The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Dedicated for Somaliland politics and affairs.

Moderator: Moderators

User avatar
AwRastaale
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 7612
Joined: Mon Nov 30, 2015 5:09 am

The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by AwRastaale »

Image

In the next map, I predict there will be major population shift if the ongoing droughts continue to push people to the brink of survival. I predict more displaced people, more urbanization and people as far as Haud in Ethiopia will cross the border into Somaliland to settle in small and major towns.

If the drought lasts for another 5 months, we will see a shift from nomadic or pastoralism lifestyle to urbanisation. We may see an increase in agriculture as people try to find a solution to the ever reoccuring shortages.

We will see major shift in prices of food and shortages in what was Somali traditional proteins; camel, goat, sheep and beef.

We should be able to recover in the next five to ten years. I am anticipating more nomads to settle in cities and send their kids to schools. Initially it will be difficult and there will be surge in poverty and displacement but eventually we will recover. The next major famine will not have as much impact because hopefully by then we will have more city dwellers than nomads seeking employment in other sectors.

Do not be concern about shortages in protein. I believe it will recover too but it will not be the industry that you once knew. We may see the first baby steps by entrepreneurs and investors to form what could possibly become the first small-medium commercial farming in Somaliland. I expect more people to buy huge sets of land to prepare for both agriculture and livestock commercial farming. Shortages will always be there irregardless because human wants are unlimited whereas supply and the process of producing their needs are limited.

In the 1940s and 50s we saw the shift from natural and makeshift reservoirs (natural catchments, bali) to people building berkado/man-made reservoirs similar to pools and the sinking of wells.

Image

Today we entered the era of dams.

We will see the rise of major dams similar to that of Humboweyne and initially estimates state Somaliland could host as many as 150 medium-to-large dams that can store over 200m cubic metres of water per year.

Image

Unlike balis, berkado and wells, which were once under the ownership of individuals and tribal interests, dams will become national assets. When people entrust these limited resources under the state, we will see the merger of medium to large firms either partnerships or proprietary companies. They will be the only ones capable of competing with the state for these resources and in our free market, people will always seek an alternative option.

For example if today the 10 largest livestock exporters merged and pitched to set up a multi-million dollar dam in Dacar-Budhuq to grow such and such, you bet they will most likely get the go ahead.

The more people we remove from pastoralism, the more resilient will be for the next major drought given that we have a window of opportunity of no less than 10 years.

People who left miyi ten years ago are not suffering as much as those who remained today.

The opportunity cost to this is that it could rain tomorrow for the next decade without a single drought and those who remained could see their animals increase by ten fold if not more.

Image
Likely migration

Image
seasonal rivers to be dammed in the future and land to be flooded

In the ongoing changes in SL, there will be short term winners and losers. I see drought hit hard regions such as Sanaag, Sool, Togdheer and Hawd (Ethiopia) as negatively impacted regions whereas we will see positive gains from Berbera to Tog-Wajale along the Berbera-corridor road...give or take anything above or below that channel.

We will see lots of cashflow in this area not only from traders, truck industry boom, restaurants, hotels but it will become hot real estate. The cash exchange will keep things moving.

Because of the positive impact by the port, Hargeisa will cope well with the influx of displaced people from Hawd, parts of Togdheer and surroundings.

Berbera will have or see little impact as it is far from most epic centers and nomads cannot go from camel herders to fishermen or deckhands overnight.

Wajale will see little impact as people in this region already transitioned from nomadism to semi-agriculturalist. Even they have proven that camels who remain on specific site become more resilient than those forced to chase every cloud and drop of rain across vast lands. They burn more calories and by the time they get to the new site pasture and water may have already dwindled.

Sanaag, Sool and parts of Togdheer will struggle the most.

I recommend the government to pursue more dams like that of Humboweyne especially in Awdal, south of Hargeisa, Aw Barkhadle, Dhacar-budhuq, Gacan Libaax, Sheikh, Daadmadheedh and the Togdheer seasonal river or Nugaal Valley.

I would like to see the government fence off an area of at least 5km sq of land for livestock (especially goats and sheep) pilot project with on site water source and alternating grassing/feeding grounds. The animals raised here could also contribute to future droughts by donating 5-10 goats/sheep per person (people who lost everything). It is also good security for what supposed to be Somaliland's main cash earner. Gradual transition and diversification are must but abandoning all together is unacceptable.




The Ras, observing things.
Waachis
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 2584
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2016 7:20 pm

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by Waachis »

Well said brother. The transition from nomadic lifestyle to settled agriculture will definitely be difficult initially, but well-worth the struggle in the end. You should have your own blog or something, so we can read these things in a more organized way, if you get what I mean.
User avatar
AwRastaale
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 7612
Joined: Mon Nov 30, 2015 5:09 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by AwRastaale »

Waachis wrote: Sat Mar 11, 2017 10:09 pm Well said brother. The transition from nomadic lifestyle to settled agriculture will definitely be difficult initially, but well-worth the struggle in the end. You should have your own blog or something, so we can read these things in a more organized way, if you get what I mean.
I think different forms of transition has been underway in Somaliland and Hawd for some time now. For example there are less people willing to invest in camels. There is still demand for camel milk but the cost associated with camels are much higher and export is not that attractive (fluctuates a lot).

For example from 2009-2014, the growth in camel export was only 6 percent compared to 14 percent growth in the exports of sheep/goats.

The difference in terms of monetary is camels brought in roughly $50m while goats/sheep generated $250m.

At the local market you need at least a dozen sheep/goats to get what you could get for one camel or roughly two cattle (Borana breed).

However, it is far cheaper to breed sheep/goat than camels as is the case with cattle too (half the cost of camels).

Sheep/goat milk is not popular amongst Somali population other than using for cheese or in tea. Cow milk is not popular but it is becoming more alternative day by day.

Camel milk is still the ultimate king but producing enough is never enough.

More people are moving to the cities and those going the opposite a small so called Diaspora entrepreneurs who want to test new methods but they themselves are not full time nomads but in a managed environment. These will be the people I predict will seek solution(s) for these droughts. They will be the ones who will take the risks and bet on better days tomorrow. I can see them overcoming and helping recover lost livestock and in the process bringing about better water harnessing methods.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LSopyg7tl54

I hate blogs.
User avatar
sahal80
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 21186
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2012 1:49 pm

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by sahal80 »

AwRastaale wrote: Sun Mar 12, 2017 3:12 am
Waachis wrote: Sat Mar 11, 2017 10:09 pm Well said brother. The transition from nomadic lifestyle to settled agriculture will definitely be difficult initially, but well-worth the struggle in the end. You should have your own blog or something, so we can read these things in a more organized way, if you get what I mean.
I think different forms of transition has been underway in Somaliland and Hawd for some time now. For example there are less people willing to invest in camels. There is still demand for camel milk but the cost associated with camels are much higher and export is not that attractive (fluctuates a lot).

For example from 2009-2014, the growth in camel export was only 6 percent compared to 14 percent growth in the exports of sheep/goats.

The difference in terms of monetary is camels brought in roughly $50m while goats/sheep generated $250m.

At the local market you need at least a dozen sheep/goats to get what you could get for one camel or roughly two cattle (Borana breed).

However, it is far cheaper to breed sheep/goat than camels as is the case with cattle too (half the cost of camels).

Sheep/goat milk is not popular amongst Somali population other than using for cheese or in tea. Cow milk is not popular but it is becoming more alternative day by day.

Camel milk is still the ultimate king but producing enough is never enough.

More people are moving to the cities and those going the opposite a small so called Diaspora entrepreneurs who want to test new methods but they themselves are not full time nomads but in a managed environment. These will be the people I predict will seek solution(s) for these droughts. They will be the ones who will take the risks and bet on better days tomorrow. I can see them overcoming and helping recover lost livestock and in the process bringing about better water harnessing methods.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LSopyg7tl54

I hate blogs.
:up:
User avatar
X.Playa
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 17317
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2002 7:00 pm
Location: Canada,Hawd

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by X.Playa »

You sound like a make up artist who is telling a dead woman how beautiful the postmortem lipstic would look on her.

Kid this is a national catastrophe 85% out of total 18 million animals have gone thats lost in the billions. 90% of the nomads are finished. Billions of wealth gone.

And you are happy beacuse why? These poor once rich independent proud people will flock to the cities to chew qaad beg and talk shit in hargaysaand Burco coffeehouses further increasing the unemployment of the masses.

Its a fucken catastrophe and you are telling us we will eat cake in the future :meles:
soomaali1987
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:48 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by soomaali1987 »

What a load of bullshit propaganda....what are you issaaq retards been smoking?
Maamulkiinna waa meel abaar ah and there is always water shortage and poor people and you think people will afford crops cultivated with expencive water?? Without subsides commercial farming is affordable to the people in west...yet you idiots assume the poor issaaq reer miyi can buy the most expensive food on earth.
i love when one issaaq brings expensive western solution all other issaaq diaspora agreed with him.
there is an issaaq idiot who is trying to spin delaying your election as positive thing.

get it trough your thick skull you are somali with all the shitty qualities(clansm and corruption) that are making of somalis everywhere.
soomaali1987
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:48 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by soomaali1987 »

X-playa those reer miyi will start startup urban farms on the roof top of hargeysa skyline and start producing modern art while they wait for rain.
soomaali1987
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:48 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by soomaali1987 »

We will see lots of cashflow in this area not only from traders, truck industry boom, restaurants, hotels but it will become hot real estate. The cash exchange will keep things moving.

Because of the positive impact by the port, Hargeisa will cope well with the influx of displaced people from Hawd, parts of Togdheer and surroundings????

Pass the joint bro...or are on meth?
Are you a kid or adult?
No adult person of any understanding of somalia affairs cannot produce that text.
User avatar
X.Playa
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 17317
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2002 7:00 pm
Location: Canada,Hawd

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by X.Playa »

^^^^ stop trolling hooyadaa isaaq wasaye. The draught is affecting the entire horn of Africa adna isaaq isaaq baad la shir imanaysaa iyo nacaybka xaafadiihina. Fucken jaahil.
soomaali1987
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:48 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by soomaali1987 »

Dont get skittish my issaaq friend...you so called landers are very active in forum....spreading lies and fantasyland propaganda...there must be balance...i have arrived to call on your bullshit.
Fact is you are as fucked as rest of our people so come to table as somali spread soomaalino and stop this secessionist propaganda. :som:
User avatar
balwarama
SomaliNet Heavyweight
SomaliNet Heavyweight
Posts: 1780
Joined: Tue Aug 04, 2015 7:50 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by balwarama »

The whole DP take over thing, is an Emirati attempt to get back at Djibouti, after they were kicked out of there, in favor of a chinese company. The economic benefits are insignificant at best and none existent at worst. You see, these Khaleeji Arabs have women mentality. If they feel wronged, they will stop at nothing to bring you down. Look what happened to Gaddafi. He once insulted a Saudi sheikh
CaliQaseV2
SomaliNetizen
SomaliNetizen
Posts: 354
Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2016 1:14 pm

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by CaliQaseV2 »

AwRastaale wrote: Sat Mar 11, 2017 8:19 pm Image

In the next map, I predict there will be major population shift if the ongoing droughts continue to push people to the brink of survival. I predict more displaced people, more urbanization and people as far as Haud in Ethiopia will cross the border into Somaliland to settle in small and major towns.

If the drought lasts for another 5 months, we will see a shift from nomadic or pastoralism lifestyle to urbanisation. We may see an increase in agriculture as people try to find a solution to the ever reoccuring shortages.

We will see major shift in prices of food and shortages in what was Somali traditional proteins; camel, goat, sheep and beef.

We should be able to recover in the next five to ten years. I am anticipating more nomads to settle in cities and send their kids to schools. Initially it will be difficult and there will be surge in poverty and displacement but eventually we will recover. The next major famine will not have as much impact because hopefully by then we will have more city dwellers than nomads seeking employment in other sectors.

Do not be concern about shortages in protein. I believe it will recover too but it will not be the industry that you once knew. We may see the first baby steps by entrepreneurs and investors to form what could possibly become the first small-medium commercial farming in Somaliland. I expect more people to buy huge sets of land to prepare for both agriculture and livestock commercial farming. Shortages will always be there irregardless because human wants are unlimited whereas supply and the process of producing their needs are limited.

In the 1940s and 50s we saw the shift from natural and makeshift reservoirs (natural catchments, bali) to people building berkado/man-made reservoirs similar to pools and the sinking of wells.

Image

Today we entered the era of dams.

We will see the rise of major dams similar to that of Humboweyne and initially estimates state Somaliland could host as many as 150 medium-to-large dams that can store over 200m cubic metres of water per year.

Image

Unlike balis, berkado and wells, which were once under the ownership of individuals and tribal interests, dams will become national assets. When people entrust these limited resources under the state, we will see the merger of medium to large firms either partnerships or proprietary companies. They will be the only ones capable of competing with the state for these resources and in our free market, people will always seek an alternative option.

For example if today the 10 largest livestock exporters merged and pitched to set up a multi-million dollar dam in Dacar-Budhuq to grow such and such, you bet they will most likely get the go ahead.

The more people we remove from pastoralism, the more resilient will be for the next major drought given that we have a window of opportunity of no less than 10 years.

People who left miyi ten years ago are not suffering as much as those who remained today.

The opportunity cost to this is that it could rain tomorrow for the next decade without a single drought and those who remained could see their animals increase by ten fold if not more.

Image
Likely migration

Image
seasonal rivers to be dammed in the future and land to be flooded

In the ongoing changes in SL, there will be short term winners and losers. I see drought hit hard regions such as Sanaag, Sool, Togdheer and Hawd (Ethiopia) as negatively impacted regions whereas we will see positive gains from Berbera to Tog-Wajale along the Berbera-corridor road...give or take anything above or below that channel.

We will see lots of cashflow in this area not only from traders, truck industry boom, restaurants, hotels but it will become hot real estate. The cash exchange will keep things moving.

Because of the positive impact by the port, Hargeisa will cope well with the influx of displaced people from Hawd, parts of Togdheer and surroundings.

Berbera will have or see little impact as it is far from most epic centers and nomads cannot go from camel herders to fishermen or deckhands overnight.

Wajale will see little impact as people in this region already transitioned from nomadism to semi-agriculturalist. Even they have proven that camels who remain on specific site become more resilient than those forced to chase every cloud and drop of rain across vast lands. They burn more calories and by the time they get to the new site pasture and water may have already dwindled.

Sanaag, Sool and parts of Togdheer will struggle the most.

I recommend the government to pursue more dams like that of Humboweyne especially in Awdal, south of Hargeisa, Aw Barkhadle, Dhacar-budhuq, Gacan Libaax, Sheikh, Daadmadheedh and the Togdheer seasonal river or Nugaal Valley.

I would like to see the government fence off an area of at least 5km sq of land for livestock (especially goats and sheep) pilot project with on site water source and alternating grassing/feeding grounds. The animals raised here could also contribute to future droughts by donating 5-10 goats/sheep per person (people who lost everything). It is also good security for what supposed to be Somaliland's main cash earner. Gradual transition and diversification are must but abandoning all together is unacceptable.




The Ras, observing things.
Hawdian, can you scale this work to Soomaaliweyn level? How does these migration shifts might affect the other four territories?
So far you mentioned migrations between Hawd (Isaaq) territories and SL; what about the others?

Is it likely that nomads will migrate to cities and towns of different clans?

Thanks
User avatar
X.Playa
SomaliNet Super
SomaliNet Super
Posts: 17317
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2002 7:00 pm
Location: Canada,Hawd

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by X.Playa »

soomaali1987 wrote: Sun Mar 12, 2017 8:54 am Dont get skittish my issaaq friend...you so called landers are very active in forum....spreading lies and fantasyland propaganda...there must be balance...i have arrived to call on your bullshit.
Fact is you are as fucked as rest of our people so come to table as somali spread soomaalino and stop this secessionist propaganda. :som:
SL is here to stay wether you shit ir fart. Keep your blue thong up your stinking ass .
soomaali1987
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:48 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by soomaali1987 »

How come if you are independent there are somaliland seats in somali parliament?
I feel like half of isaaq wants federal state and other ictiraaf...soon you may have maamul gobol waqooyi civil war.
after all clan poiitics divides the people to sub sub clan.
soomaali1987
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 3:48 am

Re: The Institute: Drought impact on shifting livelihoods

Post by soomaali1987 »

I think your flag looks stupid you wannabe arab...what is grand purpose of your flag? The aspiration behind of it?
Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Return to “Politics - Somaliland”