SomaliNet Forums

Gubbet wrote: Wed Oct 05, 2022 3:45 am Generally, I am talking about the shameless confusion being engineered about having disagreed with an "opinion" of mine regarding settlement when really it was a seriously impartial, conflict analysis with detailed, on-the-ground documentation that one attempted to contest although without being aware at first.

Balanbale is emotional for some, as I clearly disclosed, which has partly fed into Balanbale becoming one of the most targeted locations for IDP/humanitarian oriented scams from an entire post-1991 Mogadishu based network from Guriceel-Dhusamareb who attempted to weaponize NGO business to respond to the emotional loss created by the revocation of the 1996 agreement while simulataneously personally enriching themselves.

The modus operandi was always the same, in hindsight; institute 4-6 "jiingad" (tin collapsibles) randomly, "recreate" a narrative appropriating a name relevant to the migratory route of their experience during the 1996 agreement, promptly set the scene for material documentation, temporarily bait Balanbale engineering the creation of "conflict," then disperse.

But of course, one now had a project proposal to go and continue milking the scam even used to monopolize "peace building" and "conflict resolution" line item grants.


What a cohort has been doing using Balanbale provacation is fundamentally egregious, but it is no longer a secret, and it is very well understood concept now.

There are really no "villages" between Balanbale and Guriceel. It is not even like Caabudwaaq where there are villages like Bangeelle even Xananbuuro.

In Balanbale, the "villages" are on the west towards the Marehan grazing grounds in Ethiopia and in Guriceel, the villages are towards the south to Hiiraan and Matabaan area for Cayr. Between Balanbale and Guriceel,there are utilized spaces with water and other features for migratory movements in the past, but no real "villages.


It is merely empty tin collapsible ghost dots for the purposes of the grant scams. This is why even the 3 variations of the UNOCHA maps are incredibly inaccurate.

Furthermore, there are at least 1/4 of a dozen (+-3) recreations of names and identifications purposely engineered for weaponizing conflict resolution to scam humanitarian grants/aid.

There are multiple "Ali Hassan"---multiple "Bali Hawd"---multiple "Odaale."

I will give an example of this disconnect using "Oodaale."

"Oodaale" old is outside Guriceel. What they have reinterpreted as "Oodaale" is called by Marehan in Balanbale as "Gaxandhaale."

It is true that during the experience of the 1996 agreement, Guriceel folks freely passed by Gaxandhaale on their way to Feerfeer route which Rer Balanbale have not used since 1982 and the Ethiopian-SSDF capture of Balanbale in which many Marehan from Balanbale were massacred.

In that migration, seasonally, both going down to Feerfeer and coming back up to Galgaduud, Guriceel nomads would build their temporary ood for rest or emergency, which ever, next to already populated spots and Gaxandhaale was a very convenient location being the settlement with good water access utilized always by the southern facing Rer Balanbale.

Guriceels upcycled "Odaale" to reinterpret "Gaxandhaale" in their subjective memory, but where they immediately decamped next to Gaxandhaale. The area has been a very targeted landscape for the IDP scam where there was recurrent empty "jinged" overnight placement/morning emptiness. It is where Rer Balanbale started to understand what this was all about.

Well, two years ago, Rer Balanbale decided to physically settle in "Gaxandhaale" as a deterrent to the recurrent bait and switch.

For an entire year, last year, there was random attacks on Gaxandhaale; drive by sort of shootings. Even just as weaponized was information; at every turn Guriceel folks redrafted the narrative of "two communities of Balanbale from Gaxandhaale fighting over resources."

I mean really just put "Gaxandhaale" and "Balanbale" into Google and you will get countless hits and propaganda about this repurposed information warfare.

This is Gaxandhaale as of last month; half a year after it was successfully completely seized back from the forces of misinformation after a 2 year campaign to solidify security of the wider perimeter.



It is no longer the useful victim targeted for temporary "jiingad" placements to scam donor conflict resolution/IDP grant schemes, a ghost created for purposed mapping without equities on the ground;---but is now a real building process with brick and morter school and clinic and water well entirely financed by Rer Siyaad Diini of Balanbale and contributions from other Marehan.

Balanbale has had the misfortune of becoming a target of a thrifty scam, but the usefully "unaware" era has come to a close.

The experience of Gaxandhaale speaks for itself after the information warfare of the recent past.

Gubbet wrote: Thu Oct 06, 2022 8:58 am Saddam,

From what some people researching this have told me, the water grants are the 2nd biggest sources of humanitarian scams. In fact, the water grants are always the "facilitator" jump starting the schemes.

Look at the recent clashes at Labogalle.

When groups east of Caabudwaaq district came all the way to Labogalle, a place not even on the fault line or boundary between Caabudwaaq and east of the highway groups (i.e. "Darod/Marehan" & "Hawiye/Habar Gidir) and engineered the stunt of building a "berkad"---the objective was never an intentional, serious proposal that one believed was durable and realistic.

And, in fact, the conclusion to Labogalle was the predictable outcome. Rer Caabudwaaq settled it to their satisfaction---at the cost of engineered conflict.

Why would you do it? You do not settle anywhere near the berkad; it is not even land in dispute. You have no equities in the area, no settlements, no population... essentially no community based "men of arms" to protect your investment---

---and this is central Somalia, particularly inside the territory of Darod/Marehan. The civil war in Somalia can be summarized into a clash between you and the people of Caabudwaaq.

What Labogalle represented was a stunt predicated on facilitating the next scam to bid for the IDP/humanitarian donor grants using the water schemes---and, hmm, let's see; the need for "conflict resolution." Amirite?

At this point, humanitarian/donor grants are implicated in the direct manufacture of conflict and instability unless and until they seriously mitigate their liability to these scams by conflict entrepreneurs.

For an entire year, last year, there was random attacks on Gaxandhaale; drive by sort of shootings. Even just as weaponized was information; at every turn Guriceel folks redrafted the narrative of "two communities of Balanbale from Gaxandhaale fighting over resources."

I mean really just put "Gaxandhaale" and "Balanbale" into Google and you will get countless hits and propaganda about this repurposed information warfare.

This is Gaxandhaale as of last month; half a year after it was successfully completely seized back from the forces of misinformation after a 2 year campaign to solidify security of the wider perimeter.

https://www.hiiraan.com/news/2021/Dec/w ... 179612.htm

Faahfaahino kasoo baxaya dagaal beeleed khasaare geystay oo ka dhacay gobolka Galgaduud

Jimco, December, 10, 2021 (HOL) - Faahfaahino dheeraad ah ayaa kasoo baxaya dagaal beeleed saacadahii lasoo dhaafay ka dhacay deegaanka Kaxandhaale oo ka mid ah deegaanada hoostaga degmada Balanbale ee gobolka Galgaduud.

Dagaalka ayaa la sheegay inuu ahaa mid waqti kooban socday islamarkaana geystay khasaare isugu jira dhimasho iyo dhaawac kala gaaray labada Maleeshiyo Beeleed, kuwaas oo isku adeegsaday hubka noocyadiisa kala duwan.

Ilaa 4 ruux oo isugu jira labada Maleeshiyi beeleed ee dirirtu dhexmartay ayaa la sheegay iney ku dhinteen dagaalka dhacay, waxaana sidoo kale lasoo warinayaa dhaawacyo gaaraya ilaa 10 ruux, kuwaas oo la kala geeyay xarumo caafimaad oo ku kala yaala degmooyinka Guriceel iyo Balanbale ee gobolka Galgaduud.

Dagaalkan ka dhex qarxay markale labadaan Maleeshiyo beeleed ayaa ah mid salka ku haayo arimo la xariira dilal iyo aanoyin qabiil oo haray u dhexmaray labada dhinac.

Wararkii ugu dambeeyay ee saaka ka imaanaya deegaanka uu dagaalka ka dhacay ayaa sheegaya in halkaasi wali laga dareemayo xiisad dagaal, maadama labada ciidan ee Maleeshiyaadka ay wali is horfadhiyaan islamarkaana gurmadyo kala gaareen labada dhinac, waxaana laga cabsi qabaa inuu markale bilaawdo dagaal u dhaxeeya labada Beelood oo haray dhowr jeer oo hore ugu dagaalamay deegaano ka tirsan gobolka Galgaduud.

Jamaal Cali Cabdi, Hiiraan Online
jamaal@hiiraan.com

https://www.caasimada.net/xildhibaan-ma ... galgaduud/

Xildhibaan Mahad Salaad oo la ogaaday inuu hurinayo dagaal beeleedyo ka dhacay Gobolka Galgaduud

By Saalax Saciid Sabriye

January 8, 2018

Muqdisho (Caasimadda Online) – Shalay Gelinkii dambe ayaa waxaa dagaal khasaaro geystay waxa uu duleedka degmada Balanbale ee Gobolka Galgaduud ku dhexmaray laba Beelood oo halkaasi ku wada nool.

Maamulka degmada Balanbale ayaa ayaa faah faahin ka bixiyay dagaalkaas kaas oo sheegay ay ku lug leeyihiin Siyaasiyiin iyo mudane ka tirsan Baarlamaanka Soomaaliya.


Gudoomiyaha deegaanka Balanbale ee Gobolka Galgaduud Jaamac Xeyle Maxamed ayaa Dalsan u sheegay in dagalkaas uu ka dahcay deegaanka Kaxandhaale ee duleedka Balanbale isla markaana uu ku lug leeyahay Xildhibaan Mahad Salaad oo ka mid ah Baarlamaanka Soomaaliya.

Waxa uu sheegay in ay wada dagaalameen dad Reer miyi ah oo xoolo dhaqato ah,isla markaana dadkaas ay dagaalkooda hurinayaan Xildhibaan Mahad Salaad iyo Siyaasiyiin ku sugan Muqdisho.


Dhanka kale xiriir ayaan la sameynay Xildhibaan Mahad Salaad oo lagu eedeeynayo in uu hurinayo dagaalkaas si uu uga jawaabo eedeynta loo jeedinayo balse kama jawaabin taleefoonadeena.

Hoos Ka Dhageyso Codka Guddoomiyaha

Caasimada Online
Xafiiska Muqdisho
Caasimada@live.com

Gubbet wrote: Thu Oct 06, 2022 3:29 am This description of an understanding I developed while in Caabudwaaq district recently seems to have perked interest so let us make it more accessible.

Gubbet wrote: Wed Oct 05, 2022 3:45 am Generally, I am talking about the shameless confusion being engineered about having disagreed with an "opinion" of mine regarding settlement when really it was a seriously impartial, conflict analysis with detailed, on-the-ground documentation that one attempted to contest although without being aware at first.

Balanbale is emotional for some, as I clearly disclosed, which has partly fed into Balanbale becoming one of the most targeted locations for IDP/humanitarian oriented scams from an entire post-1991 Mogadishu based network from Guriceel-Dhusamareb who attempted to weaponize NGO business to respond to the emotional loss created by the revocation of the 1996 agreement while simulataneously personally enriching themselves.

The modus operandi was always the same, in hindsight; institute 4-6 "jiingad" (tin collapsibles) randomly, "recreate" a narrative appropriating a name relevant to the migratory route of their experience during the 1996 agreement, promptly set the scene for material documentation, temporarily bait Balanbale engineering the creation of "conflict," then disperse.

But of course, one now had a project proposal to go and continue milking the scam even used to monopolize "peace building" and "conflict resolution" line item grants.


What a cohort has been doing using Balanbale provacation is fundamentally egregious, but it is no longer a secret, and it is very well understood concept now.

There are really no "villages" between Balanbale and Guriceel. It is not even like Caabudwaaq where there are villages like Bangeelle even Xananbuuro.

In Balanbale, the "villages" are on the west towards the Marehan grazing grounds in Ethiopia and in Guriceel, the villages are towards the south to Hiiraan and Matabaan area for Cayr. Between Balanbale and Guriceel,there are utilized spaces with water and other features for migratory movements in the past, but no real "villages.


It is merely empty tin collapsible ghost dots for the purposes of the grant scams. This is why even the 3 variations of the UNOCHA maps are incredibly inaccurate.

Furthermore, there are at least 1/4 of a dozen (+-3) recreations of names and identifications purposely engineered for weaponizing conflict resolution to scam humanitarian grants/aid.

There are multiple "Ali Hassan"---multiple "Bali Hawd"---multiple "Odaale."

I will give an example of this disconnect using "Oodaale."

"Oodaale" old is outside Guriceel. What they have reinterpreted as "Oodaale" is called by Marehan in Balanbale as "Gaxandhaale."

It is true that during the experience of the 1996 agreement, Guriceel folks freely passed by Gaxandhaale on their way to Feerfeer route which Rer Balanbale have not used since 1982 and the Ethiopian-SSDF capture of Balanbale in which many Marehan from Balanbale were massacred.

In that migration, seasonally, both going down to Feerfeer and coming back up to Galgaduud, Guriceel nomads would build their temporary ood for rest or emergency, which ever, next to already populated spots and Gaxandhaale was a very convenient location being the settlement with good water access utilized always by the southern facing Rer Balanbale.

Guriceels upcycled "Odaale" to reinterpret "Gaxandhaale" in their subjective memory, but where they immediately decamped next to Gaxandhaale. The area has been a very targeted landscape for the IDP scam where there was recurrent empty "jinged" overnight placement/morning emptiness. It is where Rer Balanbale started to understand what this was all about.

Well, two years ago, Rer Balanbale decided to physically settle in "Gaxandhaale" as a deterrent to the recurrent bait and switch.

For an entire year, last year, there was random attacks on Gaxandhaale; drive by sort of shootings. Even just as weaponized was information; at every turn Guriceel folks redrafted the narrative of "two communities of Balanbale from Gaxandhaale fighting over resources."

I mean really just put "Gaxandhaale" and "Balanbale" into Google and you will get countless hits and propaganda about this repurposed information warfare.

This is Gaxandhaale as of last month; half a year after it was successfully completely seized back from the forces of misinformation after a 2 year campaign to solidify security of the wider perimeter.



It is no longer the useful victim targeted for temporary "jiingad" placements to scam donor conflict resolution/IDP grant schemes, a ghost created for purposed mapping without equities on the ground;---but is now a real building process with brick and morter school and clinic and water well entirely financed by Rer Siyaad Diini of Balanbale and contributions from other Marehan.

Balanbale has had the misfortune of becoming a target of a thrifty scam, but the usefully "unaware" era has come to a close.

The experience of Gaxandhaale speaks for itself after the information warfare of the recent past.

Zak77, who is currently on your ignore list, made this post.

Gubbet wrote: Thu Oct 20, 2022 5:10 am

you rename your settlements

This thing with the renaming is a weird and truly baffling strategy that exists with the community east of the road in Mudug and Gagaduud. I was speechless when I was made aware of it in Caabudwaaq recently as I had pointed out in a topic about Balanbale.

Balanbale District especially was targeted with this as I described using Gaxandhaale near Balanbale Town.

All of it designed to erase the "distance." Through co-opting, they are either moved up or the place moved down.

Just couple days ago, this guy Kees posted another of his water well-porn fixations except he claimed his group [east of the highway] were drilling this in "Mircawleed" [in Rer Cabudwaaq territory, west of the highway].

Now normally, I never interact with these social media references because they are a waste of time---but, I enquired about this Mircawleed in which they claimed they were digging a well.

Apparently this "Miro Cawlo" was a recent restyling of "Wad" or Wad Gelinsoor.

And where is Wad?

East of the highway. Nothing to do with actual Mircawleed, west of the highway.