How did Somalia become a failed state.

[Khalid Ali]

[gobdoon]

We are in this together believe it concerns and effects every Somali person on earth, any one who thinks it doesn't his village or Qabiil family is stupid, short sighted and naive
Somalia never functioned as a modern nation, despite of that our people are resilient, independent, proud and tough people whom failure doesn't come to their vocabulary

[paperino]

He gathered infos & pics from Google and reads (eye movements) from the teleprompter. Nothing interesting, just someone trying to earn a few bucks.

[SunFromNorth]

We became failed because the SNM waged gurilla attacks on our national army you can thank your Sacad Muuse oncels

[Khalid Ali]

That govt had to be destroyed because the somalis deserved much and much better.

Paperino I think James is well learnd on diplomacy and international relations and history. He is quiet accurate in all his statements. I think this is a hobby for him I doubt he does it for money and views. If it makes a few buck so be it. But it's a hobby for him.

[paperino]

Paperino I think James is well learnd on diplomacy and international relations and history. He is quiet accurate in all his statements. I think this is a hobby for him I doubt he does it for money and views. If it makes a few buck so be it. But it's a hobby for him.

After making the video, James probably doesn't remember 10% of what he read from the teleprompter or the infos he gathered from Google. I think you were easily impressed 'cause he's cadaan.

[Khalid Ali]

Ofcourse he studies it. White people have weird hobbies. Allot of Europeans study Africans and their culture politics it's not something new really. He is right on almost evething really.

[paperino]

He is right on almost evething really.

It's to you.

[Khalid Ali]

Tell me which statement he made that is wrong misinterpreted or even a fat lie. Tell me.

[paperino]

Tell me which statement he made that is wrong misinterpreted or even a fat lie. Tell me.

Among his many errors:

* He claims Somalia's area is 250k sq mi (it's 246,201 sq mi), and also failed to subtract SL's area
* He claims ethnic Somalis make up over 85% of the population, a dubious claim
* He claims only 90% of Somalis are Muslims
* He claims the late Mohamed Farah Aidid was the #1 & most notorious warlord
* After the Black Hawk incidence, he ignored for obvious reason to mention the US killed 10k or more civilians
* He failed to mention at all the dumping of toxic waste in Somalia by his cadaan brethren, at the same time babbling about piracy & pirates
* He claims Yemen is worse than Somalia, yet the latter exemplifies 'Failed State', a contradiction
* He ignored to mention other failed states that are worse than Somalia, like south Sudan
* And many more

[SunFromNorth]

That govt had to be destroyed because the somalis deserved much and much better.

Paperino I think James is well learnd on diplomacy and international relations and history. He is quiet accurate in all his statements. I think this is a hobby for him I doubt he does it for money and views. If it makes a few buck so be it. But it's a hobby for him.

Lool yeah we really deserved it that is why we have been a failed shithole for 30 years

[Khalid Ali]

Tell me which statement he made that is wrong misinterpreted or even a fat lie. Tell me.

Among his many errors:

* He claims Somalia's area is 250k sq mi (it's 246,201 sq mi), and also failed to subtract SL's area
* He claims ethnic Somalis make up over 85% of the population, a dubious claim
* He claims only 90% of Somalis are Muslims
* He claims the late Mohamed Farah Aidid was the #1 & most notorious warlord
* After the Black Hawk incidence, he ignored for obvious reason to mention the US killed 10k or more civilians
* He failed to mention at all the dumping of toxic waste in Somalia by his cadaan brethren, at the same time babbling about piracy & pirates
* He claims Yemen is worse than Somalia, yet the latter exemplifies 'Failed State', a contradiction
* He ignored to mention other failed states that are worse than Somalia, like south Sudan
* And many more

Somaliland isn't part of Somalia so he is right there technically

It is true 85 percent of ethnic somalia nationals are 85 percent all agencies agree with that

Wasn't aideed the number one who was number one according to you

There is no way us killed 10000 people where do u get that number out of your buttbole

He didn't have to mention that at all.

How's that a contradition both yemen and Somalia are failed states. Yemen has allot of death toll yemen is only at a different stage. It is where Somalia was in the 1990s

South Sudan isn't worse then Somalia. Second he didn't have to. Mentioned this since the video is about Somalia

[paperino]

Somaliland isn't part of Somalia so he is right there technically

Your grasp of math is poor:
246,201 sq mi (Old Somalia) - 68,000 sq mi (SL) = 178,201 sq mi (Somalia)
Basically, you & James denied the existence of SL.

It is true 85 percent of ethnic somalia nationals are 85 percent all agencies agree with that

85% is a statistics decades old, and doesn't reflect today's reality.

Wasn't aideed the number one who was number one according to you

He was/is a hero to millions, including reer Waqooyis.

There is no way us killed 10000 people where do u get that number out of your buttbole

NYT*, former ambassador Robert B. Oakley & other officials mentioned thousands, while Mad Mac mentioned the figure I quoted.

James wouldn't mention horrible things (killing thousands of civilians, dumping toxic waste, etc) his cadaan brethren did to Somalia/Somalis, and that's something to be expected from a biased and qabiilist cadaan.

* https://www.nytimes.com/1993/12/08/worl ... 10000.html