A Genuine Question....

[Koronto91]

When "TFG" supporters read or hear about news that Ethiopians got killed or have lost the control of a city in Somalia, do they feel saddened by this? I am curious to know, so any "TFG" supporter out there, tell us what you feel?

[Murax]

I weep all night for their deaths.

[Koronto91]

I weep all night for their deaths.

Jadiidis don't count!

[Murax]

I weep all night for their deaths.

Jadiidis don't count!

[Adan*5]

they do,cause they know the more ethiopian soldiers kiled,the near is the sword comming towards them.waa murtadiin is nacay,

[Murax]

^^

Who's murtadiin? TFG supporters? What gave You the authority to say that?



Self righteous former USC supporters turned "wadaads" are wreaking havoc nowdays.

[Monk-of-Mogadishu]

When it comes to government soldiers dying, I really don't care. But when Ethiopians die, it just means that Somalia is one step closer to anarchy.

Like Murax said, many of us do weep. I mean, I weep for any dead human, but Ethiopians in Somalia are putting their lives on the line, without even pay, just to give Somalis some security. Its gut-wrenching to see them hurt, let alone killed.

May allah make their road safer, most of them in Somalia are Muslim.

[AhlulbaytSoldier]

Everytime when the ethiopians get killed,my wife makes cakes.But here is the funny part: we didnt listen to news.

[Boqor__Daarod]

When "TFG" supporters read or hear about news that Ethiopians got killed or have lost the control of a city in Somalia, do they feel saddened by this? I am curious to know, so any "TFG" supporter out there, tell us what you feel?

they weep so bitterly and so much you would swear that the oceans were flowing from there eyes

[Adan*5]

war it's national sport to kill ethopian soldiers in somalia nowadys,there goes hardly no day without it

[Adan*5]

^^

Who's murtadiin? TFG supporters? What gave You the authority to say that?



Self righteous former USC supporters turned "wadaads" are wreaking havoc nowdays.

we supported the Kacaan too

[The-Screw]

where are those bloody mods!

[Murax]

[quote="Adan*5"we supported the Kacaan too [/quote]



Listen, I don't give a flying you know what about the TFG and everybody knows that. This is a matter of principle deen wise. You cannot use the TFG as a criterion for Kuffr and use the ICU as a criteria for Iman like many simpletons who just discovered the Religion in 2006 do. You cannot call TFG supporters kaffirs period. This is a matter of Takfir and its very serious.

[Adan*5]

[quote="Adan*5"we supported the Kacaan too

Listen, I don't give a flying you know what about the TFG and everybody knows that. This is a matter of principle deen wise. You cannot use the TFG as a criterion for Kuffr and use the ICU as a criteria for Iman like many simpletons who just discovered the Religion in 2006 do. You cannot call TFG supporters kaffirs period. This is a matter of Takfir and its very serious.[/quote]

sxb ,I agree with you.things are more complicated than just use ICU and TFG to measure in good and bad.that would be unblanced due to the unjustice that has been done in the past 16 years in somalia.

but look rather at the over all picture,the main player behind all this.The Tigray abysynninan empire that has a long tradition which is built on strong hatred ,envy,greed and animosity aganist somalis ,as well as any Islamic principals especially in the east africa...What catagory will you put on those that serve that kinda epmire or ideology????

read Meles zenawi interview with the tImes..where he states,that the Islamic movemnets in Somalia had an agenda to create a calipahte in the whole East-africa sentered in Somalia.
its clearly he is palying on fear,,selling his lies to suspecious Western powers, to reach his goals.

[Murax]

Adan, I understand Your points. If the question is are people who are in the TFG committing a major sin along the lines of Zinnah, alchohol, gambling etc.? Yes they are. Are they murtadiin though? That can only be determined on a case by case basis where the culema will look into the Person's case and find out why He did what He did and then they'll pronounce whether He's a kaffir or not.