Aji iyo Madhibaan Myth

[caburiye1]

I don't know if any of you believe in this myth but it does not make sense. It goes something like, Nin ladhoho aji iyo nin ladhoho madhibaan baa safar aaday( from where to where is unknown). Gaajo ayaa qabatay markaas ayay neef baqtiyay hilibkiis cuneeen ( which is acceptable in Islam if you have to save your Life). Markii ay tageen meel cunto leh, Aji ayaa iska matajiyay madhibaana maiska matajin( In islaam, it does not command you to force yourself to throw up after you have eaten dead meat to save your life).

1) Who exactly was this madhibaan guy travelling with? darood, hawiye, Dir etc). No tribe admits their awoowe was the one in the journey. Which proofs no one was in that journey.
2) From where to where were they traveling and how related were they?
3) If Islam does allow eating dead meat to save your life and does not command you to force yourself to throw up, What crime has the madhiban guy committed to deserve such million years punishment?
4) Since so many somalis ate baqti during the war and there is no proof that they vomited, Can we not intermarry with their tribe?

Nothing of this shit makes sense.

[caburiye1]

This even is not sheeko. It is called Sheeko xariir just like dhegdheer iyo Juudaanka habeenkii soodhaca.

[grandpakhalif]

midgan people were marginalized because they resisted accepting islam while other clans did.

[Based]

[caburiye1]

midgan people were marginalized because they resisted accepting islam while other clans did.

What Proof do you have that they resisted Islam? I have never heard of that. So what if they resisted. They are Muslims like anyone else. Why punish them now then? Quraish took arms and fought the prophet. When they became Muslims, they were welcomed. Cumar was the worst before Islam.

[caburiye1]

It seems like Most of you do not want to engage in this debate because maybe you condoning the practice.

[Khalid Ali]

They are tumaalo out cast of the society we also have other Yibros who refused to accept islam in 12th century but they were forced they are also Yahud by origin,today they are untouchables.

[kambuli]

This is clearly the most stupid myth that one will ever hear Nin baa iska matajiyey, nina waa iska deystey What a load of bull-sh't
The sad part is we see all the time an idiot (fuqa cirka u taagay) who is good for nothing except shaxaad and saying anigu laandheere ayaan ahay while the hard working brother who is either shoemaker,welder, barbar etc is called midgaan or tumaal

We all are responsible for the supression of these innocent people and we all paid..Cuqabdoodii...We all need to ask their forgiveness wallaahay..

[Conqueror]

They are tumaalo out cast of the society we also have other Yibros who refused to accept islam in 12th century but they were forced they are also Yahud by origin,today they are untouchables.

Khalid, adigu horta soo madan ahen Yibir? Nin Samaroon ah aya ba berri hore wuxu nugu yidhi, magaca "Isaaq" ama "Isaxaq" mahaa magaac Arabi ah o waa magaac yahudeed. Maxa ka jira sheekadas?

[Khalid Ali]

They are tumaalo out cast of the society we also have other Yibros who refused to accept islam in 12th century but they were forced they are also Yahud by origin,today they are untouchables.

Khalid, adigu horta soo madan ahen Yibir? Nin Samaroon ah aya ba berri hore wuxu nugu yidhi, magaca "Isaaq" ama "Isaxaq" mahaa magaac Arabi ah o waa magaac yahudeed. Maxa ka jira sheekadas?

Waxasi wa iska sheeko Huuhaa Isxaaq wa magac nabi Isxaaq ibn Ibrahim maha Yahuud wa magacyodi reer Bani Israel sida Yusuf Suleyman daud Ciise etc, wa magacyo nabi Carab badan ba la baxa ma taqana ninki siirada nabiga so ururiiye Ibn isxaaq ba la odhan jiray.

[eliteSomali]

I've heard the story. The two guys were said to be brothers of the same dad and mom. They went on a journey and after a few days, their supplies(food n water) came to an end. This forced them to improvise. They saw a dead cow and ate it. But after arriving at a little town: one threw up and the other did not. The on who didn't was given the 'midgaan' name. It became an stigma. This is a common somali sheeko, I doubt it really happened tho.