot comment on his religious teachings because I am ignorant of them. However, it is a known fact that he was at odds with Al Shabab yet some Somalinetters are celebrating his persecution by the Kenyan government out of an emotional dislike of his salafism. Wait until the Kenyan expand their witch hunt to the common Mali in Kenya.

This

Talo alle udaa wrote:It's funny how a band of alcoholics, and part time muslims are criticizing well known somali scholars
Lama is the guy who thinks he is a european swede, kulaha "we like to drink alcohol to loosen up"
Another, odeygan la dahah Lejusticier waa suufi/qabyalaad ku aasan
Midkan dameerka Yalaxow waa qabyaladeysti single ku ah 50, wuxuu aaminsanyahyna aan la ogeyn.

Shekhyadu tol bey ka dhasheen la socda xerta suufi wal cilmaniyiin. wa tolka islaamka.

To criticize a particular scholar on particular position is understandable, to attack Somali Scholars based on the title and the role they play in our society is an indirect attack on the ideals they hold.

Our resident mods, old men in their 50s, are out of touch with the beliefs of the vast majority of somalis.

Gedogurl,
Sheikh is an individual.we can critique every single somali person of influence. I dont think you will find a person who has been as outspoken of mistreatment of somalis by alshabab, ethiopia, kenya and somali warlords than sheikh umal.he is not perfect.but he is a somali of reasonable stature and influenfe in the community. I dont believe kenya cares whether he is a salafi or talafi or a xalwo eating sufi. If this were the case, all those xawaalado would not be on the list.kenya is attacking somali people of influence and money.it is not the time to discuss somali sheikhs errors and jurisprudence positions from youtube videos.. Dont act like as if those sufi sheikhs are perfect.war dadkani "kenya is attacking somali people/ institutions and you are talking about sheikh baa maalin sida yidhi" waa imtixaan.

Disgusting how our scholars are insulted and dragged through the mud by forces of duunya. They hate the message but only attack the messenger.

Ilaahay protect the culima

The sheikh was supposed to come to T.O. on the Victoria Day long weekend next month...

Advo wrote:Disgusting how our scholars are insulted and dragged through the mud by forces of duunya. They hate the message but only attack the messenger.

Ilaahay protect the culima

Amiin

Advo wrote:Disgusting how our scholars are insulted and dragged through the mud by forces of duunya. They hate the message but only attack the messenger.

Ilaahay protect the culima

This..


Ameen......

One does not need to read the whole book to find misinformation in the book. I think the Shaikh stated the parts of the book that contained misinformation. I think that's fair.

Talo alle udaa wrote:It's funny how a band of alcoholics, and part time muslims are criticizing well known somali scholars
Lama is the guy who thinks he is a european swede, kulaha "we like to drink alcohol to loosen up"
Another, odeygan la dahah Lejusticier waa suufi/qabyalaad ku aasan
Midkan dameerka Yalaxow waa qabyaladeysti single ku ah 50, wuxuu aaminsanyahyna aan la ogeyn.

Shekhyadu tol bey ka dhasheen la socda xerta suufi wal cilmaniyiin. wa tolka islaamka.

To criticize a particular scholar on particular position is understandable, to attack Somali Scholars based on the title and the role they play in our society is an indirect attack on the ideals they hold.

Our resident mods, old men in their 50s, are out of touch with the beliefs of the vast majority of somalis.

Haye. Scholar? I guess a better word is demagogue + religious entrepreneur + lackey is the right term.

Stop consuming the cheap cool aid Tallo

If you are going to quote me, please do it correctly! or is this the cool-aid-waan-daadshe- faqi tolkiisa kama janno tago- wahabi way? I wrote " Alcohol makes us talk" in reference to Swedes ( I am one) relationship to alcohol.

Attack me and LJ as much as you want but please avoid insulting Dr. Yalaxow.

Ladies and gentlemen, Tallo's rants above is a manifest of what is wrong with our society.

Lamagoodle wrote:

Kareem99 wrote:

Lamagoodle wrote:Jaidi and LJ,
View this

Walaalo I watched the whole video and I didn't see him call for the killing of the author. Marka hore diinta aqoon uma laho, laakin from what little I know it is not allowed to kill anyone (including someone committed murder in front of you) without due process in court. What I see in this video is a man exposing the blatant lies of another man. The book's cover is grotesque, and that in itself should be a clue to the low quality of the book. Sheekha xumaan kuma arag in this video (admittedly, I don't listen to many Islamic lectures so I don't know of too many Sheikhs).

Many (not all) Orientalists are veiled Islamophobes, and to me, Islamophobes and Islamic extremists are two sides of the same coin. I'm not interested in their rhetoric and insults, and I wish they allowed us to practice our faith in peace without playing "tug-of-war" with the majority of the Muslims like you and me.

He might not have said it explicitly but the message was clear. View it again. The author is in hiding.

What I see in this video is a man exposing the blatant lies of another man

What????????????? Come on saaxib!!!! I hope that is a typo!!! Exposing? blatant lie? This is a book written by a muslim scholar; he should have finished reading and commented it.


Quality of the cover; what do you mean??????????

The biggest threat to our people is UMUL et al. The wahabists who have embraced it; imported it in somalia(AFrica) and use it as a mechanism of faith are to blame for the plight of muslims.

A good scholar (muslim or not) would read the whole book, be prudent in the way he chooses his words and argues for his case. He does not engage in outright condemnation.

Advo wrote:Disgusting how our scholars are insulted and dragged through the mud by forces of duunya. They hate the message but only attack the messenger.

Ilaahay protect the culima

Scholar? where did you get that from? He is a demagogue (af minshaar), a wahabi entrepreneur, a lackey and a pathological liar ( watch the video).

If islamic scholarship is measured in the way sheikhs talk... then there is a huge problem. Check the islamic databases on scholarship and do a statistics on how many papers/books on islam he has published; Publish it here and then we can argue

Lamagoodle wrote:

Advo wrote:Disgusting how our scholars are insulted and dragged through the mud by forces of duunya. They hate the message but only attack the messenger.

Ilaahay protect the culima

Scholar? where did you get that from? He is a demagogue (af minshaar), a wahabi entrepreneur, a lackey and a pathological liar ( watch the video).

If islamic scholarship is measured in the way sheikhs talk... then there is a huge problem. Check the islamic databases on scholarship and do a statistics on how many papers/books on islam he has published; Publish it here and then we can argue

Somalis are notorious charlatans always feeding off the women.