What is your opinion on Secession?

[Cumar-Labasuul]

This is a serious question directed at the sane members on this website, I want to know what are your opinions on secession in particular somaliland? I know that the vast majority are against it but I would like to know the reasons. Look at Somalia we have been in war for two decades now and the main reason is that we don't know how share a country and more importantly is that we have no respect for each other. Me personally it would of been great to have a united country of all our lands, but our problem is that we can't stand each other. I believe that there was a time when we could of all been united under the somali flag, but that time has now passed.
Allah says love for your brother, what you love for yourself, so the best I can do is make du'ah that somalia becomes free from chaos. But as for being one country well I believe that we cannot share a country so why should you force your brother something he doesn't want.

[michael_ital]

Of COURSE secession is necessary AND inevitable. After all, can you blame Isaaq for wanting to distance themselves from the dysfunction of xamaar?

[The Nomad]

I believe it is an empty pipe dream, but it is irrational to expect those who have instituted a functioning government and have a semblance of peace to put their own needs behind those of people who will never see calm unless it is instituted forcefully (ICU, Shabab).

As for the foreigner above who believes it is 'inevitable' I'd advise him to pick up a law book and study cases similar to S/Land. It will never happen. They will remain unrecognized.

[Hyperactive]

honestly i dont care.
and not of my business to have a say about it.
wont chnage any thing in my daily life. so why care?

somali o idil wallh inan shaqo iga galin.
only i feel sorry for the poor women , kids and old people who suffering in civil war. that's all.

[The_Emperior5]

I think it’s the best thing we ever did took back our independence
1960 was wrong
Trying to create a Somali empire beyond colonial borders , we wasted our energy
So this is the best thing and Somaliland’s independence is sacred

[Crazy Cat Lady]

It would set a dangerous precedent around the world, imagine every tiny group slighted by the central govt demanding secession! If Somaliland is recognized I give up on life.

[michael_ital]

As for the foreigner above who believes it is 'inevitable' I'd advise him to pick up a law book and study cases similar to S/Land. It will never happen. They will remain unrecognized.

Gimme a fuckin' break here pal. We're talking world politics, not Federal case law or criminal codes. But perhaps you can enlighten with some of this case law to which you refer.

[Cumar-Labasuul]

It would set a dangerous precedent around the world, imagine every tiny group slighted by the central govt demanding secession!

Why can't we be like North Korea and South Korea or Serbia and Montenegro?

[abdikarim86]

when this TFG fails

couldn't landers at least try
to be interested in the next
peace process

[The_Emperior5]

when this TFG fails

couldn't landers at least try
to be interested in the next
peace process

Lool the next tfg will faill to
we showed the world wrong intay dunnidu xammar ku mashquushantahay,, the worls is asking whats wrong with xammer , bal adba

[Crazy Cat Lady]

It would set a dangerous precedent around the world, imagine every tiny group slighted by the central govt demanding secession!

Why can't we be like North Korea and South Korea or Serbia and Montenegro?

Maybe not North and South Korea... maybe like the UK (devolution)?

[Somaliman50]

when this TFG fails

couldn't landers at least try
to be interested in the next
peace process

smartest lander here

[michael_ital]

It would set a dangerous precedent around the world, imagine every tiny group slighted by the central govt demanding secession! If Somaliland is recognized I give up on life.

@ "tiny group"


BTW, will you choose pills or razor blade?

[Captain24]

It would set a dangerous precedent around the world, imagine every tiny group slighted by the central govt demanding secession! If Somaliland is recognized I give up on life.

Nice to see you are a dooro. I always though you were a Lander

[Ms.Erudite]

It would set a dangerous precedent around the world, imagine every tiny group slighted by the central govt demanding secession! If Somaliland is recognized I give up on life.

Why would it be dangerous?