SomaliNet Forums

SMH. There's nothing to argue about.

First it was the marriage of Aisha, then it was about a goat eating the Quran and now its about the sun.Do you actually think I am going to sit and answer one hadith after another that you decide to bring forth?

I'm not going to reward your insincerity here, now run along.

You're mixing apples and oranges, the part dealing with prophets marriage with Aisha was about morality, the other parts were about contradictions in the sources that stipulate death for adultery/homosexuality which arose from the first debate.

Its clear that the second hadith is in the Sahih Muslim, so it doesn't really matter:
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that it had been revealed in the Holy Qur'an that ten clear sucklings make the marriage unlawful, then it was abrogated (and substituted) by five sucklings and Allah's apostle (may peace be upon him) died and it was before that time (found) in the Holy Qur'an (and recited by the Muslims). [34 Muslim, II, No. 3421.]

There is no such verse in the Quran, and you can give any excuse that you want, but it would mean that parts of the Quran is not there.

Obvious contradictions in Sahih hadith and atleast a grave scientific error, are you going to respond to this

Arabman

Memo: How to stray Muslims
Status: To be kept classified

-Identify as a deist, as it's a neutral designation (compared to atheist, Christian, Jewish, etc).

-Don't directly attack the prophet, instead go indirectly or make indirect links. For instance, repeat over and over "50 years old" and "6 years old", until it settles in the victim's subconscious.

-Don't attack the Quran, instead go for Hadith. Study the works of anti-Hadithists like Rashad Khalifa or the Quran-aloners. Attack incessantly, until it settles in the victim's subconscious as a residual doubt.

Where did you find that?

Sahih Al-Bukhari Hadith 7.592 Narrated by Abu Huraira
I heard Allah's Messenger (saws) saying, "There is healing in black cumin for all diseases except death."

Really?

Should people who think that these sahih hadith that are full of contradictions and errors should be the basis for whose to live and whose to die, use black cumin when they get sick instead of modern medicin alot of which is based on evolutionary medicine .
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolutionary_medicine

About black cumin been good for the human body and curs all desease actually first it come from ancient greeks.forexample thousend years before birth of prophet muhamed scw in ancient Greek well known physician which had name of Dioscorides used black cumin seeds to treat headaches and toothaches.. Black kumin mentioned in the Bible as well. so black kumin is something all ancient civilazations belived to be good for the human body.

you obviously crave this attention. your questions have already been answered a dozen times in this thread alone but you keep bringing up the same issues. i'm sorry no one can help you, now please phuck off.

edit yalaxaow this guy just clownin, using "evolutionary medicine" in 632AD kulaha, retard

DR-YALAXOOW wrote:About black cumin been good for the human body and curs all desease actually first it come from ancient greeks.forexample thousend years before birth of prophet muhamed scw in ancient Greek well known physician which had name of Dioscorides used black cumin seeds to treat headaches and toothaches.. Black kumin mentioned in the Bible as well. so black kumin is something all ancient civilazations belived to be good for the human body.

What's your point?

wolverine wrote:

the other parts were about contradictions in the sources that stipulate death for adultery/homosexuality which arose from the first debate.

Its clear that the second hadith is in the Sahih Muslim, so it doesn't really matter:
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that it had been revealed in the Holy Qur'an that ten clear sucklings make the marriage unlawful, then it was abrogated (and substituted) by five sucklings and Allah's apostle (may peace be upon him) died and it was before that time (found) in the Holy Qur'an (and recited by the Muslims). [34 Muslim, II, No. 3421.]

so this hadiith it means Quran we have today is not complete, according this hadith there are revealed verses from heaven which was lost before it made it the Quran we know today. hmm interesting:shock:

Sunni muslims accuse shias muslims that shias believe that there are missing verses in the quran while some Sunni muslims themselfs call a sahiih . a hadiiths which cliames there was a Lost verses in the quran which Goat cuntay

blackstars25 wrote:you obviously crave this attention. your questions have already been answered a dozen times in this thread alone but you keep bringing up the same issues. i'm sorry no one can help you, now please phuck off.

edit yalaxaow this guy just clownin, using "evolutionary medicine" in 632AD kulaha, retard

What point has been answered....do you mean the part in which parts of the quran are not there anymore...that part still stands. Do you mean the obvious contradictions in hadith or unscientific advise in sahih hadith? These hadith that people thrust to tell who deserves to die
give it a rest son...

Keyblade wrote: What's your point?

my point is we are living 21 century and not 7th century we know lot of things today which people in 7th century did not knew.

wolverine wrote: What point has been answered....do you mean the part in which parts of the quran are not there anymore...that part still stands. Do you mean the obvious contradictions in hadith or unscientific advise in sahih hadith? These hadith that people thrust to tell who deserves to die
give it a rest son...

lmao you need to give it rest. your silly questions have been generously and eloquently answered by salaxow but you refuse to accept them because you are seeking nothing but capitulation from us, which you will not get.

Wolverine is a deist. Can't be surprised at all. But Yalaxoow, WTF is Dr. yalaxoow? What's this nigger's belief?

^just call him an atheist, don't let him fool you with technical jargon. Dr.Yalaxoow is muslim, i see nothing wrong with what he said.

it's time to drop 'The Banhammer' on murtad wolverine. He started respectfully enough however he is now simply trolling and desperately seeking attention whilst looking like a headless chicken.

Mods do your damn job.

eliteSomali

Wolverine is a deist. Can't be surprised at all. But Yalaxoow, WTF is Dr. yalaxoow? What's this nigger's belief?

Can't be suprised about what?