waar ninkan maxuu ka hadalayaa?

[X.Playa]

https://youtu.be/Q3c6hykS6Z4

[X.Playa]

https://youtu.be/_PndzG3Y19g

Khalid Ali how did this story ended, the dhulos were complaining about the gadhweyn welcoming the sacad muuse pilgrim to the shrine saying since they own the area it should have been them doing the invitations, while the gadhweyn argued it always have been their land.

[hangool79]

just give the facts is this Jiidali or Midhisho, I dont wanna watch the video,

[X.Playa]

Its jidali.

[hangool79]

Its jidali.

biggest mistake HY did back in the nineties was allowing those nalaaye ahmed dhulos to come back to Sanaag.

[JSLHistorian]

We actually kicked them out from many areas. 20 years ago you could find many Dhulos in Dararweyne, Bohol, Bancade etc now you
won't see any. We have also planted Gadhweyn and constructed new villages in eastern Sanaag such as as Dhoob, Dhuur Madare,
Laas Qacable, Dumar Gaduudshe and many more.

[Maroodijex]

I agree with the odeyga hore. I never heard of Ali Sheekh Isaxaaq. And the only time I have ever heard about Shariifo is recently.

Also, another myth that is recently heard is Habar Habuusho being a princess. Ahahaha Habuusho was Magaado's servant.

It happens in the world today that even Kings marry their servants, case in point Saudi King who married his Habesha servant who had King Fahad.

[Xildiiid]

^
The whole sheikh Isxaaq saga is a myth.

[X.Playa]

^
The whole sheikh Isxaaq saga is a myth.

prove it, you need a rigours argument cant just make statement like that, life isn't that simple.

[Khalid Ali]

^
The whole sheikh Isxaaq saga is a myth.

How is it a myth people act as if Sheikh isxaaq dates back 4000 bc like the ancient Egyptians

Sheikh isxaaq is around 800 to 900 years ago

are u telling as the man sheikh isxaaq never existed and we made him up

[Xildiiid]

The burden of proof is not on me, it's on people who believe in this fairy tale.

They have to proof the link between this man and his so called descendants without using the regurgitated and invalid oral 'history'. A similar case would be the non existing link between the modern day Jews and the ancient Jews of the Bible.

[Khalid Ali]

Do u believe there is a link between u and ur ancestor Salamadow or is that also a myth ?

[LiquidHYDROGEN]

^
The whole sheikh Isxaaq saga is a myth.

prove it, you need a rigours argument cant just make statement like that, life isn't that simple.

How do you reconcile your hatred of Arabs with your belief in this myth. It is a myth. Somalis are homogenous to the horn of Africa. No ethnic Somali descends from an Arab sheikh on a magic flying carpet. Whether Isaaq existed however is another question.

[X.Playa]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZhEBh5msgc
he did , and he did his research well. unlike you sitting on your butt and just making silly unqualified statement . I have listened to his lecture and he qualified his long research and cited first account of people who came to Mait and met sheikh isxaaq and quoted their manuscript. and let see your argument with sources contradicting him.

[Xildiiid]

Do u believe there is a link between u and ur ancestor Salamadow or is that also a myth ?

First of all, I do not have an ancestor called 'Solomadow'. It's allegedly a matrilineal alliance between 3 brothers. Can I prove that they existed? The answer is no..

Do I believe they existed? The anwer is no, it's probably a myth.

However the Isaaq clan and all its sub clans and sub sub clans are a social and political reality that one simply can't ignore.

Labadaa kala saara..

X.Playa,

There's no link whatsoever, between the man in question and his living 'descendants'.