13 year old boy kills his father.. Should he be killed?

[Alchemist]

Wiil 13 jir ah ayaa maanta abihiis ku toogtay meel u dhaw magaalada Kismaayo, isagoo sadex xabadood madax uga dhuftay, waxaana hooyada dhashay wiilka oo hada umul ah ay ku talisay in wiilkana la toogto.

Hobyonet. Muqdisho Axad, feb. 24, 2008

Tuulo lagu magacaabo Cabdi Biiro ayaa waxaa maanta ka dhacay shil aad u yaab badan ka dib markii wiil da'adiisa lagu sheegay 13 jir uu abihiis sadex xabadood madaxa uga dhuftay isagoo abahana halkii uu ku naf baxay.

Wiilkan yar ayaa la sheegay in ay caruur yaryar ka soo dacwoodeen,markaas oo uu abaaha wiilka dhalay uu garacaay wiilkiisii,intaas ka dib ayuu cunugii raadsaday qori uu guriga ku ogaa si uu caruurta uga aarsado dhiibki gaaray wuxuuna kor u riday xabado .

Markaas ka dib waxaa maqlay aabihii oo u soo cararay inuu ka qabto balse wiilkii ayaa kula soo jeestay oo sadex xabadood madaxa kala helay.dad ka agdhawaa goobta ayaa qabtay wiilkii isagoo hada lagu hayo saldhiga.

Wiilkan ayaa waxa uu u weynaa 11 caruur ah oo ay walaal yihiin iyadoo hooyadii dhashana ay hada umul ku jirto ,hooyada ayaa la sheegay inay ka naxday falkan wiilkeeda uu geystay waxayna ku talisay in loo qasqaaso .

Dhacdadan ayaa waxaa hada lala sugayaa aabaha dhalay marxuumka dhintay oo lagu magacaabi jiray Cabdi Guure kaasoo go'aan ka gaaraya sida lagu dhameynayo arinkan yaabka leh.

Maslah Osman

Hobyonet

[The-Screw]

No, the kid is 13 years old. i thought Sharia law applied to those 15 and older, wiilka waa in la iska cafio, he needs a mentor. kids break when frusterated, maybe his father was abusive. who knows, bottom line, killing the kid will not bring his father back and it will not improve the situation.

[Alchemist]

A rough translation..

Couple of boys from the neighborhood complain to the boys father about him.. The father gives the 13 year old boy a light beating, the boy gets his gun and shoots the father 3 times in the head, the father dies..

The boy is the oldest of 11 and his mother is pregnant with her 12 child.. Now the mothe is saying the boy should be killed for his crime..

Some of the saddest crimes happen in Somalia walahi.. Now who will provide for the family?

How will that young boy live with himself.

But is the boy old enough according to islamic sharia which is 15 by most opinions?

Discuss

[HELWAA]

That what happens when parents abuse their kids...The children become violent and the result is this.

Inaalilaah waa arin naxdin badan walaahi...killing the son will not bring the father back, when he realize what he is done and that 12 children is without a father....that is enough punishment for him.

[xaseey]

Hooyada xaq miyey u leedahay in ay amarto qisaasta wiilka yar,,,

and i dont believe in jirto hooyo dhaheysa wiilkayga hala dilo

[Alchemist]

Ok lets not be so quick to accuse the father of being abusive here because we dont know the facts..

Also lets remember it is the father who has just been killed by receiving 3 bullets to the head..

I personally dont think the boy should be punished though because he is too young and killing his own father is a enough of a punishment..

[Boqor__Daarod]

the boy should be checked wether he reached his puberty or not. if he did then it is up to the family to decide to forgive him or kill him.

[Basra-]

Alchemist thanks for translating, otherwise u know i would never even dared respond. looool


Well, before we get into the 'child abuse' arguement..... lets get back to the style of execution.Three bullets in the head??? Geez, that is just too much hate: 1:2:3!!!! Bang! Bang! Bang! Wow!

i thought kids from somalia grow up with a sense of parents respect and daqaan?? Caudubillahi. Well, this is the effects of anarchy of current Somalia situation now-- so basically it doesn't matter if u raise kids in somalia or the west. If u raise them in the west-- they turn to be unrespectful,gaalo, selfish, spoil brat, useless hedonists, holigaans! If they are raised in somalia, they are little moryaasn thugs, unrespectful,homicidal maniacs! So we have to find a place/middle ground here for kids to be raised: Timbuktu. :)

[Alchemist]

Basra lol Timbuktu...


Your welcome...


Darood, i agree..

[Hyperactive]

not expert the justice system
balse 13 is too young for qisas
even if they leave him
he is dead man walking.
it'll be dificult to live with himself
i don't think he will mentally healthy.

[Muktaaar]

xelwa

aint nothing wrong with beating kids
as child my father use to beat the xaar out of me
kids need to fear someone or they will misbehave 4 sure


as 4 the article
as the screw said
the kid is not 15 yet
so he shouldnt face the ultimate punishment which is death

[Somaliweyn Commando]

he should be lashed 10 times with a wire

3 times a day for 4 years straight

[Alchemist]

[quote="Somaliweyn Commando"]he should be lashed 10 times with a wire

3 times a day for 4 years straight[/quote]

lool great ruling..

[Sir-Luggoyo]

Subxaana-Allah,

Walle we are a cursed nation, as Basra said, there is no scape except Timbuktu. Shooting him would not do any good for anyone, but what surprised me most is the mother who is advocating for his death. The b!tch is only concerned for the man who was digging her, she can't close her legs and that is why she has 13 children whose oldest is 13, the b!tch was popping out every year and her major concern is lack of a d!ck, belo hoosta kaa gashay

[gobdoon]

If the mather did not agree him to be hunged I would say know but know mum wants him dead he should be killed after all she is his mather,and she must know what a monister he is and if he is not put down now he might do something worse in the future he already claimed the life of his father,but don't only blame,blame the whloe country that shows you how bad the situation is there,13 years old getting acces to a deadly weapon,We are all cursed and is the reflection of the whole society.