
Kudos to the group !!!!
Rightwing,
Last I heard only HJ were

Moderator: Moderators
Once again, the SEMG felt compelled to mention in their report that a high volume of tax exemptions were granted by the PM. Regardless of the legality of the tax exemptions, the UN monitoring group for Somalia seems to imply something dodgy was occurring. As for innocent until proven guilty, you seem to be under the impression that this report is some sort of indictment, when it merely seeks to analyze the mismanagement of funds. The SEMG reports to the UN Security Council, not to any judicial body that would indict these folks.mody21 wrote: That is exactly my point there is nothing inherently illigal or dodgy about tax exemption many minister ask for organizations they work with be tax exempt, so to mention with no proof of extraordinary actions beyond request for tax exemption only undermines them, if they furnished proof that these tax exemption were to cronies or were being used inappropriately it would be another thing. so far all I hear from you is, oh they think its dodgy so it must be , in the normal world its innocent until proven guilty, and the fact of mention doesn't constitute guilt.
They are the group doing the investigating. If they say they have obtained evidence, then we have to take their claim at face value. The monitoring group is an impartial, independent body that reports only to the UN, unless you're saying there's some sort of conspiracy at work.mody21 wrote:There is actually no evidence that they furnish backing this claim, its merely them saying "we have obtained evidence that this happened" were is this evidence exactly?
Did you?mody21 wrote:did you actually read the whole article?
the articles states that during faarmajos tenure as a Pm 15 million were donated by the AUE, but that abdiweli who was working under faarmaajo at that time claimed only 10 million was received, and that of that 10 million 3.5 million was mismanaged by Pm faarmaajo, the money was not the responsibility of abdiweli as it was not donated during his term , it was the responsibility of farmaajo, abdiweli is actually defending faarmajo in a way when he says only ten million was donated, but that 3.5 of the ten million was mismanaged, notice he never made a claim about corruption. There is Absolutely nothing in this report that incriminates abdiweli. Thats the simple truth if you wanna argue for the sake of argument we can do that to.
There is actually nothing in the report that says there were high volumes of tax exemption, it only states that the PM requested tax exemption for certian companies he claimed were working with the TGF, there is actually absolutely nothing and I mean nothing dodgy about that what so ever, its like saying the president of the united states had a metting with the vice president and writing that in a report that alleges corruption, in a way it make gullible people like you who have their on agendas try to make that something wrong or worthy of suspicion when in fact that is in the job description of most public services workers. This is one of the things that made me suspicious about this report, which is at this point a "leak" (which in the wistleblower community is a another word for unreliable). If you want to claim abdiweli is in the wrong because he did something that was completely within his work field but that seemed "dodgy" then by all means.Based wrote: Once again, the SEMG felt compelled to mention in their report that a high volume of tax exemptions were granted by the PM. Regardless of the legality of the tax exemptions, the UN monitoring group for Somalia seems to imply something dodgy was occurring. As for innocent until proven guilty, you seem to be under the impression that this report is some sort of indictment, when it merely seeks to analyze the mismanagement of funds. The SEMG reports to the UN Security Council, not to any judicial body that would indict these folks.
I am not saying that there is some sort of conspiracy at work I am just saying I will not pass judgement based on hear say which is what this report is so far.There is no substantial evidence to back it up, what so ever. You on the other hand are attempting to accuse abdiweli who is so far the smallest fish in the pond, based on so called evidence that is not in the report? and your only come back is "well if they say they have it they must have it" does that make any sense?, if I go and accuse sharif of being a thief, and say "I have evidence trust me" is that enough to warrant any legitimacy?.Based wrote: They are the group doing the investigating. If they say they have obtained evidence, then we have to take their claim at face value. The monitoring group is an impartial, independent body that reports only to the UN, unless you're saying there's some sort of conspiracy at work.
Based wrote: Did you?
From the report:
"The MoFIN, for example, records a contribution from the UAE as US$15,000,000;
The Monitoring Group has confirmed that the UAE donated US$10,000,000 to the Farmaajo administration and US$5,000,000 to the Abdiweli administration.27
28. Lastly, TFG PM Abdiweli Ali informed the SEMG that the US$15 million from the UAE had been wrongly reported. He noted that in 2011 the Farmaajo Administration had received US$10,000,000 from the UAE, but only deposited US$6,500,000 to the Central Bank, and that his administration had received US$5,000,000, which was entirely deposited into the Central Bank account.28 The SEMG could not reach the Central Bank to confirm these claims and the Prime Minister could not understand why his Ministry of Finance had reported a higher amount than that registered by the Central Bank of Somalia."
10 mil was given to Farmaajo's admin, and 5 mil to Abdiweli's hence the 15 mil the Ministry of Finance reported. Abdiweli claimed 3.5 of the 10 Farmaajo receieved was missing, but the monitoring group could not verify the claims made by Abdiweli.
As for nothing implicates Abdiweli in this report, refer to my second point.
in which part of what you said is abdiweli incriminated in anything?, abdiweli claimed that 10mill was received from the UAE during faarmaajo tenure, but that 3.5mill was misappropriated, he also stated that the 5mill that his administration received was deposited completely into the central bank?, from what I read so far, the accused is not abdiweli but faarmaajo, and the fact of this "monitoring group" not being able to confirm this only shows incompetence and bad reporting on their part, if they claim to have "confidential" diplomatic channels, yet cannot confirm a single deposit to the central bank what legitimacy do they have? as for faarmajo if he has nothing to hide he would come out and defend himself just as abdiweli did.He noted that in 2011 the Farmaajo Administration had received US$10,000,000 from the UAE, but only deposited US$6,500,000 to the Central Bank, and that his administration had received US$5,000,000, which was entirely deposited into the Central Bank account. The SEMG could not reach the Central Bank to confirm these claims