Can this be an excuse to murder?

[Lord Diplock]

A man suffering from impotency caused by failing health finds his wife and her lover in bed, in the ensuing argument between himself and his wife, she humiliate him by calling him 'hopeless in bed' and etc. The angry man then strangles his wife and is then charged with first degree murder and he avails himself with his own of defence of 'I was humiliated and I lost it'

If you were a juror in this case, what would have been your reaction? guilty or not guilty?

The facts of the case is that simple.

[Skippa]

not guilty...of first degree murder, there's no premeditation...
manslaughter perhaps

[LobsterUnit]

lifelong community service at a viagra processing factory.

[Lord Diplock]

not guilty...of first degree murder, there's no premeditation...
manslaughter perhaps

Skippa, with first degree murder THERE is always intention or predetermination. that is why it is much serious offense than manslaughter.

[Skippa]

I got you bro...I'm saying there no premeditation in this case...

[Ms.Erudite]

Unfortunately it can be..provocation is still a defence.

[Lord Diplock]

Unfortunately it can be..provocation is still a defence.

Unfortunately provacation is not a defence in murder, self defence is. interestly battered women have this difficulty i,e if they kill their spouse after a long period of abuse.

[Ms.Erudite]

In the Uk it is...along with diminished responsibility

[TrophY-WifeY-]

Not guilty


Act of Passion

[Shonuff]

guilty.........for being blind to the fact that his wife had a lover. Also there is no excuse for murder in Islam so the motherfocker should be fried but she should be stoned to death for adultery too.

[black velvet]

At the end of the day the woman is dead and he is the one who killed her. That makes him guilty and although anyone can sympathise with his situation there's no excuse for killing someone especially not because they hurt your feelings.

[Advo]

I dont think her words called for murder, he shouldve just threw acid on that bytch's face and let live.

his madhale and she's disfigured.

[Shonuff]

lol.

[HELWAA]

Guilty!...He should just walked away...now he is behind bars...bal muxuu faaiday.

[S-D-M]

Dude killing is not that hard.........just make sure you can tell yourself....only yourself it was worthy..... People kill each other over simple conversation or over mijin qaad ah.