Page 1 of 1

Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 2:20 pm
by ciyaal_warta
i took this subject called Islamic philosophy as an elective subject man...the whole class is bout debating some current issues the hardest question was when the lecturer asked us: the scientist that clown animals claimed to be GOD since they can create animals or may be human beings they said there aint no difference between them and GOD since they can create too..so whats the difference between those atheist scientist creations and the Almighty ALLAH sw creations ?

the answer must be logic with no religious text ..u got to think logically whats the difference ?

it took us three classes to answer it..am askin s.netters watz the difference ?

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 2:40 pm
by abdisamad3
Those scienctist are only re-planting what Allah created already..they cant just start from the scratches and create something out of nothing..

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 2:49 pm
by surrender
tell us one thing these scientist have created so far?.

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 2:50 pm
by ciyaal_warta
abdisamad3 wrote:Those scienctist are only re-planting what Allah created already..they cant just start from the scratches and create something out of nothing..

perfect man :clap: :clap: ....thats the same answer we come up after a long debate


those Scients create something out of something ..but ALLAH subhanahu 3aza wajala creates somthing out of nothing ... :up:

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 2:52 pm
by ciyaal_warta
surrender wrote:tell us one thing these scientist have created so far?.

i watched a video not long time ago..some clowned sheep u can search it online sis

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 2:58 pm
by surrender
yh but they didnt created that out of nothing, they used what was already there, a life form that got has created, and altered it here and there! thats not what creating is!

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:06 pm
by American-Suufi
i thought i will read a well constructed philosophical thesis.

is this how teach in malaysia? already children know this.

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:07 pm
by ciyaal_warta
surrender wrote:yh but they didnt created that out of nothing, they used what was already there, a life form that got has created, and altered it here and there! thats not what creating is!

thats their claim ..they claimed that they can create so in order to show them they jus used something alrdy ALLAH sw created we have to answer 'em in a logic way....coz these atheist dont care bout religious text and dala'il ..so we had to debate the issue in da class...it took us three classes to come up wif the perfect answer which is( ALLAH sw creates something out of nothing..while those scientist create something out of something)

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:09 pm
by ciyaal_warta
American-Suufi wrote:i thought i will read a well constructed philosophical thesis.

is this how teach in malaysia? already children know this.

loool waryaa i thaught u went bk to xamarweyne learning the new philosophy of the shushumow .... nah bro its question raised in the class but we debate any current issues...marka bk to u i heard alshabab lookin for ur xamar cadcad arse man?

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:11 pm
by American-Suufi
ciyaal_warta wrote:
American-Suufi wrote:i thought i will read a well constructed philosophical thesis.

is this how teach in malaysia? already children know this.

loool waryaa i thaught u went bk to xamarweyne learning the new philosophy of the shushumow .... nah bro its question raised in the class but we debate any current issues...marka bk to u i heard alshabab lookin for ur xamar cadcad arse man?
:lol: :lol:

i wanna become a thorn in alshabab's throat. i will volunteer to fight them alone and be like superman.

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:30 pm
by abdisamad3
ciyaal_warta wrote:
abdisamad3 wrote:Those scienctist are only re-planting what Allah created already..they cant just start from the scratches and create something out of nothing..

perfect man :clap: :clap: ....thats the same answer we come up after a long debate


those Scients create something out of something ..but ALLAH subhanahu 3aza wajala creates somthing out of nothing ... :up:
masha-allah brother..you see we think alike..allahu akbar.. :clap: :clap: :up:

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:34 pm
by ciyaal_warta
abdisamad3 wrote:
ciyaal_warta wrote:
abdisamad3 wrote:Those scienctist are only re-planting what Allah created already..they cant just start from the scratches and create something out of nothing..

perfect man :clap: :clap: ....thats the same answer we come up after a long debate


those Scients create something out of something ..but ALLAH subhanahu 3aza wajala creates somthing out of nothing ... :up:
masha-allah brother..you see we think alike..allahu akbar.. :clap: :clap: :up:

mashaALLAH bro..sometimes we have to think logic thats the whole point coz some pple wont understand daliil or hadith and quran u have to explain it in logic way use the signs of ALLAH in this universe..mashallah bro..jazakaALLAH kheyr man :up:

American Suufi

man they hit xamarweyne wif mortars man .... its time for u to start the superman fight man... :clap: :clap: bring ur shushumow and bajiye and massacre them man :mrgreen:

Re: Islamic Philosophy Debate

Posted: Fri Jul 31, 2009 3:39 pm
by abdisamad3
perfect man :clap: :clap: ....thats the same answer we come up after a long debate


those Scients create something out of something ..but ALLAH subhanahu 3aza wajala creates somthing out of nothing ... :up:
masha-allah brother..you see we think alike..allahu akbar.. :clap: :clap: :up:[/quote]


mashaALLAH bro..sometimes we have to think logic thats the whole point coz some pple wont understand daliil or hadith and quran u have to explain it in logic way use the signs of ALLAH in this universe..mashallah bro..jazakaALLAH kheyr man :up:
[/quote]

True bro..i've had many discussions with the atheist..so I always try to give them a logical explanation.. :up: