Father Kills Infidel Daughter: Was He Justified?

[FAH1223]

[quote="hyperactive"]lol Fah
we are hanafi they whole country's official madhab is hanafi.
wah iska tukado ma arkin.
accually not different than shafi'i other than they pray less that shafi'i
in taraweeh.
my father said in his father's mosque in moqadisho they used to pray 21 rakah traweek qwith nafla and witir is 23.
here we pray only 8 traweek and 2 nafla and one witir all together is 11
so if he is hanafi he should pray less.lol[/quote]

my xabashi friend whos Sha'ific is always shocked at what this guy is saying

"50 rakat a DAY?"

Subxanallah, he was telling me about it yesterday

i was like...."yeah, cool, mashallah, ect, ect"

[gurey25]

if your daughter refuses to wear the hijab or become a slut
its the fathers fault.
its is he who has brought her to a kaafor country,
he is the one that did not intill the values in his daughter.


now why did he kill her?

ill tell you that it has nothing to do with Islam at all.
its all a matter of pride, he was concerned about what the other men will say about him, and "dishonour" him.

Islam is just a convenient excuse.


i hope he sucks diks in prison,

[Diblomaasi]

What a tragedy.

The animal justifies killing his daughter because she wasn't wearing hijab. If this is true then he should return to Pakistan and go on a killing spree.

If you've ever been to Pakistan you'd know that the only time a pakistani woman covers her hair is when she hears the aadaan and then removes the cover immediately after the aadaan.

I have never came across a group of muslims more ignorant of Islam than south asian muslims (from Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, etc.).

The man probably got the idea of killing his daughter from his backward culture. These people have the most brutal and savage practices for dealing with women. They have honorary killing in which a woman is killed by her closest relative (mostly father or brother) if she is believed to have in some way tarnished the honor of the family (mostly by talking to some guy her father doesn't approve of).

Wallaahi I wouldn't be surprised if it turns out that he killed her because she refused to have sex with him. Punjabis have an age-old tradition of f-king their daughters and sisters.

If what this man wanted was for his daughter to follow the tenets of Islam, then he should do the same and go to an Islamic country and have the sharia courts deal with him.

[El Loco]

Nice to see the large majority here are hammering this moron. Maybe there is hope for muslims after all.

[Diblomaasi]

Megatron,

The topic of this thread and the poll are both an insult to Islam.

1. Not wearing a hijab does not make one an infidel
2. The actions of this man cannot in anyway be justified under Islam.

[Diblomaasi]

[quote="El Loco"]Nice to see the large majority here are hammering this moron. Maybe there is hope for muslims after all.[/quote]

What are your ilk doing in a Somali-Islamic forum?

I believe there's an opening at LGF this morning. You may finally get hold of your much sought-after account and leave this forum once and for all.

[biko]

[quote="Niya"]Megatron, what is your definition of infidel?

The father took her life NOT because of love of Islam BUT to save face in his community. It all about appearances, and not substance.[/quote]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


ecxactly!

[Megatron]

First: Addressing the thread topic title. Was it inflammatory ? Yes. But it got people reading, and encouraged healthy debate, which was my intention. Mission accomplished.

Now, to MAD MAC and others. This is what you get when you have an uneducated goat farmer enacting his own interpretation of Islam, combined with his instilled bacward cultural practices. Nothing to do with Muslims, or Islam.

[DANGIRL]

What can possibly justify this father of murdering his daughter and especially when the person is your own flesh and blood??..Hoestly,I believe the motivation behind the girl murder was not his religious conviction,but more of his cultural norm.

[biko]

the reason he killed his daughter aint got nothing to do with Islam, the same way circumcising somali girls aint Islamic.

[Algebra]

The title was misleadin, I though the girl left the Islam.

[Skippa]

Masha'Allah Fah & Hyperactive....I'm very proud of these two young ones!!!

[muktaar]

when you away from home for more than 10 hours working
and ur daughter is watchin BET and MTV
dont be surprise if u come home one day and find a 35 yr dreadlocked adoon on the top of your sweet inncent muslim gurl
its the price that comes with the freedom in the western atmsphere

[El Loco]

"dont be surprise if u come home one day and find a 35 yr dreadlocked adoon on the top of your sweet inncent muslim gurl"

This is focking hillarious............... Sweet Jesus, I am still laughing over the imagery.